Up Next
Candace Owens Masterfully Confronts Woke College Students Who Challenge Her on Identity Politics and Religious Symbols
8:12
Piers Morgan Reveals His Honest Take on Israel-Palestine After Removing His Journalistic Hat
27:30
Cam Higby Street Interviews Reveal Bipartisan Condemnation of Political Violence Following Assassination
1:16
Cam Higby and Kim Gervais Defend Free Speech and Charlie Kirk's Legacy at Georgia State University Campus Tour
Cam Higby and Kim Gervais traveled to Georgia State University to continue Charlie Kirk's mission of open dialogue on college campuses following his assassination. The event brought together students from across the political spectrum to discuss contentious topics including morality, socialism versus capitalism, transgender policy, gun rights, and civil discourse. Through multiple exchanges with liberal and conservative students alike, Higby and Gervais demonstrated that peaceful disagreement remains possible even in an increasingly polarized America. The discussions touched on the non-aggression principle, military spending, healthcare policy, gender identity, and the circumstances surrounding Kirk's death. Students challenged the speakers on issues from bathroom policies to historical celebrations like Juneteenth, while Higby and Gervais consistently emphasized respect, truth, and the importance of conversation over violence.
Continuing Charlie Kirk's Mission Through Campus Dialogue
Cam Higby and Kim Gervais appeared at Georgia State University as part of a campus tour honoring the late Charlie Kirk, who was assassinated while peacefully engaging with students. The event drew students from diverse political backgrounds, all willing to engage in civil discourse about controversial topics. Higby opened by explaining their mission: to show that Americans can still have conversations and stand before those who disagree without fear of violence.
The speakers emphasized that this tour was planned specifically because Charlie Kirk was killed for his opinions. They wanted to demonstrate that his vision of respectful dialogue could continue despite attempts to silence it through violence. Throughout multiple exchanges, both Higby and Gervais repeatedly thanked students and audience members for their respectfulness, noting that this embodied what Kirk had always preached to his followers.
The Non-Aggression Principle and Moral Foundations
The first substantive discussion centered on moral philosophy when a student holding a sign stating "nobody should be killed for their opinions" engaged with Higby. The student explained his moral framework based on the non-aggression principle, which holds that unjust aggression against another person or their property is fundamentally wrong. Higby probed deeper, asking where this moral compass originated.
The student explained that he views the non-aggression principle as the most consistent moral code, applicable to theft, abortion, murder, and slavery. Higby challenged him on when proactive rather than reactive force becomes justified. The student argued that credible threats of violence or active attacks justify defensive aggression, including defending others. He recounted personally pepper-spraying Antifa militants who were chasing his colleague Katie Daviscourt into traffic in Seattle.
The conversation touched on whether leftists seeking violent revolution could claim just aggression. The student distinguished between rebelling against unjust government oppression and Charlie Kirk's situation. Kirk never hurt anyone, never oppressed anyone, and actively taught his followers to show respect to those who disagreed with them. He was simply sitting behind a table expressing his positions when he was gunned down.
Socialism, Capitalism, and Universal Healthcare Debate
Gervais engaged with a political science student who identified as leaning toward socialism while acknowledging the tragedy of Kirk's death regardless of political affiliation. The student, who is Chinese-American with grandparents who lived through Mao's regime, expressed concerns about government overreach while supporting increased social welfare programs.
Gervais challenged the student on universal healthcare, citing the $4 trillion annual cost estimate before even building necessary infrastructure. He argued that socialists often advocate utopian ideas without calculating realistic costs or considering how to fund education, housing, and healthcare simultaneously. Drawing on his family's experience in the USSR, where his grandfather spent six years in the gulag for spreading religion, Gervais warned that these ideas historically lead to authoritarianism and millions of deaths.
The student countered that he doesn't support complete elimination of private companies or capitalism, positioning himself more as a democratic socialist with one foot in each system. He proposed reducing military spending on unnecessary Pentagon projects to fund social programs rather than raising taxes. Higby agreed that wasteful Pentagon spending exists but noted that budget decisions remain subjective and under executive authority.
Higby emphasized his opposition to excessive military interventionism while defending the necessity of defense spending. The student, identifying as a pacifist who looks up to MLK and Gandhi, expressed hope that change can occur without violence. Both speakers agreed that peace should not be met with violence but maintained that defensive wars like World War II following Pearl Harbor were necessary.
Gender Identity and Transgender Policy Concerns
A student asked why Higby believes a man cannot be a woman. Higby provided his definition: a woman is an adult human female, and female denotes a person capable of creating ova. Since men cannot produce ova, they cannot be adult human females and therefore cannot be women. He compared claiming to be the opposite sex to claiming to be a different race or species.
When asked why this matters to him, Higby stated his loyalty to truth. He argued that the idea that men can become women degrades truth just as claiming he could become a black man or a lizard would. Beyond philosophical concerns, he pointed to policy impacts in bathrooms, sports, and education that affect everyone.
The student questioned what education policies concerned them. Gervais cited Atlanta-area middle schools with books teaching seventh and eighth graders that boys can be girls if they feel like it. He distinguished between affirming transgender identity and providing actual treatment for what he considers a mental illness supported by medical literature.
Higby argued that body dysmorphia is treated differently than other conditions. Society doesn't tell anorexic women they're fat and should stop eating, nor do doctors tell schizophrenic patients that voices in their heads are real. Transgender identity is the only mental illness where people are told their condition is valid and should be fulfilled rather than treated. He cited the healthy body identity disorder, where people want limbs amputated, as an example of a condition society would never affirm.
The Lia Thomas Case and Women's Sports
Higby shared the story of his friend Paula Scanlan, who swam on the University of Pennsylvania team with Lia Thomas. Will Thomas previously swam on the men's team and dated members of the women's team. When Thomas transitioned and joined the women's team, the coach initially promised he would change in the family bathroom. However, Thomas ended up in the women's locker room with full male anatomy.
Higby described the uncomfortable situation where female swimmers, including Thomas's former romantic partners, had to change next to him while wearing extremely tight racing suits that take 20 minutes to remove when wet. The lockers are open shelves right next to each other with no privacy. While Higby didn't suggest Thomas would assault anyone, he emphasized the profound discomfort of the situation.
Gervais added that over two-thirds of Democrats, along with 80% of independents, oppose biological males in women's locker rooms. He noted this is one of the few issues where majorities of both parties agree. The speakers argued this represents common sense that transcends political divisions.
Detransitioners and Long-Term Consequences
Higby spoke about knowing multiple detransitioners from Seattle's dense transgender population. He mentioned someone who lived his entire adult life as a woman, underwent all surgeries, and still appears female despite detransitioning. This person now uses the username "transphobe01" on Twitter, having realized how the experience damaged his life.
Another friend, Ary Salvatore, transitioned and went to Thailand for bottom surgery, only to later regret it. Higby also mentioned Maya Poet, who realized during the October 7th attack in Israel that gender identity didn't matter when bombs fell and she had to choose between grabbing her breast binder or running to bomb shelters.
Gervais cited Mayo Clinic data showing that the eighth year post-surgery represents the highest suicide rate for transgender individuals. He argued this indicates surgery doesn't fix the underlying mental illness. Instead of addressing root causes, affirmation creates lifetime pharmaceutical patients whose prescribed medications may worsen their mental state.
The student suggested that societal rejection causes high suicide rates. Higby and Gervais countered that society has moved toward acceptance, dedicating an entire month to LGBTQ causes. They maintained that lying to people about their condition doesn't help them and that compassion means providing real treatment rather than affirmation.
Charlie Kirk's Controversial Statements
A black female student approached explaining she had no empathy for Charlie Kirk because of hurtful and hateful things he said. Higby responded that he couldn't force anyone to have empathy for Charlie, acknowledging how devastating Kirk's death has been for him and his colleagues. However, he maintained that nobody who was peaceful and killed for their words should be murdered.
The student listed Kirk's statements that offended her: claiming gun deaths are acceptable to uphold the Second Amendment, calling empathy a made-up word, saying the civil rights movement was a mistake, opposing Juneteenth as a holiday, and targeting black people, women, LGBTQ individuals, and immigrants. She also objected to Kirk's position that children born in the United States to immigrants shouldn't automatically receive citizenship.
Higby agreed with celebrating Juneteenth, noting he didn't know the context of Kirk's statement but arguing that Republicans especially should celebrate it since Abraham Lincoln, the first Republican president, freed the slaves. Gervais added that President Trump made Juneteenth a federal holiday in 2019.
On birthright citizenship, Higby expressed full agreement with Kirk's position. He explained that the United States is one of only four countries maintaining jus soli doctrine, where birth on American soil automatically grants citizenship. He argued that almost the entire world has moved away from this policy and that the United States should reconsider it.
The Importance of Respectful Disagreement
Throughout the event, Higby and Gervais repeatedly emphasized their appreciation for respectful dialogue. They thanked students who disagreed with them for approaching the microphone and engaging civilly. Higby noted that discussions serve multiple purposes: provoking thought, teaching and learning, observing different perspectives, and showing people at home that conversations remain possible.
The speakers acknowledged that minds might not change immediately but hoped students would go home and ponder the ideas discussed. They expressed their own willingness to consider opposing viewpoints rather than simply trying to win arguments.
Higby explained that laws ultimately derive from morality, and different people hold different moral frameworks. The necessity of public discourse lies in determining whose morals are most logically consistent and sound. Disagreeing with someone's morals doesn't make them a bad person, just someone who thinks differently. The critical task is figuring out who's actually right through conversation rather than violence.
Living Charlie Kirk's Legacy
The Georgia State University event demonstrated that Charlie Kirk's vision of campus dialogue could continue despite his assassination. Students from across the political spectrum engaged in substantive discussions about morality, economics, gender, rights, and history. While disagreements remained unresolved, the respectful tone validated Kirk's belief that Americans can love those who disagree with them and treat them with dignity.
Higby and Gervais positioned their tour as both memorial and mission. They wanted to show that fear of violence wouldn't silence conservative voices on college campuses. They wanted to honor Kirk's memory by continuing exactly what he was doing when he was killed: inviting opposition to challenge ideas, treating dissenters with respect they often don't receive, and demonstrating that differences of opinion don't justify violence.
The speakers made clear they weren't imposing their views but rather making the case for their positions to the best of their ability. They acknowledged that students who called Kirk a fascist could make that claim, but claims don't equal truth. Someone can call another person racist or fascist, but that doesn't make it so. Political assassination cannot be justified by applying labels to peaceful people expressing opinions.
Video Transcript
All right, you're good. >> So the sign on the right says nobody should be killed >> for their opinions. >> Over their opinions. >> Yes. >> So that is coming from what? Your moral compass. >> Yes. >> Uh what gives you the right to oppose your moral compass on others? >> Yeah. So, um I I'm not saying that I have a right to impose my my moral compass on other people, but what I am doing is making the case for my set of morals to the best of my ability and basically positing them or posing them against you or anybody else who's here. So, my personal belief is that every human individual ought to have the right not to be unjustly aggressed upon. I think that anytime you unjustly aggress upon a person, which would be anytime you touch, harm, or hurt another person or their property without their permission or without a first act of aggression, I think that that is wrong and immoral. So like for example, if I walk up to David and I punch him in the face, that's unjust aggression towards David. If David punches me in the face and I punch him back, that's self-defense. I'm justly aggressing him in response to his unjust regression aggression. And that's that's what guides most of my moral principles. Can I ask you another question? >> Absolutely. >> Where are you getting that moral compass from? Where does that come from? Why do you think that >> it's the right uh the non-aggression principle? That's that's where I I'm not if you're asking if I'm religious or not religious. So, um I I generally have found this principle, the non-aggression principle to be in my opinion the most flawless uh moral code. I think that it plays into uh essentially any situation uh related to morals. Uh stealing. Ste, why is stealing wrong? Well, stealing is wrong because stealing, theft of property is uh unjust aggression. Why is abortion wrong? It's unjust aggression. Why is um murder wrong? Unjust aggression. Why is uh I don't know, can name a crime um is unjust aggression. Why is slavery bad? It's unjust aggression. >> Okay. So, from my understanding, that's a very reactive or passive stance. So when it comes to someone who is the aggressor, you think, and I'm asking, there's no way that you should be proactive in stopping it. Like you can see it, >> if you can see it coming, you shouldn't stop it. >> No, because you cannot predict what other people are going to do. And therefore, you cannot judge them for what you anticipate they're going to do. Unless they're unless it's like this, right? Unless it's like this where I'm like actively going to you can like see I'm swinging on David, right? But if I'm just espousing a belief and you think that belief is dangerous and could potentially lead to violence, you don't have a right to kill that person just because you think eventually the national progression of this ideal will lead to violence. I think leftists the natural progression of their ideals will lead to violence. And that's not just because I think that. It's because they say it. They know that they need a violent revolution in order to institute socialism in the United States. Otherwise, it won't work. The the Marxian view requires a violent revolution in order to institute. So I can't kill those people just because I know that they want violence. >> Okay. So my phone >> so I'm going to take it out of the >> At exactly >> do you have the right to >> stop so right before someone kills him you can tell they're about to kill him. >> Mhm. >> Is that like >> Yeah. It's aggression. So it's like a threat, right? So if I if I swing on David but I miss that's a threat. It's a threat of violence, right? So it's it's unjust aggression. So aggression uh in this sense is not just you know me yelling at David is not aggression in this sense. It would be it would be deemed an aggressive act like in the colloquial sense but uh aggression in this sense means violence or threat of violence. >> Yes. So my my main question sorry is that at what point can you be proactive but you could be the aggressor instead of the reactor in terms of >> the just aggressor. You could be the just aggressor if somebody's threatening. You could be the just aggressor if somebody is uh actively attacking you or uh threatening to attack you in a credible way. >> Like self-defense, right? Like self-defense. You would agree that's just aggression. >> Yeah. So, but if you are protecting someone else, is that considered just aggression? >> Oh, yeah. Sure. For sure. Yeah. If you're if you're protecting somebody else that you're like of But I think I think there has to be a degree of observation like um I've actually done this, right? like one of my colleagues um Katie Davis Court was being chased down by Antifa militants in Seattle and she was chased into an intersection. She's a little um like small woman, right? And I had to pepper spray them to defend her, right? Because I could see the threat against her. She was chased into an intersection, oncoming traffic, etc., etc. I think there has to be a level of observation. I think you have to actually watch something go down physically and then respond in the moment. But what I don't think you can do is like if I punch David right now and then I walk away and then tomorrow David sees me and he shoots me with a gun. He doesn't have the right to, you know what I mean? It's the time has passed. He's no longer under threat. >> Okay. I have another question. >> Absolutely. >> So would it be fair to argue that like you said the liberals, conservatives, they're using violence to incite socialism? Would it be fair to say that that is a type of just progression on their from their perspective? >> Wait, what do you mean? Say say again. >> They're they're using violence to promote socialism like you said, right? >> Uhhuh. >> From their perspective, could that be seen as just aggression? >> Um, no. Because I think it's abstract, right? Again, like you have it's this is self-defense, right? So, you have to um subjectively you could you could we like this what where this rabbit hole will ultimately lead is like whether or not capitalism is bad, which ultimately isn't the argument. I think that's where it would ultimately go. If if somebody I guess if somebody is like actively oppressing other people, if if somebody's actively oppressing people and has them in chains, then I think uh yes, ultimately you can like justly address that institution that's that's oppressing people back. Uh, and I don't want to get into the specific like the moral argument of whether or not capitalism or socialism is good because it's going to lead us down like a long rabbit hole. Um, but yeah, sure, fine. I would say that that's that can that can be a form of just aggression if you rebel against like an unjust government for example. >> So to understand your point of view, what you're saying is it can be said that from their perspective is just aggression, but from your perspective what they're doing is not just aggression. Is that >> Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. I I don't believe that they are acting justly in aggression. So would you say that you guys are just >> well this this is well no I wouldn't say like so for example right here so so generally those like what leftists are trying to rebel against is like the government right because they believe the government is oppressing them right there's a difference between aggressing against an unjust government and trying to prevent oppression and gunning a man down in broad daylight sitting behind a table just like this one because he had a difference of opinion. Charlie Kirk never hurt anybody. Charlie Kirk wasn't oppressing anybody. Charlie Kirk went to college campuses and he invited his opposition to come have conversations with him. He he he like uh taught his followers. He preached to his followers, show the people on this campus the respect that they don't show us. Do not be disrespectful to them. Do not boo them. Do not laugh at them. Do not ridicule them. Show them what we don't get. And there are clips of him doing and saying this. He he loved the people who disagreed with him. He believed that they were God's creation and that everyone should love them. And that's who Charlie Kirk was. And he was gunned down in broad daylight because people didn't like his opinions, not because he was oppressing anybody. >> I want you to look behind you. You see that tall building with a GSU on there? Somebody was sitting at a building like this because people like us sit behind a table like this expressing our positions and was gunned down for that. Right? He's not he's not some political authority. He's not a member of Congress that can enact his positions. he was simply going to campuses and laying out his position in a very civil and tolerant way. So there's no no in my opinion I don't see a way to justify that. Even if you're on the socialist side or communist side and you believe that this is a fascist that is trying to oppress you, there's no justification for it. It seems to me what they wanted to do is end Charlie Kirk's movement because he's a very effective individual. Um, yeah. I mean, there's really no just justification for it. >> So, uh, I hear what you're saying >> and I'm just trying to understand. So you believe that there's no just justification for the killing of Charlie Kirk, >> but the people I'm seeing a lot of rhetoric from the opposite side saying that it was just and your whole argument is just that >> it's greed that's on. >> No, no, you're just listening. >> It's not blown out. >> Just start again. >> Said the one side is justifying the murder. They're justifying it like they have um guess on the conservative liberal >> democratic side like >> conservatives are justified >> sorry liberal not conservative liberally liberal like >> okay like leftly >> yeah on the left side like they are saying that it's a justified killing but you're saying it's not a justified killing. So how can you determine what is just and what is not cuz you said it's about the aggression right? Yeah, I think it's I think it's exactly what I said. Charlie Kirk was not unjustly aggressing anybody. He wasn't harming anybody. And also >> they would argue that he was aggressing through his rhetoric and they said it was like harmful words to harm. >> Yeah. I would say sticks and stones may hurt my bones, but words can never hurt me. Somebody is not unjustly aggressing you. Again, unjust aggression is physical violence because you're they're saying things that you don't like uh or you feel offend people in some emotional way. Um, and I also want to say real quick before you go into your next point, I really appreciate how respectful you're being and I really appreciate how respectful the audience is being and um, this is what it's all about. >> Yeah. >> I just I I also want to say that I understand that they can make the claim that Charlie Kirk is a fascist, but that doesn't make him a fascist, right? You can I can call I can call you racist, right? That doesn't make you racist. So just them calling Charlie Kirk fascist isn't doesn't justify going out and and conducting a political assassination at the end of the day. >> Okay. >> It's arbitrary, right? Like who's deciding that he's actually a fascist? >> That is exactly the point that I'm trying to wrap my head around. Like you said, it's arbitrary. Even the concept of just and unjust, there's a divide. It's arbitrary. So >> I believe it's rooted in actual law, right? >> In law that humans create. >> Yeah. Who and who decides the law? >> Well, that's well, it's a combination of everything. It's common law. It's also based on religious law. So, there's a right like I shouldn't be able to just kill you just because I want to kill you. We used to do that thousands of years ago. I think I think that laws um whe whether I know a lot of people don't like this um but laws are ultimately based on the morals of whoever is writing them and whoever is voting on them. Okay? And so I think what we have to do and exactly what we're doing today is arguing for whose morals are the best morals and whose morals uh basically stand up against everybody else's and are more logically consistent and logically sound and that's what we have to do because ultimately morality dictates law and everybody has a different set of morality and uh or of morals right and so you have to go out and talk to people if you feel that you have the better set of morals you it's not it's not a you know if if I feel I have a better set of morals than you, which I do. It doesn't mean you're a bad person. It doesn't mean you're an immoral person. It just means you think differently than me, and that's totally okay. But it's it's an absolute necessity that we talk about it and figure out who's actually right. Cuz I'm sure you probably think your morals are better than mine. And >> so, I'm trying to summarize your point. So, the um the what's the word? The point, not the point, >> uh but what you're trying to achieve, >> the objective >> objective exactly of this discussion is to come to an understanding. Would you say that's a good summary? >> Yeah. Yeah. I think it's um I think discussions serve a couple different points. Um our I think our main we have we have a couple especially lately we have a couple this this tour is planned because Charlie Kirk is dead. We're we're out here to show people that you can still have discussions and you can still stand in front of people who disagree with you and talk to them without fear of reprisal in some way. Uh another reason is we want to provoke thought. So, even if you walk away with your mind unchanged, we want you to just like go home and ponder it, right? And we're going to go home and ponder what you're saying. We're here to teach. We're here to learn, and we're here to observe. Uh, and I think that's exactly what what Charlie was doing as well. Um, and uh, yeah, and it's also for the people at home. We record it obviously, so everybody can see these conversations and they can think as well. >> Cool, man. You answer my questions. Thank you. >> Hey, I appreciate it. Thanks for coming up and being respectful. >> Thank you so much. >> Hey, man. >> How's it going? >> Good, good, dude. I really appreciate both of you being here. Thank you. >> It's really a pleasure to see you going out and living in Charlie's name, promoting free speech and exchange. >> Come a little closer than Mike. >> Exchange of ideas. I think that what happened to Charlie was really devastating. No matter what side you come from. There we go. >> No matter what side you come from, what you think, he was a father, two beautiful kids, and a wife. >> And I don't think anyone should ever be killed for their ideas. >> Can I ask you a question? >> Yeah, for sure. >> Um Are you a conservative or do you lean more liberal? >> Honestly, I mean, I've never been a huge fan of the political compass because I think it's very categorical. >> Do do you more so like I mean and then this is nothing against you. I just find it um like if you're if you're more like liberal leaning, I find it very interesting and also very >> I would say I'm a modern conservative to be honest honestly in recent events after what happened to Charlie Kirk and I've been following you on Instagram for a while. >> Thanks. I appreciate it. And um if you remember >> you're famous in the south. >> I'm famous. >> Famous in the south. >> Uh if you remember before the day of Charlie Kirk, it was the murder of Arinia. Yes. >> On the bus. Very tragic. >> And I can't help but feel that these are definitely somewhat radicalizing and almost solidifying of my beliefs. >> Yeah. Yeah. And and I I I think I think there's something interesting about both. I think that Ina's death was caused by a failure of Democrats, not leftists, not li I guess Democrats are liberals, but a failure of Democrat politicians specifically in law enforcement. Um, the failure to lock people who need to be locked up up, the failure to keep them in jail. And by the way, I live in Seattle and I get attacked all the time and those people go to jail for a couple hours and then they get released every time. And and and by the way, this has nothing to do with the fact that her attacker was black because all of the people uh who attack me in Seattle and get released two hours later, they're all white. All of them, right? They they all are crazy white leftists and they attack me and they belong in prison, but they don't stay. And so I think that's a failure there. And Democrats have really tried to warp this Charlie Kirk assassination into a thing about gun control. But the fact of the matter is, if you've seen it, the rifle that Charlie Kirk was killed is not a rifle that anyone is trying to ban. It is a bolt-action single fire scoped hunting rifle. Nobody is trying to ban this rifle. In fact, the argument that Democrats always use is you don't need an AR-15 to kill a deer. What do you need? You need a 308 boltaction uh hunting rifle, right? They always say you don't need anything more than that. Well, that's all it took to kill Charlie Kirk. Nobody's trying to ban that gun. Uh, rifles, uh, you're more likely to be struck by lightning in this country than you are to be shot and killed by a rifle. Rifles account for almost, uh, like the smallest portion of gun deaths. Pistols account for the most. I think shotguns might shot Shotguns are either right above rifles or right below. I don't remember. Just look at the universal crime reporting database. Uh, table eight. >> Thanks, man. I appreciate coming up. Have a good >> How's it going, sir? >> I'm doing good. >> Good. >> Is it Is it Is it catching my voice? >> Yeah. Yeah, it's actually good. So, I I know that you're a GSU alumni, right? >> Yes. >> Okay. >> Kind of. Well, I went to GSU. >> Okay. I I'm I'm just a little curious and want to get to know you a little bit more. Uh before we jump into the political discussion, what major are you? >> Political science. >> Interesting. I'm actually poly science myself. >> Very nice. >> Uh pre-law. Uh I'm doing public health as well. >> Great. That's awesome. Political science is great. I think uh >> Oh, yeah. Political science is great. >> Just don't let the professors indoctrinate you. Holds hold to your position >> actually >> or influence you. >> I I get what you're saying, but also I feel like at least this is my experience in college is now I'm pretty sure there are professors out there who will try to skew you one way or the other, but at least with the professor that I have had at GSU, they usually allow for open discussion. Like literally last Thursday in my political science research methodic class, our entire class was just talking about Tory Kirk. He was talking about he he was my professor uh >> my professor was talking about his death and asking us about the morality principle around it. And eventually you got to well eventually he wrapped it up by saying just political violence and murder is just wrong. >> Great. I'm glad that there's professors like that on college universities. Even at Georgia State University, I've had a similar experience whether it's Georgia State University, University of North Georgia, where my professors were balanced, right? I've had people that were objective political discourse, freedom of speech, freedom of expression. They didn't they weren't biased. They weren't grading my papers terribly. But I wish I could tell you that was the case entirely. I took I took a class that was critical race theory. And of course, I'm going to oppose critical race theory. I'm going to deny objectively the various arguments that Kimberly Krenshaw or Carol Anderson will make in their books. But my professor was he accepted that ideology. For him it wasn't a theory anymore. So anybody that opposed that he would ridicule he would allow the class to join to ridicule against those individuals. And that is similar to what we experience conservatives experience when they engage in public uh discourse even in inside a college classroom. So, for example, we've seen Emory professors celebrate, right? Not not saying I hate Charlie Kirk, right? They celebrated his assassination. I don't think those kind of professors should be in the classroom teaching you, teaching me because obviously they have a bias. Now, add another factor in there. They're your political science teacher. Of course, their bias is going to be installed in the classroom. And now, they're going to be ideologically indoctrinating you. Whether you want to call it indoctrination or not, that is the reality of it. Imagine somebody like a completely opposing side of you came in there and did that same exact thing. You would say you're trying to indoctrinate me. >> I get what you're saying. I actually do. And uh >> hey, we agreed. >> Yeah, >> that's it. We're done, right? >> No. Oh, there's a lot I could I could tell you right now there's a lot we would disagree on because politically I'm like the complete opposite of you. Like uh >> and I welcome that. I love that. you you're my favorite type of people to to have a discussion with. >> Seriously, I'm being serious. I don't like an echo chamber. What if I agree with everything or even half of it? If we completely oppose each other, one, we should be able to hold a public discussion without fear of life or anything happening to us. Second of all, that is the that's the principle of America, right? >> True. Yeah. That's that's the principle of America is freedom of speech. And another thing is uh uh another thing is uh yes I was saying I my political views are complete opposite uh like I would describe myself I'm I'm not I wouldn't say I'm a socialist but I'm like borderline like not that far like I'm not that far >> and and do you feel like prior to starting school were you a little bit more moderate is it through your classes you became a little bit more radical and pushed or were you always on this balance between one foot on specialist wants to feel a little bit I guess liberal. Let's call it that. >> Uh honestly, uh I started doing things. Thank you for the support. I appreciate it. Uh I always have read a little bit like high higher level. So I really started doing political well not political research but reading stuff and learning about events. Probably start since starting like 8th grade. >> Oh, good for you. >> Yeah. Uh it's just I'm I'm weird that way. So >> No, that's not weird. That's it. You're ahead of the game. That's what it is. So, I always have actually always been a little bit more on the liberal side. Like even when I was in high school, I was always on a little bit on more on the liberal side. Now, have I gotten more and more towards uh socialism as I move through high school? Yes. >> What attracts you towards socialism? >> Uh the socialism part at least what attracts me is the ability to have people be supported. I feel like a lot of the problems in America could be solved not only allow people access to care but allow them access to jobs and stuff like that. >> Well, I want I just want to counter that real quickly. I am try I can't be more tip of the clock to universal healthare >> simply for the fact that if you're going to institute universal healthcare and give 300 and something million Americans free healthcare overnight some people don't know if they want to do it overnight over a period of years whatever okay well you'll have a bunch of people overnight let's say having free healthcare going to go and line up at all these hospitals and there's going to be a bunch of wait times 8 months 9 months 12 months 16 months here's the other thing okay we can fix that problem with infrastructure so we're going to build the hospitals first all this stuff and then give healthcare. Fine. Then tell me the cost for that. How much does it cost to to make this all happen in the first place? It's about $4 trillion a year just to cover universal healthcare before building the infrastructure everywhere. Right? That's the problem I have with I don't want to call you a socialist, but with socialists, they advocate for these utopian ideas. But they don't even take the second step to calculate how much is it going to cost us. And you're going to say, I know the response. It's like, well, we're going to just tax the rich. At some point you don't have enough taxes to actually pay for all the stuff that you want because it doesn't stop for healthcare, right? And then it goes to education, then it goes to housing. But healthcare is $4 trillion just for the healthcare part of it. That's that's the problem I have with socialism. It's a great idea. Don't get me wrong. Internally, my heart it sounds beautiful, but when but when you put it in practice, it's not realistic. And I'll say this, my parents coming from USSR, these ideas have led to authoritarian figures completely seizing control of any individual freedoms in the state and that's led to millions and millions of people dying. So it actually did the opposite. >> Wasn't your uh didn't your grandfather have to spend time in the goolog? >> Yeah. Can you imagine that? 6 years in the goolog in the in USSR. You may agree with his religious point, right? that he was just spreading religion religion Zionism and uh furthermore um like the USSR a I know I don't know if you're tanky you're probably not but a lot of tankies site like um the USSR and they talk about like the USSR lifted so many people out of poverty they solved homelessness I hear tanks say um the USSR solved homelessness by taking all of the homeless people and putting them in goologs that's how they solved homelessness there was no homeless people anymore because they were all in prison Of course. Of course. And uh I actually do know that I actually I'm Chinese, so I come from well I wasn't born in China. I was born in Hong Kong. >> And um my my grandparents both on both sides of my family went through Ma Dong. >> So I have learned from them how horrible it is. So I understand when you take it too far or when you start I understand your point that socialism could be taken too far to a point where they start seizing all individual freedom >> and that's where is I get that worry and I get that concern and that's why I always think that with socialism is one of those things where we should have regulation on how government works and what their powers are and we just need to make sure they're not exceeding those powers. Like >> personally, um my politics when I took the political compass test, I was left libertarian. So I I'm so very much socially liberal. I and I am and I'm and when because the political compass when they said libertarian, what they mean by libertarian is socially liberal. So not like in your traditional sense. >> I mean I I in >> that's not that's not necessarily what libertarian means. Libertarian generally means that you want the government to have the least amount of power possible which is what I am. I'm a right-wing libertarian. I don't think that leftwing libertarianism exists. I don't think that it's a thing because uh having a leftwing view left and right is an economic axis. You have uh like anarcho capitalism on the furthest end and then you have communism or socialism. Marxist Marx uses them interchangeably on the farthest end of the left. You can't have socialism without authority. It's it's a core necessity for the ideal to be enforced. So like for example, I've talked to some anarchocomunists and we're just you were just talking about how you have to prevent the government from getting all this power, which is virtually impossible in a situation where the government is the only people with the power. You've abolished money. You've abolished private ownership. Nobody has anything except what the government gives them. They're the elitist now. They're in charge. So it happens every time they try communism. Uh it happened in in uh China with Mao. It happened in the USSR with Lenin, Stalin, etc. Right? You always have that concentration of power. And why do you need the concentration of power? Well, because in socialism, so in capitalism, you can do socialism, right? You can have a workers uh co-op. You can have a company that is owned by the workers. You can't have that in socialism. Like if I lived in uh the USSR during war communism when Lenin got rid of all money, I can't go into the woods and start a market. I can't go into the woods and um start selling things to people and printing money. Why can't I do that? Well, because it's it's a violation of the core tenant of the idea. But what stops me from doing that? You you need a government to stop me from doing that. That's why you can't have socialism without a government. >> I'm not saying without government. >> Yeah. No, I'm just saying like libert libertarianism like >> I I do I do get what you're saying. That's why that's why I also don't like the political uh political compass test that much because it's over oversimplified. >> And it's one of those things where >> I'm a fascist. No, I'm kidding. >> Um it was one of those things where it's really oversimplified. And when I say I want uh government funding, like I'm not even saying get rid of private companies completely. I think that capitalism is necessary. >> So you're more of like um like a sock dem more like a like um >> one foot in socialism, one foot in >> liberalism. So >> I think I think that that like democratic socialism there's there's two different things that people mean when they say democratic socialism. You have you have one side where what they mean is they're just capitalists but they want more regulation. That's not democratic socialism. Then you have like the democratic socialists of America that are just they're just communists like they're Marxists, right? Then that's that's the true that's that's actually socialism, right? democratic socialism in the sense that people like uh I don't know who's Bernie Sanders >> well Bernie h no they're more extreme like AOC is actively an anti- capitalist but um it's opposition to capitalism right so like democratic socialism in the like de mo moderate democrat sense is a >> it's just capitalism with more regulation it's a it's definitely um like kind of an impingement on capitalism but it's not socialism that's for I I get why you say that. I do get why you say that. Uh so I guess I guess yeah >> it's an amalgamation I would say. >> Yeah. It's one of those things where it's just um I it's like what I'm saying is like more public funding for certain stuff but not eliminating private ownership because I think like yes for example with healthcare you're going to need private companies to invest in whether that's research new medicine there you go you're >> technology you're just going to need that like I get what you're saying and that's why I actually that's why I say I'm leaning towards that but I'm not actually that because >> because I don't agree with those people that we need to get rid of capitalist completely and I also don't think that eliminating an entire class of people is good where that's it's not it's not only not good but it's not morally right. >> Let me ask you this. What do you think about billionaires? And by the way, I just want to say again um thank you for being so respectful and thank you to the audience for being so respectful. I I'm sure that most of you probably don't agree with what David and I have to say, but I appreciate everybody taking turns and being respectful and all that. Um, so what do you think of billionaires? >> Billionaires, uh, honestly, >> I don't have much of an opinion on them because I don't know too much about them. >> The only thing that I do know is >> is that this is why I hear especially people who are more on the social socialist side is that they're all evil and they're all exploitative. I get why would they would say that but do I agree with it at least I don't know enough about how those stuff works to agree or disagree on it >> is I at least personally because I always try to approach things with a little bit of humility is saying like if I don't know something I'm not going to go and say that this is right or wrong >> and you have no idea how much I respect that because I say the exact same thing all the I'm if you know if somebody brings something up in a discussion, we live in a world that has a lot of information flowing all the time and there's a lot of news new news stories all the time. If somebody cites an article and I've never heard the headline, I'm going to ask them to send that to me. Tell them I don't know about it and tell them I'll read it later and try to figure it out. Um but but you're always going to even if you're just looking at it from a selfish position, you're always going to look smarter saying I don't know than you're going to look when you talk about something that you have no idea what you're talking about. And that's why I don't do it. Um, but I I would say the reason I brought that up, the billionaires, and this isn't an argument against you because you didn't take a position on it, is we you were talking about more social welfare programs and stuff. I disagree with social welfare, but what I would say is that billionaires fund the social welfare. Billionaires pay um almost 90% of all taxes in the or sorry, the top 1% pays almost 50% of all taxes in the United States and the top 50% pays uh 90% of all taxes, over 90% of all taxes. So the majority of your social welfare programs are directly funded by the upper upper class in the top 1%. >> So >> yeah, of course. And uh and I remember you asking how are we going to fund those programs? >> I a lot of people probably not going to like this and think it won't work. >> Can I take a wild guess? >> Yeah. >> Increase taxes. >> No. >> Okay. Well, let's see. >> Uh decreasing military funding. Oh, >> I feel like our military have gotten to a point where like here's what I think when uh like a lot of the time our government are too interventionist like we're sending money to other countries that at war whether that's Israel whether that's Ukraine I don't think that's what we need to do I think we could save those money and use them to better our own people. First, >> here's here's something I would say is um like while I do support funding to like Ukraine and Israel, right? These are I think there's benefits to it. We don't want to talk about Israel on this tour specifically as much he's a Jew and I'm a Zionist. We love talking about Israel and we'd love to talk about it more, but the only reason we don't talk about Israel on this tour is because uh there are a lot of conspiracy theories right now about Charlie Kirk and about him being killed by Israel. And we are doing this um to show people that we're not afraid and also to honor Charlie. And we don't want to >> we don't want to disrespect his memory in talking about Israel and making it about Israel because it's not and and that's not to say that you did that, but um what I would say is I think there are benefits to those things, but that's not also not military spending. So like that's that's our foreign aid budget that's delegated by Congress and not to our military. >> Yes. Sorry. Sorry. I I I shouldn't have confused this. No worries. Uh what I'm saying is not only should we Let me ask you this. You said you want to reduce the budget for the Pentagon. What exactly? Do you have an idea of what you want to reduce there? What you don't like? What you think is ineffective? What doesn't help America? >> Uh I I'm sorry I don't have it right on top of my head, but I know I don't want to say I know because it's what I heard or saw on social media and Tik Tok and stuff like that. So, I'm not even sure if it's 100% accurate, but like I know uh what I've heard is some of those um there are a lot of projects and a lot of spending that the Pentagon uses that are not really necessary and that they're just using it to keep their funding. >> Sure. I I agree. But that makes it subjective, right? Each administration gets to decide what they want to, right? It's under the perview of the executive. So the executive at the end of the day is able to say we want to delegate funding for these programs and these programs. Right? So what you think what I think regarding where the money goes to the Pentagon is kind of useless at the end. >> That is also true. That is also true. >> I'm worried that if we cut funding for the Pentagon or we start to reduce funding for the Pentagon. And there's a reason why Democrats, Republicans, it doesn't really matter for the for their political party. They continuously increase the spending when it comes down to the Pentagon. is I think we understand how important the department of war, not the defense anymore, >> uh is to America whether it is protecting our allies internationally or it's protecting our homeland because that is that's important for us as Americans. >> I I actually do get that. It's just I I guess this is also part of it that uh like I I actually like this is also my moral code is one of those things where I'm a huge pacifist. So I don't like war war or violence. >> Sure. >> And like even when people say like we need violence to achieve civil rights or equality, I disagree with that. I think we could achieve those things without violence. Like I look up to MLK, I look up to uh Gandhi, I look up to those people. Now, not to say they have done very horrible things. Like I believe Gandhi slept with his niece, right? >> I'm not sure. >> That's what I heard. I'm not sure either, but >> that's outside of my American interest. >> Yeah, I I get that. I get that. But uh like I look up those people. I look up how they use nonviolence to achieve their aims. And that's what I hope to do because I believe if we try to change things through violence, the only thing we're going to get is response is more violence. >> I I do agree with that sentiment. I think that I this is what I would say is I think that we shouldn't respond to peace with violence. You shouldn't kill um like people disagree with you, but I think that there is times where war is necessary. Like World War II, for example, uh like Pearl Harbor, we were attacked. We can't we cannot just allow our people to be attacked without defending ourselves. Um uh 9/11 is another example. Like we can't I don't think we should have been in Afghanistan as long as we were. But we cannot just be attacked and 2799 of our people be killed and we do nothing about it. U and with that being said, uh I appreciate your time. >> I think the guy behind you is getting a little tired, so I want to make sure that everybody gets time to speak. >> We're kind of Give me a handshake. I appreciate it. Thanks for coming out. >> Thank you so much, buddy. Thank you. >> We're really excited for you because I'm I'm curious. I'm honestly curious. Do you have any updates regarding whether there's more evidence that the shooter was a croper? >> Well, I was going to say actually conversation yesterday >> cuz you guys kind of opened me up to think about like out of my box. So, >> come a little closer wanting one opinion. >> Um, I don't think your opinion is correct, but >> I think we need to wait for more evidence. >> Um, I'm here cuz I wanted to talk about this side. >> Perfect. >> We have our first one. >> Yeah. Um, >> I'm sorry to interrupt, but I we actually went on about the other things a little too long because that was also the one that wanted >> Come come back up. Come back up. Jump in line. Jump in line. You come back up. >> Um, first question I guess is why can a man not be a woman? I'll conceive the chromosomes, right? And like the biological aspect, but yeah. >> Yeah. So I would say that um a man cannot become a woman any more than I can become a lizard or I can become a black man. >> Sure. >> Uh the definition of a woman is an adult human female and the definition of a female is a person or denoting a person of the sex capable of creating ova. >> And so so it's a full circle definition. You have what is a woman? A woman is an adult human female. What is a female? A person that can produce ova. So a man cannot produce ova. He can't be an adult human female, therefore he cannot be a woman. >> Why does that like bother you so much? >> Um, it bothers me because I am loyal to the truth. I think the truth is important. I don't think that we should degrade the truth. I think that the idea that a man can be a woman is a degradation of the truth. In the same way that I think the idea that I can become a black man is a degradation of the truth. Even if I dress up as a black man, paint my skin black, I'm not a black man. I'm a white man pretending to be a black man. Just like a man who dresses up as a woman is a man pretending to be a woman. And if I dress up like a lizard, I'm not a lizard. If he dresses up like a penguin, he's not a penguin. We're just two guys dressed up as lizards and penguins. >> Which, by the way, today I am identifying as a black penguin. But I just want to say I just want to say as a black penguin, let's look at the policy side of it as well because I get it. It's like why do I care? I'm more kind of socially liberal. Like I don't really care if you want to be this stuff and identify as that. But then there's the policy impact of it, right? Whether it's in restrooms, whether it's in college sports, uh whether it's teaching little kids this stuff, right? there's an actual policy impact of it when we start to say that yeah a guy that or somebody that's a biologically male is a woman that can actually have effect of it when it comes down to you me >> actually just saw something uh David um since you're the expert here if I start identifying as a Jew is there a chance like we can get that credit score up >> you know what give it two days and I'll give you uh loan free uh I yeah I'll give you no interest rates >> no interest rates on your loans buddy use it right here all day Um, but you you understand why that's silly, right? Like I understand the argument that I don't I don't want to call you a liberal, but that I hear from the left is that why do I care? They're just identifying is that in reality, like Kim just pointed out when we just start to say this stuff and say that that's that is the case, then we also have to act upon it based on policy that we have. And that's the problem I have. >> So like what sort of policies really concern? You said bathrooms, you said um sports. >> Yeah. >> And you said education. >> Yeah. >> What specifically about education? >> Well, so we've seen multiple examples even here in Atlanta, which I think is the major problem that I have. I forgot what the exact name of the middle school. This is going to bother me, but uh they had three different books there, right? Why they were this is an ele elementary ele elementary middle school sorry middle school where they were teaching kids in the books that they were reading that yes a boy can be a girl if he feels like it and a girl can be a boy if she feels like it. I don't think that's >> I don't think that's good to teach seventh graders eighth graders. Is there a reason why we should be teaching seventh and eighth graders that? >> I think that you know acceptance within someone's like how someone wants to identify you know can prevent further issues. I know the famous last words of Charlie Kirk involved, you know, transgenders being mass shooters. You know, that's linked more to mental health, I'd say, than >> Let me just say this real quickly. But right, there's a difference between affirming their belief and actually providing treatment for their what I believe is a mental illness and that is supported by various sources. >> Uh being transgender is a mental illness. >> Well, it's body dysmor what is it? >> Yeah, it's body body dysmorphia. And I think actually most transgender people agree that it's a mental illness and their solution, their solution, what they say is the treatment for >> having the mental illness of body dysmorphia is being affirmed in your gender and being allowed to transition. And I fundamentally disagree with that. Yeah, gender dysphoria or body dysmorphia, similar things. And I totally disagree with that because there's another mental illness or another disorder that is related to body dysmorphia. It's called anorexia or bulimia. And when women have anorexia or bulimia, I say only say women because it's more often women. We don't tell them, "Yeah, you are fat and you should stop eating and you should binge and purge, right?" We we say, "No, you're like unhealthily small and you need to eat food." When somebody has schizophrenia, we don't tell them, "Yeah, the voices in your head are real and you should listen to them." We tell them, "Get on these pills and hopefully, you know, this will like make the voices go away or seduce them or make your life a little bit easier." And we treat them for their mental illness. We take them to therapy. Um, and we don't we don't just tell them that it's true. And so I don't think you should do that for this one either. It's the only case where we tell people that their mental illness is valid and true and that they should they should fulfill what their illness is telling them to do rather than treating them. >> The most ridiculous one is like the healthy body people, right? There's a mental illness where they feel like they want to be disabled, like they're not in the they're not in the right body, so they want an arm cut off or they want their eyes taken out so they can be blind. You wouldn't affirm that, right? You wouldn't teach that in seventh grade. You wouldn't Right. We wouldn't affirm that to them. We would they're kind of diverting, you know, trying to make me agree with you. >> But that is the mental illness uh point. You said gender, right? Uh are you aware of the gender and sex distinction? >> I think the same thing because when you claim that your gender has changed, you claim that you're a woman. Again, a woman is just an adult human female. A female is of denoting the sex capable of producing ova. And therefore, sex and gender are the same thing, right? If you're just saying And there's there's also no in between. I don't I don't think that you can like I don't I don't think you can be non-binary. And I also don't think that you should be able to just oh I'm a man now. I'm a woman now. I'm a man now. I'm a woman now. I'm a man now. Woman now. Right. Like >> do you believe that gender is a do you believe that gender is a social construct? Is that >> I do fully believe gender is a social construct? I believe that we as a society have labeled certain like characteristics to be associated with one or the other. But you believe that when you become the opposite gender and you transition, despite the fact that you believe it's a social construct, you believe that that person becomes either a man or a woman, right? >> I think the issue here becomes more of like the strict restrictions we've put on people's identity that say for example, I wanted to be more feminine. I wanted to dress up as a woman. I wanted to do feminine activities. >> I don't believe in restrictions by the way. I don't I don't think that transgender people shouldn't be allowed to dress up as the opposite sex. I I don't it doesn't like I mean is it weird? Yeah, it's weird but people do weird stuff all the time, right? Like look at this guy. I'm just kidding. But um like people do weird stuff all the time and you can't I don't think that you should be able to restrict the bodies of adults. Whatever they want to do with their body, they should be allowed to do it. I don't think the children should be allowed to do it. Uh nor do I think they should be coerced to do it. As long as it's not happening to children, I I don't care what you do. It's just it's just wrong. Like it's what they're what you're saying. It's just factually untrue, but you're allowed to believe things that are factually untrue, right? Like I probably think some of the things you believe are factually I'm just busting your job. >> I'm just I'm just messing around with you. But um you get what I'm saying. Um and so I I don't believe in restricting it. Uh I just believe that everybody should also have the choice to decide whether or not they play into the lie. And I personally won't. >> Yeah. >> But so say someone comes up to you says they want to identify as a woman. Do you think your like core belief will make you disagree with them? >> Yeah, I absolutely disagree with them. If they're saying they're a woman and they're not a woman, I totally disagree with what they're saying. Now, have I in the past like just said screw it and called them whatever they wanted to call just to avoid conflict. Yeah, I've done that for sure. Um, but it's just I like I don't think I should be forced to tell a lie. I don't think that I should be mandated to tell a lie. And there's a lot of people who think that me not calling somebody by their desired gender would be like hate speech and I should be in jail for that. And I think that's totally absurd. Uh >> I think that's I think that's a key thing is that like if I encounter somebody that's transgender, I may disagree with them. I mean I'll believe that, you know, if they're biological male and they're claiming to be a woman, I don't believe that. But I don't know, I'm out in public. I'm not going to make a point out of it, right? I'm not going to tell them that you're not a woman. Do I hold that position? Absolutely. Am I going to continue to believe that regardless of how nice they are to me? Absolutely. But I'm not going to be a terrible person to them or whatever the case may be. >> Um I just real quick um before you make your next point, can I just get like a quick uh show of hands from the spectators of like if you guys can hear both me and him? Okay. You you can't? >> No, it's a little low. >> Which which side is is low? Is it me or him? >> Hello. >> It's him. Okay. Yeah. Just stand a little closer to the mic. >> Is there a way we can bring this up? >> Maybe maybe if we do it like this. I just want to make sure everybody can hear Is this better? >> Is that better? >> It's better. Okay, good. All right. >> What's your proposed like >> Come just come a little closer. >> What's your proposed policy change? >> Uh I think that the policy doesn't need to change. I think I think the status quo has pretty much always been that legally a man is a man, a woman is a woman. Uh now there are some states that have gone as far as to allow people to like change their genders and their licenses and stuff which I think is actually like a huge pragmatic problem because if you are identified as a man in all places, but you're actually a woman and you have long hair or you're a you're license identifies you as a woman, but you have a beard. When you if you were to commit a crime, who are the police looking for? They're going to see a guy with a beard and be like, "That's not a woman. he must not be the suspect. Like it creates all these pragmatic problems. And you could I guess you could kind of say like the opposite causes some pragmatic problems too, but I think it's far less common and far less of an issue. Um so yeah, I I think the policy just shouldn't change. I think that um women should use women's restrooms, men should use men's restrooms, and I also don't think that men should be in women's sports. I think that that's uh been >> repeatedly proven danger. >> Question with restrooms. How how often do you look at who you're going to the bathroom with? >> No, it's not it's not about it's not about um like how often I look at who I never have to worry about this because I'm a man, right? Like I if some if some transgender person walks into my bathroom, chances are they're going to be far more affeminite than me and their arms are going to be smaller, so I don't have to worry about it, right? But >> women and especially young women when they're potentially fa like in the bathroom with some giant bearded transgender person and I'm not I I really don't want to be derogatory here but like do you I I really want I want with again I'm not trying to be derogatory but I want you to understand like in the shoes of a of a small young woman who sees a big bulky person with a beard like have you ever seen photos of Leah Thomas? Dude's ripped, right? Like he's jacked. You look at pictures of him and like he has ginormous shoulder muscles. Like he's huge, right? Uh >> having a I wouldn't you wouldn't you wouldn't it's not it's not even just about like safety. It's also about comfortability. Like women should feel comfortable in their bathrooms and they shouldn't have to feel like >> they have to watch their back in their own bathroom um more so than they otherwise would. And that's my biggest thing. And like um the same thing goes for like locker rooms because when you once you throw the bathroom thing away now you're looking at locker rooms. Paula Scandlin is a friend of mine. She swam on Leah Thomas' team. Leah or Will Thomas previously swam on the men's team and dated a member of the women's team. Then one year Will Thomas comes over to the men's team and the coach announces this person will be swimming on the women's team and next they initially said uh he will change in the family bathroom and he will not be in the women's restroom or the women's locker room. Uh, and think about this bathing suit completely naked when you're changing in and out of it. And now imagine you're in a racing suit. They're extremely tight. Women's racing suits are extremely tight and they're extremely difficult to get out of when they're completely soaking wet. Uh, Paula told me that basically when you hold this little racing suit up, it looks like it could fit an American Girl doll. It's so small. So, it takes them like 20 minutes to change in and out of these things when they're wet. So, they didn't put Leah Thomas in the family bathroom. Leah Thomas with his full penis was in the women's locker room. You've seen it. I'm sure you've seen a sports locker room. The lockers, they're not even really lockers. They're just shelves and they're right next to each other. It's boom, boom, boom, boom. And now Paula and her teammates are standing right next to uh Leah Thomas with a penis who is attracted to women watching them change and who has dated actual people on that team. And that person is just in the locker room now. It's it's it's not that I think Leah Thomas is going to like sexually assault somebody in that locker room, but it's just not comfortable. I wouldn't be comfortable if I had to change next to a woman I didn't know or, you know, a woman who I'm not in a relationship with. It's just uncomfortable. >> It's not just unc it's not just uncomfortable, but everything that Cam just said, it's just it doesn't make sense. And that's why even Democrats, more than twothirds of them reject this crazy stuff. They don't want to see biological males in women locker rooms, especially in colleges or even in high school. It's common sense and that is why I mean independents overwhelmingly support that. 80% support that. I don't have to talk about Republicans, but twothirds of Democrats like how many things can Democrats and Republicans, the majority of Democrats agree with Republicans on? Practically nothing. There's, you know, other things, but that right there is common sense. >> I will admit that I haven't thought much about the specific sports issue and it seems like you guys think a lot about this case specifically. >> You have a lot of friends who have had to deal with it firsthand on the court and off the court. >> Um, I will say though that I do believe that statements like this cause more harm than good, >> especially for a lot of young people who are dealing with gender dysphoria. and you know trying to identify on at least the gender spectrum of who they want to be especially when I assume you guys consider yourselves masculine men. >> Do you think that we should lie to them? >> I think >> do do you think we should lie to them? >> Like if I fundamentally disagree that gender and sex are not mutually exclusive, should I lie to them? And again, there's no there's no law that that mandates that they can't they can't dress up as whatever they want or be whatever they want. You know what I mean? It's just fundamentally it's untrue and I'm not going to pretend like it is true. And um you're not aware of conservatives that want to you're not aware of conservatives that want to restrict >> I'm not I'm not aware of anybody outside of like super extreme people like we talked about yesterday who want to actually restrict these kind and I don't know if they specifically talk about this or what. But um another thing too is like I'm from Seattle and Seattle has a very dense population of transgender people and as a byproduct of that there's also a very dense population of dransitioners who are who have gone so far to the left like one of them lived his entire adult life as as a woman got all the surgeries and is is you honestly I it's when I first met him I thought he was a woman like he's still woman passing even though he's dransitioned and his username is transphobe01 on Twitter. He's he's gone so far because he's realized like that this is so terrible and it screwed his life up so much. Another one um Ary Salvatore is a good friend of mine in Seattle and he transitioned lived as a woman who went to Thailand and got his penis removed and had an artificially constructed vagina put in its place. And um this for all these people in Maya Poet who actually realized that it didn't matter on October 7th when she was in Israel and the bombs came down and she had to decide whether or not to grab her breast binder >> and she's like wait a minute this doesn't matter. I'm going to die if I grab it. So she ran to the bomb shelters. And so um >> now what about >> I know I know all these people and they they just they've gone so far. It all started when they were children. All of them started transitioning when they were children and now have realized it's just messed their lives up. the people whose lives it saved. You know, I believe that >> I I don't I I from the data that I've seen, it seems that transgender suicide rates remain the same regardless of whether they transition or not, which is another thing that leads me to the conclusion that this is a mental illness. And I think that we should get them real help and not just a band-aid on a bullet hole. Uh you know >> I just want to add also so after the surgery for transgender individuals the the highest suicide rate is in the eighth year post surgery. So it seems like the surgery doesn't fix anything. Affirming their belief doesn't fix anything. It actually pushes them further to do the unthinkable which is to commit suicide. I think it it's more social issues that if people like you two when you guys find out and knowing that people think like you do guys have the right to think and prestige that's not going to take that away but I think that's what causes the suicide rates that they're constantly >> even though post even though post off right so the surgery was supposed to fix the mental illness part of it but it didn't the prescription drugs that they're prescribed have only make them worse I mean that's the reality of the prescription drugs. Not only are they lifetime uh patients of big pharma now, but they're also being affected by those pills that they're taking on a daily basis that can be messing with their heads, which is why data points to the eighth year being the highest suicide rate after uh transition. >> What can I ask? What data? What evidence? I'm not fully familiar with >> Yeah. Mayo Clinic. >> Mayo Clinic. >> Yeah. I I would suicide rate post transition. What about pre-transition? >> I don't know about that. >> I assume it's quite high. It can be. I don't know. >> The statistics I've seen I think it's quite high. That's why. >> But the difference is is that you believe it's because of people like Cam and I. We don't that society doesn't accept them. I actually believe that society has gone to the point of where they have an entire month dedicated for them to the point of where they don't care about women anymore. They would rather affirm their belief because they want to affirm their belief. Right. But you're saying that society's actually doing the opposite. >> It's like I think it only picks up like right here. I got >> I'm not good with the mics. That's a problem. >> It's okay. It's okay. Totally okay. Thank you. >> No, no, no. It's just uh David. He just David needs to talk closer to >> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. >> It's hard for me to put the mic, right? >> You got anything else? >> I mean, no. I appreciate you guys having this conversation. I'm just like >> really, you know, these are questions I think need to be solved through conversation. Figure out why people disagree, why people agree. And at the end of the day, like my voice speaking for transgender people, I can't speak for the experience. I was born. >> Yeah. >> As a man, I identify as a man. >> Hey, I want to say um you know, you were there yesterday and you were respectful. There was a lot of chaos yesterday, but you were there and you were respectful and you came back today and you respectful again. So, I really appreciate it. >> Really appreciate it. Seriously. >> Thank you so much. Thank you so much. >> Thank you. >> Hi. How's it going? >> Hi. Um this is my first time ever speaking, you know, about anything. So, I did write a little bit down a little closer. Okay. I did write a little bit down to talk about and I really just want to talk about um Charlie Kirk and things like that. >> So, just give me time. >> Yeah. No worries. >> Um for me personally, as a black woman in America, I don't have really any empathy for him to be honest because of the things that he spoke about, the the words that came out of his mouth, him saying, you know, hurtful and hateful things. I don't feel like me or anyone else here if we don't have empathy for him should be ridiculed ridiculed or you know talked about bad for not having empathy for him. >> Yeah. I I can't force you to have empathy for Charlie. Um I have a lot of um you know I mean honestly Charlie's death has devastated me and I know that it's devastated a lot of other people around me. Uh a lot of my I we actually have a friend who spoke to Charlie the night before he died. Uh we I mean we're just like it's just hard for us, right? So I but I can't force you to have empathy for Charlie. Um the only thing that I have an issue with like an active proactive issue with is when people celebrate his death because I don't think that anybody who's a peaceful person who was killed for their words should be uh murdered. Um can I ask you what hurtful and hateful things Charlie said? >> Okay. So him stating that it's okay for certain that gun deaths should happen to withhold the second amendment was wrong. Him saying that empathy was a madeup word. Him saying that the civil rights movement was a mistake. Even him talking about Junth and how that shouldn't be a holiday when it literally ended slavery and and is a way to, you know, like uplift people for moving on from slavery and things like that. The words that he spoke targeted black people, women, LGBTQ people. um uh immigrants um him saying even that uh people born here in the United States from immigrants shouldn't shouldn't be allowed in the US is wrong as well. I also feel like >> just to clarify it up >> you don't could we could we hear that um list just one more time uh cuz I want to go through some of these and by the way there's at least one in there that I disagree with Charlie on and that's Junth. I think that Junth should be celebrated. I don't know what why why Charlie said this. I don't know the context around the quote, but I think if not for anything else, all Republicans should support Junth because guess who freed the slaves? Abraham Lincoln. He was a Republican, the first Republican. And we shouldn't have slavery in the country. And I don't know why that's not something that we should all agree on. But for the conservatives listening, uh Jun should be celebrated uh if not for anything other than if you don't care about slaves. Abraham Lincoln was a Republican and he did it. Slaves were freed in the north by 1804 though. That was 5 years before Lincoln. >> And what what president made uh Junth a federal holiday? >> I'm not sure who it was. >> It was Trump. >> It was really it was Trump. >> It was Trump in 2019 or 2020, whichever one it was. >> What were the other statements? >> Okay. Um he talked about Jeene. He talked about um he said that US like um people born from immigrants in the United States should not be >> Absolutely. I agree with that. So the the um I agree with this 100%. I I think that >> there should be a by the way almost the entire world had this doctrine. It's called just soil doctrine where this the child of a person as long as they're born on American soil is an American citizen. >> 2019 >> there's only four countries in the world now that have this just soil doctrine. The United States is one of them. Uh this doctri