Charlie Kirk Confronts Student on White Privilege Claims After Tucson School District Debate

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Charlie Kirk Dismantles White Privilege Narrative in Heated Exchange with Student on Systemic Racism

Charlie Kirk Dismantles White Privilege Narrative in Heated Exchange with Student on Systemic Racism

3:48

Charlie Kirk and Candace Owens Dismantle White Privilege Argument With Military Member at Campus Conversation Event

Charlie Kirk and Candace Owens Dismantle White Privilege Argument With Military Member at Campus Conversation Event

7:36

Charlie Kirk Defends Strong Men, Traditional Values, and Free Speech at Oxford Union Debate

Charlie Kirk Defends Strong Men, Traditional Values, and Free Speech at Oxford Union Debate

1:39:10

Charlie Kirk banner
2,422 videos 1,389,747,653 views US Joined Aug 30, 2018

Charlie Kirk is the Founder and President of Turning Point USA, the largest and fastest growing conservative youth activist organization in the country with over 250,000 student members, over 150 full-time staff, and a presence on over 2,000 high school and college campuses nationwide. Charlie is also the Chairman of Students for Trump, which aims to activate one million new college voters on campuses in battleground states in the lead up to the 2020 presidential election. His social media reaches over 100 million people per month and according to Axios, he is one of the "top 10 most engaged" Twitter handles in the world. He is also the host of “The Charlie Kirk Show,” which regularly ranks among the top news shows on Apple podcast charts.

Charlie Kirk Confronts Student on White Privilege Claims After Tucson School District Debate

Charlie Kirk faces a heated exchange with a student who argues that Arizona's laws targeting Mexican American studies programs and immigration enforcement prove the existence of white privilege and systemic racism. The student cites a 2017 federal judge's ruling on Tucson Unified School District's banned ethnic studies program. Kirk counters by flipping the argument, pointing to affirmative action policies, healthcare distribution practices, and corporate hiring quotas that he argues create advantage for people of color. The confrontation ends with a Latino Turning Point USA volunteer sharing his own perspective on discrimination, stating he's experienced more mistreatment from the left than from conservatives.

March 25, 2024

Student Challenges Kirk on Arizona's Controversial Laws

A student confronted Charlie Kirk about white privilege and racism in Arizona, specifically referencing two laws deemed racist by federal courts over the past decade. The student focused on the Tucson Unified School District's Mexican American studies program, which was created in 2003 to close the achievement gap between Latino and European American students in a district where 75% of students are Latino.

According to the student, the program successfully closed the achievement gap by 2007. However, Arizona State Superintendent Tom Horne called the classes racist and accused them of teaching the overthrow of the government and segregating students, despite allegedly never attending a class himself. After multiple attempts between 2007 and 2009, Governor Jan Brewer signed a law in 2010 banning these classes. The student argued that a federal judge ruled the law racist in 2017, finding it violated the 14th Amendment.

The student also referenced Arizona's SB1070 law, describing it as legislation that allows officers to pull someone over and demand proof of citizenship based on appearance, arguing this represents a clear example of white privilege in action.

Kirk Rejects the Premise of Systemic Racism

Charlie Kirk firmly rejected the student's arguments, stating there is no such thing as white privilege or institutional racism. When asked if the federal judge was wrong, Kirk responded that judges can be wrong all the time. He challenged the student's assumption that Jan Brewer signed the legislation out of hatred for Latino people, asking for evidence of such motivation.

Kirk questioned the student's interpretation of SB1070, asking what was wrong with the law. When the student explained it allows officers to demand papers based on appearance, Kirk responded that everyone should be asked for their papers regardless of skin color, noting he gets asked for his driver's license every time he's pulled over.

The Victim Mentality Argument

Kirk offered the student direct advice, saying he was looking at the world as a victim and believing in a lie about systemic racism and an evil system designed to crush him. Kirk argued this mindset is designed to keep people down and disempower them, insisting that white people also get pulled over and asked for papers regularly.

The student pushed back, clarifying he never called himself a victim but acknowledged that his journey would be different from someone who doesn't look like him. This set up Kirk's major counterargument.

Kirk's Reversal: Claims of Advantage for People of Color

Kirk agreed the student's journey would be different, but argued it would actually be easier, not harder. He presented several specific examples to support his claim:

  • Affirmative action laws that benefit people of color over white applicants at certain universities
  • Texas Health and Human Services policies that allegedly prioritize Hispanic and black people for Regeneron and monoclonal antibody treatments
  • State Street Capital Advisers requiring board permission to hire white people while allowing unlimited hiring of Hispanic and black people
  • United Airlines' stated goal to double the number of Hispanic and black pilots while hiring fewer white pilots

Kirk concluded by telling the student that the current system makes it easier for him, declaring that people of color currently have preference and it's easier for them to succeed than their white counterparts. He stated directly: "You have privilege."

A Latino Conservative's Perspective

As the exchange grew heated and the student's companion expressed frustration, Kirk invited Daniel Fuentes, a Latino volunteer with Turning Point USA, to share his perspective. Fuentes testified that despite being pulled over by police many times, 99% of those officers treated him nicely, including officers who looked nothing like him.

Fuentes shared that at every Turning Point event he's attended, his Caucasian brothers and sisters have treated him well. He made a pointed observation: he's experienced more mistreatment from whites on the left than from those on the right for being a Latino conservative. The audience responded with applause as Kirk thanked both participants and moved to the next question.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!