Up Next
Charlie Kirk and Riley Gaines Face Heated Questions at San Francisco State University Event
1:47:09
Charlie Kirk Debates Immigration on California Campus: Should America Deport All Illegal Immigrants?
37:51
Charlie Kirk's Billion View TikTok Compilation Reveals Campus Conversations That Shaped the Election
25:10
Charlie Kirk Dismantles Illegal Immigration Myths and Debates Abortion With UC San Diego Students
Charlie Kirk faces off with UC San Diego students in heated debates about illegal immigration and abortion. When a student rattles off statistics claiming illegal immigrants boost the economy and commit fewer crimes, Kirk methodically dismantles each argument, invoking federal law 8 USC 1312 and asking the simple question: what should the penalty be for breaking into America? The conversation shifts to abortion, where Kirk defends the pro-life position grounded in the belief that human dignity begins at conception, not consciousness. From immigration enforcement to the sanctity of life, Kirk demonstrates why appealing to self-evident truths matters more than selective statistics.
The Illegal Immigration Debate
A UC San Diego student approached Charlie Kirk with a prepared list of talking points defending illegal immigration. The student claimed illegal immigrants power the economy, constitute 50% of US farm workers, fill 70% of construction jobs in states like Texas, and pay $13 billion annually in taxes including $2 billion to Social Security they can't claim. The student argued that deporting them would slash agriculture output by $60 billion and raise food prices by 6%.
The student continued, citing statistics that undocumented immigrants in Texas have 26% lower homicide conviction rates than native-born citizens and are incarcerated at half the rate nationally. The argument concluded with claims that mass deportation would cost $315-400 billion, shrink GDP by $1.7 trillion over 10 years, and tear apart 4.4 million US citizen children who have undocumented parents.
Kirk's Response on Federal Law
Kirk didn't engage with the statistics directly. Instead, he asked a foundational question: what should the penalty be for breaking into America? When the student initially dismissed illegal entry as merely a misdemeanor, Kirk corrected him, citing 8 USC 1312, which classifies illegal entry as a federal felony punishable by up to 5 years in prison, though often enforced as a misdemeanor.
Kirk pressed the student repeatedly on what the appropriate penalty should be. After the student fumbled through responses about merit-based systems and checking his phone, he finally conceded that sending people back would be an appropriate penalty. Kirk seized on this agreement, pointing out that deportation is exactly what should happen.
Challenging Crime Statistics
Kirk then dismantled the student's crime statistics by pointing out a fundamental flaw: every illegal immigrant is by definition a criminal because they break the law by entering illegally and continue breaking the law every day they remain in the country unlawfully. According to federal law, both breaking in and harboring yourself in the interior of the United States are criminal acts.
When the student insisted that once illegal immigrants are here, they commit fewer crimes than native-born citizens, Kirk asked if he knew the names Lake Riley or Rachel Morren. The student admitted he did not. Kirk explained that Lake Riley was a University of Georgia student murdered by an illegal alien who had been deported five times and was a known peeping Tom. Kirk emphasized that every single American killed by an illegal alien represents a death that should never have happened.
Beyond Crime: The Full Impact
Kirk expanded the conversation beyond crime rates, listing six additional problems with illegal immigration:
- Illegal immigrants steal social security numbers
- They depress wages for American workers
- Many are involved in smuggling operations
- The southern border serves as the largest human trafficking operation in American history
- They flood public schools, social services, and hospitals
- They represent a burden on taxpayers
Kirk illustrated the wage depression argument by explaining that when a plumber, electrician, or welder must compete against someone from Nicaragua willing to work for five dollars less per hour, it directly harms American workers. He pointed out that despite 20 years of mass migration bringing 30 million people into America, wages have actually gone down.
Settlers vs. Immigrants
When the student invoked the common refrain that America is a nation built by immigrants, Kirk made an important distinction: America was founded by settlers, not immigrants. Settlers come to a barren place and build something new, while immigrants come to a country already built. He cited the 1840s California Gold Rush as an example, noting that people moving west to unindustrialized California were settlers building a new place, not immigrants arriving at an established nation.
Cultural Cohesion and Language
Kirk raised concerns about cultural cohesion, asking the student if he found it troubling that a majority of young people in California speak Spanish rather than English. The student didn't see the problem, suggesting the solution was simply to teach them English. Kirk countered with what he called a better solution: don't import a bunch of people who don't speak English in the first place.
Kirk emphasized that America is more than an economy. "We're one nation under God, not one nation under GDP," he said to applause. He argued that when social cohesion breaks down and the country imports people who don't share American values and don't necessarily assimilate, it creates a major problem. The American creed is falling apart, and mass immigration has not helped that creed.
The Italian Student's Perspective
A student from Italy offered support for Kirk's position, sharing that Europe faces major problems with illegal immigration, including people who don't respect laws and create dangerous situations. She expressed frustration that as someone respecting the law and trying to immigrate legally, she faces difficulty and may have to return to Italy, while others who come illegally can do whatever they want. Kirk praised her perspective and said America needs more legal immigrants like her.
Approaching Politics on Campus
A conservative student named Ellie asked Kirk about the best way to approach political discussions on campus. She noted that when she talks with people on the other side, they're often surprised her ideas aren't crazy, but she wondered if there were better approaches given that many on campus view these conversations as invalid or even evil.
Kirk responded that the problem lies with UC San Diego, not with his approach. He referenced an op-ed telling students to ignore him, interpreting this as evidence that those students aren't smart enough or intellectually mature enough to have discussions with conservatives. He emphasized that he comes with almost no notes, while students can use AI, bring professors, or team up with friends. He's completely open to disagreement and prioritizes those who disagree by moving them to the front of the line.
Kirk rejected concerns about tactics or Reddit criticism, saying he doesn't care about "libs on Reddit" who aren't well-socially adjusted. He focuses on the 90% of Americans who want to make something of their lives, have kids, and contribute to society. He pointed out that what happens at these events gets seen hundreds of millions of times on social media, and the crowds are growing.
The Abortion Debate: Consciousness vs. Personhood
Another student shifted the conversation to abortion, arguing that the metric for assigning personhood should be based on sentience rather than conception. The student drew an analogy between a brain-dead person showing no brain activity and a fertilized egg, suggesting both lack consciousness.
Kirk immediately identified the flaw in this comparison. A brain-dead person at the end of life represents "no more," while a developing human represents "not yet." These are fundamentally different moral circumstances. One consciousness will come, the other will not. You cannot conflate the two.
The Blueprint Analogy
The student tried a different approach, comparing a fertilized egg to a blueprint for a building. Just as a blueprint isn't the building itself, the student argued that a fertilized egg isn't equivalent to a human life. Kirk countered by asking if the building is actively being constructed in real time, pointing out that a blueprint sitting dormant is indeed different from an active construction process. The baby is the building currently being built following the blueprint of DNA.
Development Stages and Rights
When the student pressed Kirk on whether a fertilized egg has the exact same moral value as a developed human, Kirk affirmed that they're simply at different stages of development. The student challenged this, asking why stage of development should determine rights. Kirk pointed out that society does make some distinctions based on development, such as not letting a fetus drive a car, but the right to life is different and doesn't depend on cognitive capabilities.
Animals vs. Humans
The conversation turned to why we give moral consideration to human zygotes but not to animals, who also undergo development. Kirk explained that human beings have a soul while animals do not. This represents different levels of moral worth. When the student suggested this conflates consciousness with the soul, Kirk distinguished between the two.
Consciousness, Kirk explained, is merely your internal narration, your ability to reason. The soul is something beyond consciousness. He illustrated this with the experience of being speechless before a breathtaking sunset or a newborn baby. The fact that words cannot adequately describe certain profound experiences proves that something transcends reason and speech. That is the soul.
Self-Evident Truth
Kirk challenged the student to identify the innate moral difference between a four-year-old and a zygote. When the student answered "consciousness," Kirk rejected this as irrelevant. Both are human beings deserving protection. Consciousness alone is not a marker of dignity. Being a human being is what confers dignity and rights.
When the student characterized this as circular reasoning, Kirk called it self-evident truth. Human beings have rights because we are human beings. This position is, according to Kirk, irrefutable because you must first posit that human beings have rights. The student asked what would convince Kirk that the pro-life position is wrong. Kirk answered that it would be an impossibility unless the student could prove God doesn't exist.
The Religious Foundation
Kirk acknowledged that abortion is fundamentally a moral issue, and all moral issues appeal to some authority. From a Christian perspective, human beings are the only creatures made in the image of the Creator, possessing characteristics like the ability to reason, sympathize, empathize, feel, predict, plan, show mercy, offer forgiveness, and be introspective. This sets humans apart from animals.
Kirk explained why it's difficult to change the minds of those who don't believe in God on abortion: without belief in God, you don't necessarily believe human life is special beyond being unique or interesting. You don't believe it's made in the image of a creator. This is why pro-life advocates tend to be people of faith, and that clarity is important.
Morality and Society
The student attempted to ground morality in what helps society progress, but Kirk immediately challenged this utilitarian framework. What if society agrees to kill people with disabilities? In Iceland, it's essentially mandatory to abort babies with Down syndrome. By the student's logic, since Down syndrome individuals could be viewed as a strain on society, their elimination would be justified.
When the student acknowledged there should be some protection for vulnerable people, Kirk pressed him: by what standard? Kirk appeals to a book—the Bible. What does the student appeal to? The student admitted to believing in some transcendent value to life, some sacredness. Kirk pointed out that if the student truly adopted a broader pro-life stance and believed society should support women in having children rather than forcing them to make impossible choices, they would actually find common ground.
Video Transcript
I have um I have a couple points that I want to talk about in illegal immigration. Um is it okay if I write if I say all of them with no interruption? Okay, cool. So, first, illegal immigrants power our economy. They're 50% of US farm workers harvesting the food on our tables and fill 70% of construction jobs in states like Texas. They pay 13 billion annually in taxes, including 2 billion to Social Security that they can't claim. Deporting them would slash agriculture output by 60 billion and raise food prices by 6%. Why gut our farms and wallets when these workers fuel our prosperity? That's my first point. Second point, they strengthen our communities with lower crime rates. So in Texas, undocumented undocumented immigrants have a 26 lower percent homicide conviction rates. So which is 2.2 per 100,000 versus three for nativeorn citizens. Nationally, immigrants are incarcerated at half the rate of native born where it's 85% versus 1.7 1%. Uh that's according to Bureau of Justice Statistics from 2019. So if safety is your goal, why deport people who make our streets safer? This is my third point. Uh mass deportation tears apart American families. Over 4.4 4 million US citizens uh children have an undocumented parent and in Texas one in seven kids lives in a mixed status household. Um okay this is my fourth point. Deportation is a fiscal nightmare. Removing 11 million people would cost 315 to 400 billion more than the entire homeland security budget and shrink our GDP by 1.7 trillion over 10 years. And um this is my last point. Our immigration system is broken, pushing people to cross illegally. Visa waits Mexicans can exceed 20 years and the asylum blockage is 1.3 million cases with hearings four to 6 years out. Uh, okay. >> You done? >> That's pretty much it. Yeah. Yeah. >> All right. So, without looking at the phone, look at me. What should the penalty be for breaking into America? >> I think there should be a system where it's more merit-based. So, if this person >> No penalty. So, what is the penalty? So, what what what should happen? >> It's a f It's not a penalty. It's a mis that's not true. It's 8 USC 1312. You can look it up right now. >> It's a felony if it's done twice. That is correct. That is not correct. I Googled it, dude. To illegally go across the southern border with the well intent to come into harbor yourself into the interior of the United States to violation of 8 USC 1312, which is a felony in the federal criminal code. Now, it can be enforced as a misdemeanor or it can be upwards to 5 years in prison. Now, I want to know since it's a felony, law on the books, 8 USC 1312, what should the penalty be? Um well, in my opinion, these kinds of like um laws are not are are usually they're they're um what do you call it? They're um sorry. >> Usually the the the like the the sorry >> um wait, sorry. Can I can I choke my phone real quick? I apologize. [cheering] Can you can you repeat the the question? Sorry. >> What should the penalty be? >> Penalty be >> for someone that breaks or comes into America illegally? What should the penalty be? >> I think there should be a a merit system where the people Okay, the penalty. All right, let's >> that's not the answer. It's a very simple moral and legal question. What should the penalty be if you come into America illegally? Okay. So, since it's a misdemeanor, not a felony, misdemeanor. >> I just told you it's not. You can look up on your chat GPT. What is 8 USC? Look up what is 8 USC 1312. >> No, I I know. I've already looked it up. >> Yes. It's which is >> when it's your second time crossing the border illegally, then it becomes a felony. It can it can be and it is enforced as a felony and it usually is done as a misdemeanor citation because no one has the stones to do 20 million felony you know uh applications. >> Okay. >> So I just want to ask >> what should the penalty be then >> for someone that comes into this country illegally? >> Usually there's there's three ways that go about this. when there's a penalty. It's there's either like a fine or there is some kind of like uh public service that this person does. Um or you send them back. But but >> send it back. I agree. That's what we should do. >> Okay. Okay. So, [cheering] okay. So, this is this is interesting. So, one of the stats, one of the statistics that I read said that illegal immigrants don't cause as much as much like they don't break the law as often as people who are native born. That is statistic. But every single one of them are criminals. They're all criminals. >> They're okay. Sure. By law. By law. No. By law. Of course. Of course they are. >> Wait. So if they if they if they commit less crime and they're all criminals. >> Wait a second. By definition, >> they they all have broken the law by being here. And they break the law every day by staying here cuz you're actually not allowed to stay here either. Do you know that? So every day you're here, you're actually continually breaking the law. You can't break in or harbor. That's what the federal law says. So by breaking in, it's not just the only law they broke. every second you remain here, you're also breaking the law. So that statistic is invalidated by just them breathing here, they're breaking the law. >> No, of course not. Of course not. So of course it makes sense for them when they're here, they're breaking the law because they're illegal immigrants, obviously. Obviously. But once they're Okay. Yeah. Of course. So once they're here, once they are here, what kind of harm are they actually doing when you look at the numbers statistically? No. No, that's not true. Okay. >> Black wages have gone up. Okay. In Texas, >> DUIs have gone up dramatic dramatically. >> Try not to interrupt, bro. Hold on. I I I'm I'm interjecting and I let you go uninterrupted with your whole siloquy, right? So >> So let me just let me ask you a question though. >> Okay. >> So if it is correct >> Yeah. >> that illegal aliens commit less crimes, which of course it's not correct. >> That is correct. Look it up. In Texas, they made a study in 2019. 26% are lower >> is any crime. It's just not correct. But I'm not going to debate that. It's it's it's I just pro I just proved it at its face because they commit a crime by being here every day. That is a crime. >> Okay. Once they are here, what kind of crimes are they committing? which is >> okay. Well, >> they're they're 26%. >> Do you know the name Lake and Riley? >> No. Educate me. >> Oh, you don't? >> No. No. >> Do you know Wow. Do you know the name Rachel Morren? >> No, I don't. >> Wow. >> Educate me. What? What? >> So, Lake and Riley was a girl at the University of Georgia. Okay. >> There was a peeping Tommy illegal alien that was deported five times prior. He hunted her down her and murdered her on a hiking trail university of Georgia. >> Okay. So one person doesn't represent all >> immigrants. Every person who is killed by an illegal alien is one that should not happen. Every single one of course and also the ones that are born everyone. And so that's the point is that it's not a matter of the rate. >> The the rate even if I accept your premise which is incorrect. The rate is irrelevant. The number is what's relevant. There should be zero illegal aliens. There should be zero Americans being killed by illegals. Not to mention there's six other problems with illegal aliens. They steal social security numbers. They depress wages. They are heavily involved. By the way, not to mention a lot of people that cross on the southern border are also smuggling girls, weapons, and drugs alongside the southern border when they come. It's the largest slavering operate slavery operation in American history that many illegal aliens help make possible on the southern border. And I guess the final question I'll have is should a government serve its citizens first and foremost? >> Yeah, of course. Of course. Well, okay. There's many there's been many people who are like very political leaders who have said that this place is built off of immigrants. >> Oh, is it Well, hold on. Let's think about that. Was was first of all, it's legal, not illegal. But was America founded by immigrants or settlers? >> Settlers. >> That's not an immigrant. >> Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Well, that's not my point. My point is that people >> You brought up the the nation built by immigrants? >> Yeah. We're actually because the political leaders have said that this place is built >> Yeah. And they're from They're wrong. Political leaders are wrong. George W. Bush is wrong. All these political leaders who have built America, >> By the way, the first person to say that was >> How is that wrong when illegal immigrants make they grow the economy statistically? >> Allow me again. Allow me to build it out for you. >> Immigrants have helped at times in American history. But we are first and foremost a nation founded by settlers. Immigrants come to a country already built. Settlers come to a barren place and build something new. This land was barren when people came >> in the 1840s gold rush. This was not an easy place to live. Yeah, >> California was not exactly industrialized. There was not immigrants coming west to California. Those were settlers building a new place around, you know, western western values. Finally, I would just ask the question, >> do you see a moral distinction between a legal immigrant and an illegal immigrant? >> Well, the argument is that they're cutting in line. Like their argument is that they're cutting in line in the 20ear process that it would take for someone to be to cross. >> It's not 20, but >> yeah, at most it's 20. At most it's 20. Right now, there's around like 1.2 million people who are currently waiting. That would take six to seven years for a hearing. >> And by the way, no one has a right to come to this country. Just to be clear, >> let me stay on track of what I was going to say. >> Okay. So, so people people who come here usually almost all the time when they come here, it's they benefit society. They benefit society. There's studies that have done this. >> Not necessarily. >> Okay. Not necessarily, but overall in general when you look overall disagree with that, >> you can't disagree with a fact. The final question is sure. >> Do you have any concern that there are too many people coming into this country and we're a nation of strangers, not a nation of neighbors? >> If the people who are coming are creating America, making it more growing, like the economy is growing, then what harm is that doing? Especially if the people are >> covering that an economy though, aren't we? We're a culture. We're a language. >> Of course. Okay. So, let's talk about that front. When they come here, they don't have any kind of they're not committing as more more crimes than the people who are already here. That is we've already dispelled that. But that is not you can't dispel us. California. Do you think there's anything wrong that a majority of young people in California speak Spanish, not English? >> Is there Wait, sorry. Can you see the >> Do you think there's anything wrong or troubling to the fact that a majority of people under the age of 30 here in the state speak Spanish, not English? >> Um, >> is there a problem with that? >> Well, yeah. Everyone should be able to have a ability to communicate with the rest of the crowd. >> So, I I guess I don't know what the big issue of that. >> See, I think it's a huge problem when we have a nation where you can't communicate with your fellow. >> Okay. Simple solution. Teach them how to speak English. What is your point? >> Yeah. And that our schools don't do that actually. And also have a better solution. Don't import a bunch of people that don't speak English. >> You mean importing people who actually grow the economy. >> Reject I reject your premise. We are more than >> a premise. That's a study that's been done. >> Do you know what a premise is? I don't actually care as much about economic growth cuz we're one nation under we're one nation under GD. We're not one nation under GDP. We're a nation under God. And when we lose social cohesion [cheering] and you import a bunch of people that don't share our values, that don't necessarily always assimilate, that's a major and serious problem. And we are a we are a people first and foremost with a creed. And that creed is falling apart. Mass has not helped that creed. Yes, they might buy more trinkets. They might help depress wages. Massigration of course can help. >> All good things, all great things for America. >> Well, they help major corporations, but you know what they also do? They keep down the wages of working people. If you are a plumber, Yes, of course. If you think about it, if you're a plumber, electrician, or a welder, and you have to compete against someone from Nicaragua who's willing to do it for five bucks less an hour, that depresses the wages of the American citizen, >> right? Yeah. So, there's been studies I've done that also like counteract that. >> illegal immigrants. No, let's use our studies. Let's use our statistics. >> How about our reason? So, we've had mass migration for 20 years. Have wages gone up? >> I I don't know. >> No, they haven't, actually. So, forget your studies. For 10 years, we've had for 10 years, we've had 30 million people come into America, >> wages have gone down dramatically. Maybe there's a reason why. >> Okay. Okay. >> So, what I encourage you to do just because there's a study that confirms you should use your reason and look actually at self-evident truths. Be like, "Huh, does that make sense? Can you name >> statistics are self-evident truths?" >> Well, not always. Statistics are very misleading. Yes. you like for example I could say did you know that 600 people a year die because of seat belts well that's a misleading statistic because over 100 thousand lives are saved by seat belts that's an incomplete statistic >> wait okay so where where is the so that's a gray area so where's the gray area where people are talking about where 26% of illegal immigrants who come here commit less crimes than native born >> okay we have how many times have we been over this that's just not correct >> that is correct that is correct >> every single crime it doesn't matter >> this is a study that was done in Texas the most diverse second most diverse Every crime an illegal commits is one that should never have happened. It is a period. They should not be here. So I don't care about the rate. The rate is irrelevant. So let me just ask one final question. >> It is relevant. >> Someone broke into the country and cut in line. What should happen to them? >> Well, they get they're given ideally there's a system. Ideally there's a system that's merit based where these people then become part of the part of the the citizen like they become a legal citizen. >> Yeah. I mean we have clarity but not agreement. I say deport them all back to their country of origin and put Americans first. >> That's not that's not an appropriate solution when >> the American people voted for it and it is appropriate. >> It isn't appropriate because most of the people that do come here illegally contribute positively to society. Not again, dude. Statistically, everything backs this. >> You're not listening to anything I'm saying and that's fine. They take jobs from Americans. They depress wages. They steal social security numbers. They commit a crime every single day that they're here. They flood our public schools. They flood our social services. They flood our hospitals. They are a burden on the taxpayer. They should go back and make their own country great again and apply and become a legal immigrant if they want to live here. Thank you very much. >> Thank you. [applause and cheering] >> In in Europe, we having a a big problem with illegal immigration. People are coming that they don't respect our laws that woman stabbing is dangerous to go around. So I don't understand when people come here to talk to you liberals saying that they want to welcome them because you don't know who is entering in your country. >> Amen. And I'll tell you we need more legal immigrants like you in this country. I'll tell you what [cheering] >> and it makes me upset that for me for me it's difficult. I'm respecting the law. I'm here if I I have to be here legally. I'm going to go back to Italy because I cannot work. And it makes me upset seeing someone that comes here illegally and does whatever he wants. That's it. >> My name's Ellie. Overall, just to go into my question, I I am on I am conservative. So, going into this, I was like, oh, like what what should what should I ask you about? I think overall I was going through different policies and in general I agree. Ultimately, I think the topic of my question is how to approach politics in school and in general with this function. I found that a lot of times when I talk to people who are on the other side of me, they are surprised to find out what I think and my ideas are not that crazy. It's like when you actually get into the meat of it, it's like, oh, actually maybe it does make sense. And so I think it's really valuable to start giving these ideas to the world. And so this is this is one of these options. But I guess my question is, is this the best way? Because when I um when I hear like for example on Reddit, they're like, don't approach him. Don't do this. He's just doing that. He's doing this. He's doing that. He's using all these tactics. And so I wonder if you've considered not to say that this is a bad way to go about it, but if there's maybe a slightly better way because I think what you're saying has a lot of value in this world, but it's propon like in this school specifically, it is thought of as evil and is like not like a a valid way to >> that's a UC San Diego problem, not not a Charlie problem, right? >> No. And it's not and it's and it's not to say it's a problem of you. No, no, no. And meaning like if and I read the there was some op-ed journalists where they said ignore Charlie, you know, ignore him. But what they're saying is that they are not either smart enough or they're not intellectually mature enough to have a discussion with a conservative on any issue. I have literally almost no notes. I have like a couple charts to show you if the topics come up. You guys can use AI, you guys can use Grock, you could use whatever you want. You could bring a professor, you could bring five of your top libs together. >> Debate me, right? >> Yeah. >> Do I other side? Okay. Thank you. And you guys can debate me at any time. I I I fail to understand why. Well, actually, I know the reason. Speech is not a left-wing value. And they do not believe in freedom of speech. They believe in totalitarian control. There are exceptions to that. So, if they have a problem, I I think this is one of the best ways, not the best way. I literally could not be more open to disagreement. I say if you disagree, you go to the front of the line. >> Yeah. And I mean, how often do you as conservatives get a chance to challenge liberals on campus, right? And being welcomed ever. >> Absolutely. Almost never. Definitely not. >> Because speech is not a leftwing value. >> No. But to say that I mean with all of that being said, that is very true. But ultimately what happens here is I see a lot of like the ideas just being like bubbled against. And so like when I talk to my friends, they're not their ideas aren't changed from these conversations. And so I wonder if there's just like a >> You would be surprised. Sorry to interrupt. What we what happens here gets seen hundreds of millions of times on social media. Absolutely. The crowds are growing. And so, look, some people are going to remain close-minded. They're not going to, you know, have their horizons open, but that's on them, right? They have to actually want to pursue the truth and not just have their own worldview confirmed. >> And then I guess that's where I I disagree because I think fundamentally there is truth within anything. And I believe that maybe I would ask you like to say to or to see that like you have a big role in this. You have a big fan base and a big media base that you can make you are making incredible change. And to take it one just one step further would be really trying to push the narrative against this being like a place where people are just like debating. It's it's more than that. >> What would you like to see? >> I no I guess maybe it's more of a question. And I guess I don't know move like moving forward like trying to m maybe um to see that like instead of using these really fast tactics and to really like try to bring it down. Not to say someone is No, no. I not to say that they're No, >> I I disagree with all that. That's fine. >> Yeah. >> I I mean you're thinking way too much about libs on Reddit. I care about normal people. So >> No, I And no, but the >> I mean you did bring up Reddit. I'm sorry. You're like >> No, I guess that's true. No. And I guess >> these people are not well socially adjusted, right? I talked to the 90% of the American people that actually want to make something of their life and you know have kids and >> no and I I couldn't agree more with that like stance. I guess maybe stepping away from Reddit, it's to me the people on this campus, this is a school I go to and almost everyone I'm surrounded with has a completely different view from me and I'd love >> Not everybody. >> No. No. And this is like but this like the people here to find them it feels like you're like sipping through a needle in a hay stack. >> You want a hat? >> Sure. >> All right. Thank you very much. >> I think when we talk about abortion I think we really get into this um idea of like when we should assign personhood, right? So um uh you clearly believe that life begins at conception and I think it would be better if we shift the uh if we shift that metric to a more based on sentience and I believe that like um and the question I have for you is that like since you believe that life begins at at birth let's say we have a person that's grown to old age and they have died and they have um they have absolutely showing no brain activity at all. Um would you believe that like you know that person uh that dead person is the equivalent of like a human life? Yeah, I mean it is a human life, but those are two totally separate things. One, one is no more and the other one's not yet, >> right? >> So, so not yet is different than no more. If someone's at the end of their life and there's nothing more we can do to continue their life, that is a different moral conversation than someone that has not yet been completely grown as a human, as you and I. Two totally different moral circumstances. So, you can't conflate the two, >> right? Um, but I think they both have the same problem where like uh that uh it's it's about the presence of consciousness, right? Then, >> no, it's not a problem. One consciousness will come, one will the one will not. >> That's so they're two separate things. One has potentiality, one does not. So you can't conflate the two. >> Okay. Let's say like let me use a different analogy then. Let's say um I have a blueprint to a building, right? And uh I have the materials for the building and you destroy those materials. Um that the materials of of the building isn't the building in itself. Can we both agree that there's a difference between those two? >> Is the building building itself in real time and it's currently being constructed and it's going up up? Oh, but it still doesn't matter because then they're still adding value to the fact that we're creating the >> bad analogy. A blueprint because the blueprint not itself is not the building, >> right? Exactly. So like a human being's DNA is not just agree on that though. The blueprint is not the building. So there's probably different moral qualifications there. >> No, they're not. I'm saying though that the baby is the building. So you're incorrect. >> Okay. So the baby the building is following the blueprint. >> So when you're looking at like like I don't know like a fertilized egg, you're telling me this a picture of this fertilized egg is the equivalent of a human life right now. Right now the exact same. the difference. >> They're different stage of development. >> So why should stage of development give you more rights? >> Well, I mean we we Okay, you're acting like this is not something this is done in society. Like for example, we do judge based on different stages of development like cognitive capabilities, right? I'm not letting a fetus drive a car. A fetus can't drive to life. >> Apply the right to life. >> This is a little bit different. So my I guess my I guess a different question I would have to ask you is like why um do so why is your so I'm I'm assuming your two qualifications here are the fact that like it can create it's a unique cellular organism right that has the potential to >> and it's human which is inherently has dignity >> so so okay so I guess then this this brings a question because I know there's another scenario where this occurs right where fertilization of an egg occurs and they're they have they're on on track to development correct and this other example that I'll think of is like animals right I think um Do we give the why do we not give the same moral consideration to animals as we are to like like zygot in this situation? >> Animals aren't human beings. >> Okay. So, but why is human beings? >> Human beings have a soul and animals do not >> have a soul. So, so levels. So, exact. So, this is my point. It's a conscious experience. You are you are dishonest. This is honest though. Let me prove it to you. When someone is quote unquote brain dead, do you know that they still respond if someone stabs them? Their norepinephrine goes up. Do you know that a woman still me menrates if she's brain dead? So, consciousness is not human worth. There's something else going on beyond consciousness that exists in a being that is the soul. >> Okay. So, now we're getting into a conversation what the difference between the soul and a consciousness is. And >> no, they're totally different. The soul is the something beyond consciousness is your narration to yourself. Your ability to reason. There's something above reason. All of us know what that is when it kicks in. You ever hear the expression words can't describe I am speechless. You know why? Speech is reason. When you see a sunset that takes your breath away. When you see a newborn life that is born, you don't even have the words to express it because it transcends you. That is your soul. So, so I mean that's a good point like when when we give so you what you just label there is like when a child is given born when when they're born we give such moral significance to that not the fact that like they got infertilized by an egg I don't want to celebrate I want to sort of I'd rather celebrate my birthday rather than like you know the day my parents had sex that's kind of a little weird situation you know what I mean like if life begins at concept conception >> well it's called your birthday for a reason but you were you were a living being >> it seems that like society nine months prior >> gravitates to this idea of like an actual human being existing No value, right? One is your entrance to the world. The other one is the actual creation of your being. Two different things. Your birthday is when you entered the world. For example, your birthday could be at 28 weeks, not 36 weeks. So, everybody has a different day when you exit the womb, but it's not when your worth begins. That's not when your value begins. That's simply when you exit the womb. >> Right. Right. So, I I have a good question. I really want to get back to this uh idea of like you give more moral value to the level of the fact that like that humans that are developed have a soul in comparison to like you know a zygote that or actually no animals. >> Okay. So is that not the same comparison to like a zygote to a developed human being in in the sense that like like um we are a higher fire higher functioning cog conscious being in comparison to like this other thing that we can just actively kill whenever >> doesn't matter. I mean, can you actively kill a one-year-old? Doesn't have as much acuity as you do or consciousness, >> right? Yeah. But like I mean, can you kill a one-year-old? >> That's the same thing because like this is going back to my >> What's the difference between a one-year-old and a and a one day old Zyo? What's the moral difference? >> Uh the level of consciousness. >> Oh, so one's bigger, one's more developed, one's older. The consciousness is completely irrelevant cuz just you know that a one day old out of the womb doesn't have a lot of consciousness at all. It can't speak. It can't really It's kind of like disimbabulated. But you don't get less rights for that. Yeah, I I I agree. I mean like well to a certain degree I agree with that. But like there but there is a meaningful difference between a fertilized egg and a conscious human being. One is one is less conscious than the other. >> Oh no. Or one is more skills but like what's the what's the innate moral difference and prove it to me? >> Um because we it seems like we do give restrict rights and we do actually change rights based on development and consciousness. >> No life. So like a four-year-old, right? What is the innate moral difference of a four-year-old and a zygote? >> One is more conscious. >> Okay, got it. So I think that's irrelevant. I think they're both human beings deserving a protection. Consciousness alone is not a marker of dignity. >> Okay. So then what is your marker of dignity? Is >> being a human being. >> Being a human being. So your is your argu argument a little bit circular though? There is like it's just because we are we deserve rights because we're human being. >> Yeah. Of course. I mean it's self-evident. We are human beings with a soul. Therefore we have rights. >> So So it's we're we deserve rights because we're human beings because we're human beings. So like how am I supposed to win against this argument here? >> You can't >> see. Okay. Yeah. Exactly. So it's it's called it's called a self-evident truth. So, so >> it's called self-evidence. So there it is. That's why the pro-life position is irrefutable is that because you have to posit human beings have rights >> and and that's that isn't that a kind of a concern that like we we base all our entire ideology on this one illogical circle that >> it's not illogical. It's incredibly logical. We are human beings and we believe that they matter. >> If you were remove this this circle here, then you would have to actually be pro-life in that sense to be pro- life to all life. >> Oh, we are. >> Right. So animals kind of believe human beings are I'm not like a vegan or anything. I'm >> human beings are not the moral same as a as a bird. It's not the same thing >> for multiple reasons because a human being has characteristics and qualities and most importantly we believe as Christians human beings have a soul that a bird does not have. >> Okay. So characteristics and qualities >> only let me interrupt one more. The west whether you agree or not sorry to interrupt. We believe the human being is the only thing made in the image of the creator. A mo day. >> Okay. Okay. So when you say characteristics and qualities what does that mean to me? What does that mean to me? Well, first of all, not just the ability to reason, but also the ability to sympathize, empathize, feel, predict, plan, conjecture, have mercy, forgiveness, to be able to be introspective. >> I love that. I love that about us human beings. >> Oh, no. I know. >> I'm not being sarcastic. We human beings are exceptional actually. I mean, versus the the beasts of the wild, which we should appreciate and adore. But again more beyond that we come after this from a soft religious view because you don't have to be Christian to believe this right that the human being has innate inherent >> um embedded let's just say dignity that a fox does not >> right yeah so what you just did there is kind of like my argument here you're you're you're saying that like because we are human we are more developed we are we have higher cognitive reasoning we're able to emo sympathize emotion and reason do all these great things right but the thing is well I guess that's That's a that's a that's an that's a religious belief though. >> Well, that's an interesting question. >> I think that consciousness is the soul. >> And that's that's where we that's where why if you don't believe in God, it's easy to go want to murder a bunch of people. And I'm not I'm not criticizing you. It goes back to just a common theme here. If you believe in God, every human being has dignity. >> Well, you you're kind of intuition pumping there about saying if it's murder because we haven't really discuss we haven't even agreed on course if it's a human being and an elimination of life. Is it murder? But that's fine. We're not We're just This is why it's very hard to change people that don't believe in God to be pro-life because you don't you don't necessarily believe that human life is necessarily special. >> No, I I mean I do >> but you might think it's like unique and it's like interesting. It is but you don't believe it's made in the image of a creator. >> Okay. Yeah. >> And that's fine. And that that's why we tend to be the pro-life champions and those that don't believe in God don't. And that's okay. It's just that that that clarity is important for the audience. >> Okay. So I I guess we're we can keep going back and forth. I'm sure you got to hold on. I want to give some more people, but I I I do I do want to have a good question with you. Uh a question about um that I want to leave off on is so it seems like it's it's I I I think you're pretty set in stone in this in this position and I would I would like to ask what would I have to do or prove to show you in order to convince you that pro-life isn't the answer that society should be seeking for. >> I mean, it would be impossibility. You have to prove to me God doesn't exist. >> Okay. So, so then we can agree that like this is just a a moral issue that you're appealing to a book. >> Of course. I mean all moral issues appeal to an authority obviously. Why is murder wrong? >> I mean cuz it Well, the reason if you want to talk about morality, we can talk about morality. >> Abortion is a moral issue. Of course it is. >> Yeah. But the reason why >> our whole conversation is laced with morality. >> But in order to kind of like reduct it to like a textbook or a book or a specific like where do you get your morality from? >> Well, I think morality should be based on like what is the best choice of action to help society progress. That makes any sense. >> Okay, got it. What What if society agrees we should kill the dumb people? Well, um, probably not the best. >> Well, about you. But why? >> The thing is the thing is the thing is automatically that doesn't work because in Iceland it's it's it's mandatory to abort down syndrome babies. >> Okay. >> But it's best, right? Down syndrome people are a strain on society. Why do you say it's wrong? >> I mean, because there's some degree of like like uh we should protect some people. >> Why? By what standard? Why are you appealing to I appeal to a book? What do you appeal to? The thing is I I I think like there's still some value to be what standard. Is that your opinion or is there something transcended telling you that? >> No, there's something transcended because like there is some sacredity to life and that's what I agree with. I I agree that life is sacred. That that that's why I would agree that if you if you adopted a more broader pro pro-life stance, I think I would be more on side of that. Like if you want to have a society where forcing women to breed and pump out children, then I I would say you would have to create that society where like it is um uh more able for them to do that. And in addition to not not be indiscriminate between life. So I think >> I I would agree with that sentiment. Right.