Charlie Kirk Interviews Former Muslim Ridvan Aydemir on Why Islam is Incompatible with Western Civilization

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Charlie Kirk Sits Down with Bill Maher on Club Random: Discussing Faith, Politics, and Cultural Battles

Charlie Kirk Sits Down with Bill Maher on Club Random: Discussing Faith, Politics, and Cultural Battles

1:10:43

Andrew Sedra Escapes Islamic Death Threats to Warn America About LGBTQ Paganism and Muslim Brotherhood Infiltration

Andrew Sedra Escapes Islamic Death Threats to Warn America About LGBTQ Paganism and Muslim Brotherhood Infiltration

1:06:06

Charlie Kirk Sits Down With Former OnlyFans Creator Nala Ray on Faith, Redemption, and Leaving the Porn Industry

Charlie Kirk Sits Down With Former OnlyFans Creator Nala Ray on Faith, Redemption, and Leaving the Porn Industry

1:23:38

Charlie Kirk banner
2,422 videos 1,389,747,653 views US Joined Aug 30, 2018

Charlie Kirk is the Founder and President of Turning Point USA, the largest and fastest growing conservative youth activist organization in the country with over 250,000 student members, over 150 full-time staff, and a presence on over 2,000 high school and college campuses nationwide. Charlie is also the Chairman of Students for Trump, which aims to activate one million new college voters on campuses in battleground states in the lead up to the 2020 presidential election. His social media reaches over 100 million people per month and according to Axios, he is one of the "top 10 most engaged" Twitter handles in the world. He is also the host of “The Charlie Kirk Show,” which regularly ranks among the top news shows on Apple podcast charts.

Charlie Kirk Interviews Former Muslim Ridvan Aydemir on Why Islam is Incompatible with Western Civilization

Charlie Kirk sits down with Ridvan Aydemir, known as the Apostate Prophet, a former Muslim turned Christian who escaped Islam after discovering disturbing truths about Muhammad and the Quran. Ridan grew up in Germany in a strict Turkish Muslim household, became an atheist after reading the Quran for himself, and eventually found Christianity through studying the historical evidence for Christ. In this powerful conversation, Ridan exposes the incompatibility of Islam with Western values, reveals what the Quran actually teaches about violence and women, and warns that Islamic expansion in America and Europe is by design, not accident. He faces death threats daily for speaking the truth about Islam.

August 3, 2025

From Strict Muslim Upbringing to Christian Faith

Ridvan Aydemir, who runs the YouTube channel Apostate Prophet, shares his journey from being raised in a strict Sunni Muslim household in Germany to becoming a Christian. Born to Turkish immigrant parents, Ridan grew up in a home where music was forbidden and he was taught from a young age not to trust Christians or Jews. He recalls attending a religious gathering as a child where he heard that Muslims would one day fight and kill Jews, and that even rocks and trees would call out to help Muslims find Jews hiding behind them.

Growing up in Germany created a unique tension for Ridan. At school, he encountered beautiful aspects of Christian and Western culture, while at home he was taught that non-Muslims could not be trusted. This contradiction planted seeds of doubt that would eventually lead him away from Islam.

Reading the Quran Led to Leaving Islam

As a late teenager, Ridan became very dedicated to his Muslim faith and started reading the Quran seriously for the first time. This decision changed everything. Muslims are taught that the Quran is the best book ever written and that nobody can write anything better. However, when Ridan actually read it, he found it confusing, disorganized, and problematic.

The Quran contains 114 suras (chapters) that are not arranged chronologically but rather by length, with the longest chapters first. This makes the text jump around without clear narrative flow. Ridan describes reading the Quran as difficult and even stupid, contrasting it with the Bible, which he finds coherent and moving.

The more Ridan studied Islam's foundational texts, including the hadiths (traditions attributed to Muhammad), the more disturbed he became by what he discovered about the religion's founder and its teachings.

Ten Years as an Unhappy Atheist

After leaving Islam, Ridan became an atheist for approximately ten years. During this time, he tried to convince himself and others that he was happy and free from religious fairy tales. But internally, he struggled deeply with meaning and purpose.

Ridan describes wrestling with nihilism and the inherent contradiction of trying to find meaning in meaninglessness. He attempted to embrace the absurdity of life without purpose, but found it extremely difficult and ultimately unsustainable. Throughout this decade, he maintained respect for religion, particularly Christianity, even while identifying as an atheist.

Discovering the Historical Evidence for Christianity

What eventually led Ridan toward Christianity was discovering that everything he had been told about the New Testament being unreliable was false. As a skeptic and atheist, he had been taught that Christianity relied on accounts written long after Jesus by people who never witnessed anything firsthand.

When Ridan actually investigated the historical evidence, he was shocked to discover this was completely wrong. He learned that Luke was a first-class historian commissioned to research and document the life of Jesus. He discovered that Paul met directly with Jesus' disciples and apostles, spending extensive time with those who had personally witnessed Christ's miracles and teachings.

The historical verification of Christianity impressed Ridan as someone who valued evidence and reason. He felt betrayed that for ten years as a skeptic, he had been lied to about the robust historical foundation of the Christian faith.

Finding Peace in Orthodox Christianity

Ridan's wife moved toward Christianity before he did. One day she asked him to read a passage from Romans about how Paul could do nothing of his own and it was all God. Though initially resistant, Ridan became fascinated and ended up reading all of Romans, then investigating how Paul came to his conclusions.

What moved Ridan toward Christianity was both intellectual and emotional. He explored Judaism and had great respect for it, but something felt incomplete when he tried Jewish prayers. When he prayed as a Christian for the first time, he felt something return that had died within him decades ago.

Ridan joined the Eastern Orthodox Church, attracted to its humble theological approach. Orthodox theology focuses more on what God is not rather than claiming to define precisely what God is. This mystery and humility appealed to Ridan, contrasting with what he saw as Western theology's tendency to describe God's attributes with excessive precision.

Muhammad: Warlord, Pedophile, and Islam's Perfect Example

In Islam, Muhammad is considered the greatest man who ever lived and the perfect moral example for all mankind for all times. This presents massive problems when examining his actual biography.

Muhammad was a warlord responsible for tens of thousands of deaths. He married Aisha when she was six years old and consummated the marriage when she was nine, while he was in his fifties. This was not simply a product of different times—Muhammad is supposed to be the perfect example for all people in all eras, including today.

When Islamic clerics defend this, they argue that times were different, that Aisha transmitted important religious knowledge (suggesting this somehow justified the relationship), or that girls are ready for marriage when they show signs of physical development. Some reformist Muslims try to claim she was older, perhaps eight or ten, as if this makes a meaningful difference.

Muhammad also kept multiple wives and sex slaves. According to Islamic tradition, he traveled to heaven on an animal and saw that the majority of hell's inhabitants were women, whom he told needed to be more obedient and grateful.

What the Quran Actually Teaches

The Quran is considered the literal word-for-word dictation of Allah, delivered through the angel Gabriel to Muhammad, who recited it to his followers. After Muhammad's death, his companions compiled these recitations into the book Muslims have today.

Ridan explains that Surah 4, ironically titled "Women," contains some of the most disturbing teachings. Verse 24 directly allows sex slavery, stating Muslims may have sex with those they are married to and with those they possess through war. Verse 34 declares that men are superior to women, that wives must obey their husbands, and that if a husband fears arrogance from his wife, he should admonish her, separate from her in bed, and if necessary, beat her.

According to Aisha herself, Muhammad's child bride, Muslim women suffered more than any other women. She described a woman coming to complain about her husband's beatings, her skin greener than her green clothes from bruising, yet Muhammad essentially justified the beating.

Surah 9, verse 29 commands Muslims to fight Jews, Christians, and others until they are humiliated and pay the jizya (protection money). The options are convert to Islam, pay the tax in humiliation, or face death.

Islam's Expansion by the Sword

One of the fundamental differences between Christianity and Islam is how they spread. Christianity began with Jesus taking on flesh, becoming the lowest among humanity, and inviting people to follow Him. His followers spread the faith through preaching while being persecuted, often losing their lives for centuries before Christianity became widespread.

Islam began very differently. Muhammad started his Islamic state in Medina and immediately began raiding and attacking others. After his death, his successors continued this pattern, spreading Islam through violent conquest. Most Muslim territories today are the result of military campaigns, not peaceful conversion.

The medieval Muslim scholar Ibn Khaldun wrote in his work Muqaddimah that the great difference between Judaism, Christianity, and Islam is that Islam alone has a truly universal mission. The leader of Islam, the caliph, is supposed to be simultaneously the religious leader, military leader, and state leader, with the duty to spread Islam by will or by force.

No Separation of Mosque and State

In Islam, it is considered haram (forbidden) to establish laws separate from what Allah has established. Secularism itself is not allowed in Islamic theology. Muslims have a religious duty to establish Islam as the governing force wherever they are, or to leave.

This makes Islam fundamentally incompatible with Western concepts of religious freedom and separation of church and state. Islam is not merely a religion—it is a comprehensive political, legal, and social system that demands total implementation.

Taqiya and Deception

While sometimes misrepresented, there is truth to the claim that Islam permits lying in certain circumstances. Taqiya specifically allows Muslims to conceal their faith when revealing it would cause them trouble or danger.

However, the permission to deceive goes beyond taqiya. The Quran authorizes Muslims to speak in whatever way benefits Islam and Muslims. Muhammad permitted Muslims to deceive the enemies of Islam, and enemies of Islam are defined as anyone who is not Muslim.

Islam's Deliberate Expansion in the West

Ridan confirms that the Muslim world is thrilled about Islam's growth in the West. As a child in Germany, he repeatedly heard that it was wonderful that Muslims were taking over and their numbers were growing. He hears the same message today.

In the UK, Canada, and Australia, Muslim preachers openly say their vision is to take over Western nations through growing numbers and increasing political involvement. While America has not reached that stage yet, Ridan warns that quick action is needed to prevent it.

Muslim communities in Michigan, Minnesota, Texas, and elsewhere openly speak about spreading Islam and growing their influence. They frame it as peaceful, but Ridan warns that once enough power is concentrated in hands that want to establish Islam as the governing force, it will be extremely difficult to take back control.

Why Islam is Incompatible with Western Civilization

When asked directly if Islam is compatible with Western civilization, Ridan says absolutely not. Western civilization was formed and shaped by Christianity and classical philosophy. Islam is fundamentally anti-Christian, ordering the subjugation, destruction, and eventual elimination of Christianity.

Islam is also anti-freedom. In Turkey, despite being a secular NATO member, Ridan faces multiple lawsuits from the government for saying things like "the Quran is a book of ignorance." He cannot safely return to Turkey because there is no freedom of speech regarding Islam.

The freedoms Americans cherish—freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of conscience—are incompatible with Islamic law. If given power, Islam will use those freedoms to abolish the very freedoms that allowed it to grow.

What Should the Western Response Be?

Ridan offers several recommendations for how the West should address Islam. First, realize what you are dealing with. Understand that Islam is not simply a religion but a comprehensive political and legal system incompatible with Western values.

Second, acknowledge this incompatibility directly and make policies accordingly. Do not allow Muslims to take advantage of well-meaning attitudes and liberal immigration policies to spread political Islam.

Third, if you see Islam spreading and political Islam taking root, remove it through policy before it is too late. The freedoms established in the West were meant for people who share those values and can sustain them together, not for anti-freedom groups that want to abolish those freedoms and oppress others.

While this may be controversial, Ridan argues that allowing every anti-freedom ideology to exploit Western freedoms in order to destroy those freedoms is suicidal for Western civilization.

The Personal Cost of Speaking Truth

As an apostate from Islam who speaks publicly about its teachings, Ridan receives numerous death threats. Muslims tell him they will behead him and rape his family. This, he notes with dark irony, is the "religion of peace."

Under Islamic law, the penalty for apostasy is death. Ridan is considered especially dangerous because he studied Arabic and knows the original Islamic texts well. Muslims cannot dismiss his criticisms by claiming mistranslation or lack of context.

Despite the threats and danger, Ridan continues speaking out because he believes Islam is the biggest threat to free societies. While many focus on various political entities trying to subvert the West, he sees Islam as the greatest subversive force because once it gains sufficient power, it will not allow that power to be taken back.

A Call to Address the Most Important Issue

Ridan's final message is that ignorance among non-Muslims is the most disturbing aspect of Islam's growth. While many people speak about various topics online, he believes the biggest threat to Western societies and free nations is Islam, and people need to be talking about it seriously.

He emphasizes that this should be just the beginning of the conversation. Western societies must start speaking up more about this issue because it is absolutely central to preserving freedom and Western civilization.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!