James Li Revisits Charlie Kirk's Prescient October 7th Questions Israel Still Won't Answer
Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.
Up Next
George Galloway Examines Israeli Motive in Charlie Kirk Assassination Amid Growing Conservative Shift on Israel
38:00
Tim Dillon and Max Blumenthal Reveal Charlie Kirk's Growing Skepticism Toward Israel and Donor Pressures Before His Death
36:42
Officer Tatum Defends Charlie Kirk's Pro-Israel Legacy Against False Narratives After His Death
30:10
James Li Revisits Charlie Kirk's Prescient October 7th Questions Israel Still Won't Answer
James Li examines the mounting evidence behind Charlie Kirk's controversial October 7th questions, from pre-attack intelligence warnings and repositioned troops to the Nova Festival's last-minute relocation and the alleged Hannibal Directive. Kirk, who was smeared as an anti-Semite for asking whether Israeli leadership ignored or enabled the Hamas attack, accurately predicted both the intelligence failures and the subsequent campaign in Gaza. Nearly three years later, those questions remain unanswered, and the U.S. continues sending billions in aid without accountability. James breaks down the timeline, the warnings Netanyahu allegedly received, and why the right to scrutinize our greatest ally cost Charlie everything.
The official narrative of October 7th, 2023, goes like this: Hamas launched a highly coordinated surprise assault from the Gaza Strip, killing approximately 1,200 Israelis and taking 250 hostage. The victims were primarily civilians across residential kibbutzes, towns, military outposts, and the Nova music festival. Many have called it Israel's 9/11.
Six days after the attack, Charlie Kirk appeared on the PBD podcast to ask a series of questions about how Hamas could have possibly penetrated what is widely considered the most secure border in the entire world. His questions were direct and uncomfortable.
"Was there a stand down order?" Kirk asked. "Six hours? I don't believe it. Israel's the size of New Jersey. When I took a helicopter ride from Jerusalem to the Gaza border, it's 45 minutes. Six hours. They're live streaming the killing of Jews. Did somebody in the government say stand down? That is a legitimate non-conspiracy question."
The Jericho Wall Report
It turns out Charlie was right to ask those questions. One year before October 7th, Israel's chief intelligence officer had in his possession a report code-named Jericho Wall. According to The New York Times, the 40-page document laid out a Hamas attack plan extremely similar to the one carried out in October — a barrage of rockets, drones, and combatants entering on motorcycles and paragliders.
One intelligence officer stated on the record: "I utterly refute that the scenario is imaginary. The Hamas training exercise fully matched the content of Jericho Wall. It is a plan designed to start a war." She wasn't listened to. A former security officer explained the failure: "You have to take it seriously because if somebody comes to the conclusion that is going to happen, you have to go deeper and ask what are the reasons."
It remains unclear whether Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had seen the report, but some believe he holds responsibility for letting Qatar fund Hamas. In leaked remarks, Netanyahu himself reportedly said: "We tamed them with money, with other things. They are okay. We need to keep our cool. It's all a show."
The September Warning Netanyahu Allegedly Ignored
In September 2026, Israeli newspaper Haaretz published a bombshell report claiming Netanyahu received an explicit warning days before October 7th but chose not to brief his security chiefs. According to two sources who spoke with someone on the call, Sheikh Mohammed had called Netanyahu in late September to tell him that, based on information he had received, Hamas was planning to launch an attack.
Netanyahu has denied the report. Not only that, he then took what was described as a secret trip to the UAE later that month to lobby Sheikh Mohammed to publicly deny the Haaretz reporting that said he was warned Hamas was planning a major operation. So far, the UAE has refused to issue such a denial.
Unusual Military and Civilian Movements
Despite numerous warnings that Hamas was planning some kind of attack, two companies of troops from the IDF's Commando Brigade — around 100 soldiers — were repositioned from the Gaza border to the West Bank just two days before October 7th. That decision seems odd given that Israeli officials had been repeatedly telling the public that Hamas was the biggest threat to Israel.
The Nova Festival, where over 300 people were killed by Hamas, was coincidentally moved to a location only a few kilometers away from the Gaza border two days before the event. The horrific images of hundreds of charred vehicles burnt to a crisp prompted many to speculate whether the Israeli military had issued something called the Hannibal Directive, which calls for the military to use heavy firepower and aggressive measures to stop a kidnapping in progress even if it meant killing their own. This very controversial military tactic has since been confirmed by Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant.
Charlie Kirk's Second Prediction: Ethnic Cleansing
Charlie Kirk didn't just predict the intelligence failure. He also predicted what would follow. "The fact is now Bibi and the Israeli hard-right government has a mandate — I got to be careful the way I say this — they're going to try to ethnically cleanse Gaza," Kirk said. "I mean, that's — and I don't use that term lightly, okay? They're talking about basically removing 2.5 million people from there."
After Israel captured Gaza in 1967, Israeli leaders like Levi Eshkol, Golda Meir, and Defense Minister Moshe Dayan all explicitly discussed the so-called thinning or diluting of Gaza's refugee population. Facing international condemnation, this kind of extreme policy was never implemented by Israel. But post-October 7th, some in Netanyahu's cabinet have revived and publicized versions of this idea, with Bezalel Smotrich calling for complete victory and the resettling of Gaza.
This goal to permanently expel Palestinians from the Gaza Strip has received some support from the Trump administration, with Donald Trump naming his son-in-law Jared Kushner to lead the $2.45 billion recovery plan for Gaza — a recovery plan that would necessitate the relocation of millions of Palestinians.
The Price Charlie Kirk Paid for Asking Questions
Charlie Kirk, who was unmistakably a part of the pro-Israel coalition, was himself smeared as an anti-Semite and even worse than a Holocaust denier for asking these questions. On his birthday, while planning to watch the Oregon vs. Washington game, Kirk received a call from Andrew Kolvet on Shabbat. "Charlie, you're going viral. Everyone says you're a Holocaust denier and all this. It's terrible," Kolvet told him.
"I said, 'What are you talking about?' I said, 'I'm the most pro-Israel guy out there,'" Kirk recalled. "And they said, 'Well, now, you're not allowed to even, again, let me re-emphasize, calling me on Shabbat, okay?' You're not allowed to, apparently, with the new rules of this sick world we live in, you're not allowed to even ask, 'Was there an intel failure leading into the October 7th massacre?'"
Ben Shapiro of The Daily Wire wrote on Twitter: "If Charlie Kirk remains the head of TPUSA, the right has an anti-Semite problem that will follow them into the coming elections." It looks like they got their wish.
The Questions That Still Need Answers
In December 2023, Charlie Kirk wrote: "Why did Israeli intelligence officials, when notified of unusual activity in Gaza on October 6th, not put one and one together that the planned attack was about to unfold? Why did it take them between 6 and even 20 hours for the IDF to get help to the communities massacred by terrorists?" He then added: "I stand with Israel and its offensive against Hamas, but the US should not spend one more penny in Israel until we have answers to these questions."
Nearly three years later, those questions remain unanswered, and the U.S. continues sending billions in aid without accountability. Charlie Kirk learned during COVID, when they told us the virus came from a bat, when they told us the vaccine was safe and effective, when they told us Ivermectin was horse paste — that you better keep asking questions because it's the only thing that keeps us free.
He paid the heaviest price for daring to question our so-called greatest ally. But the questions he asked were legitimate, and the answers the public deserves have yet to arrive.