Up Next
Charlie Kirk Dismantles Illegal Immigration Myths and Debates Abortion With UC San Diego Students
30:01
Charlie Kirk Debates Abortion, Immigration, and Western Values at Boise State University Campus Tour
51:34
Charlie Kirk Debates Legal Mexican Immigrant Claudio on Deportation Policy and Breaking Immigration Laws
9:12
The Question That Sparked the Debate
At a campus event, Charlie Kirk fielded a question from a Trump-supporting student wearing a MAGA hat. The student asked about the future of immigration policy, specifically regarding his friend who is currently on a student visa. The friend's family had been deported back to Mexico two years prior under the Biden administration. The student wanted to understand Kirk's perspective on how people like his friend could obtain green cards fairly while supporting necessary border security measures like the wall and deportations.
America Must Put Its Own Students First
Kirk offered a candid response that he acknowledged might not win over the student's friend. He explained that his perspective centers on limiting the number of green cards for the time being, arguing that any country would make the same decision. Kirk emphasized that America's primary obligation must be to American students first and foremost, ensuring that young people in the audience can own homes, earn higher wages, and become stakeholders in their own country.
Kirk pointed to a troubling pattern over the last 40 years where America has been overly generous to its own detriment. He highlighted how it has become harder than ever for young Americans to own a home, get married, have children, and achieve the American dream that previous generations enjoyed. While not blaming green card holders entirely for this situation, Kirk argued that policy changes are necessary.
The H-1B Program and Competition for American Jobs
To illustrate his point, Kirk discussed the H-1B visa program, which allows companies to import foreign workers for specialized positions. He used the example of computer science and engineering students at Florida State University, arguing that it is wrong to import workers from foreign countries to compete against American students in these fields. American students who are pursuing degrees in computer engineering and similar programs should be given priority over foreign students, according to Kirk.
This perspective reflects Kirk's broader belief that American educational institutions and the job market should prioritize citizens and provide them with the best opportunities to succeed in their chosen careers without facing unnecessary competition from imported labor.
Merit-Based Immigration as the Path Forward
While taking a restrictive stance on current immigration levels, Kirk clarified that once America returns to a more prosperous and robust economic situation, the country should maintain a merit-based immigration policy. This policy would feature no illegal immigration and very limited legal immigration, with all legal immigration being merit-based.
Kirk acknowledged that the student's friend, who is assimilating to American culture during his time at university, represents the type of person who could qualify under such a system. The student had described his friend as already being more American than most people, very involved in American culture, patriotic, and a Trump supporter. Kirk agreed that the friend appeared to be an exception rather than the rule.
The Assimilation Problem Facing America
The student pressed Kirk on why his patriotic, America-loving friend should face barriers while protesters who don't appreciate America remain in the country. Kirk responded by noting that those born in America have a social contract that comes with citizenship by birth, which must be honored to keep society together.
However, Kirk conceded that the student made a compelling argument on the surface: some newcomers to America do tend to love the country more than its current inhabitants. Despite this valid point, Kirk maintained that as a broad rule, America needs a hard stop on current immigration levels.
Kirk identified what he described as a mass assimilation problem facing the nation. He pointed to figures like Ilhan Omar as examples of immigrants who have shown discord, venom, and ingratitude toward America rather than embracing its values and opportunities. While exceptions like the student's friend can, should, and will be made through a merit-based immigration system, Kirk emphasized that such cases are exceptions, not the rule.
The Unregulated Immigration Crisis
Kirk concluded by finding common ground with the questioning student, noting that they could both agree that far too many foreigners have entered the country over the last couple of years in an unregulated and unruly fashion. This chaotic situation has created the need for a reset in immigration policy.
The exchange illustrated Kirk's position that the time has come to put American students and Americans first. While this approach may disappoint some who are seeking paths to legal status, Kirk framed it as a necessary correction to decades of policies that have made it increasingly difficult for young Americans to achieve economic security and prosperity.
Throughout the conversation, Kirk maintained respect for the student and his friend while holding firm to his policy positions, demonstrating his belief that honest disagreement can coexist with civil discourse.
Video Transcript
[00:00] The Last Rodeo, Angel Studios newest
[00:02] family blockbuster starring Neil Mcdana,
[00:04] hits theaters May 23rd. Become a premium
[00:07] member and get two free tickets to see
[00:09] The Last Rodeo on the big screen. Plus,
[00:11] stream other Angel exclusives like
[00:13] Homestead, The Shift, and more. Help
[00:15] choose which movies get made and support
[00:18] films and filmmakers that share your
[00:20] values. Join the Angel Guild now at
[00:22] angel.com/charlie. Don't miss The Last
[00:24] Rodeo, only in theaters.
[00:27] All right. So, uh, my question has to
[00:29] like pertain more to illegal immigration
[00:30] and, uh, like green cards and
[00:32] everything. Obviously, I got the Trump
[00:33] hat on. I agree with most of what you
[00:35] stand for, but I wanted to ask and have
[00:37] you like clarify obviously the border
[00:39] wall and deportations and everything are
[00:42] like necessary now, but what do you see
[00:44] as the future for like a policy to get
[00:46] people like my friend here that he's on
[00:48] a student visa now, his family was
[00:50] deported back to Mexico. How can someone
[00:53] like him get a green card and his
[00:55] family? Where do you see the government
[00:56] going with that and getting people green
[00:58] cards fairly instead of making When was
[01:00] your family deported? Recently. Two
[01:02] years ago. Oh, two years under Biden.
[01:04] Okay.
[01:06] Interesting. Um, so uh yeah, look, my my
[01:11] perspective might not win him over. I'll
[01:13] be perfectly honest. Uh I think we
[01:14] actually need to limit the amount of
[01:16] green cards for the time being. And I
[01:17] think any country would make the same
[01:19] decision. Our obligation needs to be to
[01:21] American students first and foremost to
[01:23] make sure that the people in this
[01:24] audience can own homes, have higher
[01:26] wages, and be stakeholders in their
[01:28] country. So, I might not win over your
[01:29] friend here and that's okay, but at
[01:31] least he can have understanding where
[01:32] I'm coming from. Every country should
[01:34] look after their own country first and
[01:36] foremost. And the problem is the pattern
[01:38] over the last 40 years is we have been
[01:40] overly generous to a detriment to
[01:42] ourselves. And just for an example,
[01:43] people in this audience, it is harder
[01:45] than ever for you guys to own a home, to
[01:47] get married, to have kids, to be able to
[01:49] achieve the American dream that your
[01:51] parents had. I'm not saying that green
[01:52] card holders are an expense to that. But
[01:54] if and one is just does Florida State
[01:56] have a computer engineering program?
[01:58] Maybe it doesn't or something similar,
[01:59] right? It does. For example, let's just
[02:01] take the H-1B program. I think it's
[02:03] wrong to import workers from foreign
[02:05] countries to compete against you guys as
[02:08] computer science engineering students
[02:10] where you guys should be given priority
[02:11] as American students above foreign
[02:13] students. And so I might not I might not
[02:15] win over your friend here. However, if
[02:17] we can then get back to a prosperous
[02:20] more um robust economic circumstance, we
[02:23] should always have a merit-based
[02:25] immigration policy. No illegal
[02:26] immigration, very limited legal
[02:28] immigration. That should be always
[02:30] merit-based. But for someone like him
[02:32] who's assimilating to America, he's
[02:33] gonna be here for four years. It's his
[02:35] second year here. He's already more
[02:37] American than most of the people I've
[02:39] met. How can we get someone like that? I
[02:42] I I do. What do you mean by that? He's
[02:44] very involved in American culture. He
[02:46] voted for Trump, obviously. You voted
[02:49] with a You voted with a green card. No,
[02:51] I didn't vote, but I was going to say,
[02:52] yeah, he was going to vote. He supported
[02:54] Trump. Yeah, I got it. Supported Trump.
[02:56] Yeah, I got it. But he's very patriotic.
[02:58] And I know you saw the protesters over
[03:00] there. They don't like America. Why are
[03:01] they here and he's not? Well, I mean,
[03:04] well, they they were raised here, so you
[03:06] have to have some social contract for
[03:07] being, you know, born here and keeping
[03:08] that together. I will say you make a
[03:10] good argument on the surface that there
[03:12] are some newcomers that come to America
[03:15] that tend to love the country more than
[03:17] its current inhabitants. That is a good
[03:19] argument. I will say though, as a broad
[03:21] rule, we need to have a hard and fast
[03:23] stop and say that number one, we have a
[03:26] mass assimilation problem. Number two,
[03:28] exceptions like your friend right here
[03:30] can and should and will be made through
[03:32] a merit-based immigration system. But
[03:34] for the time being, he is the exception,
[03:36] not the rule. Far too often, we have
[03:38] people like Elon Omar coming into the
[03:39] country that is showing, you know,
[03:41] discord and venom and ingratitude
[03:43] towards America. And I think we can both
[03:45] agree that we've had way too many
[03:47] people, foreigners coming into the
[03:49] country over the last couple of years in
[03:50] an unregulated, unruly fashion. And it's
[03:53] time to put American students and
[03:54] Americans first. Thank you very much.
[03:56] Appreciate it. Thank you.
[03:58] Yes, sir.
Comments
Be the first to comment on this video.