Sheriff Nate Brooksby Details How Charlie Kirk Assassination Suspect Tyler Robinson Surrendered in Washington County
Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.
Up Next
Kash Patel and Utah Officials Announce Arrest of Tyler Robinson for Charlie Kirk Assassination in 33 Hours
29:51
Angenette Levy Breaks Down Tyler Robinson's Arrest in the Assassination of Charlie Kirk
22:06
The Assassination of Charlie Kirk: How a 22-Year-Old Gunman Cut Short the American Comeback Tour in Utah
9:04
Sheriff Nate Brooksby Details How Charlie Kirk Assassination Suspect Tyler Robinson Surrendered in Washington County
Sheriff Nate Brooksby of Washington County, Utah, reveals the inside story of how Tyler Robinson, the suspect in Charlie Kirk's assassination at Utah Valley University, was convinced to surrender peacefully. Through a retired detective's intervention and delicate negotiations with Robinson's family, law enforcement avoided a violent confrontation. Robinson, a Washington County native who attended the same high school as the sheriff, expressed fears of being shot by police and requested a peaceful surrender. Sheriff Brooksby explains the 33-hour manhunt, the shocking phone call that changed everything, and how his office facilitated the handoff to federal investigators while protecting the suspect's family from public backlash and harassment.
Sheriff Nate Brooksby of Washington County, Utah, was winding down for the evening when his phone rang at exactly 8:02 p.m. on the 11th. On the other end was a retired detective who had worked for him for many years—a friend he trusted implicitly. The detective's voice was shaky, and Brooksby's first thought was that someone had died. What came next was something he could never have imagined.
"I know who Charlie Kirk's shooter is," the retired detective said. "I know the family through religious association, and he's in Washington County now. We're working on trying to get him to come in voluntarily."
The revelation was shocking. Charlie Kirk had been assassinated at Utah Valley University (UVU) that afternoon, triggering a 33-hour manhunt that had law enforcement agencies across Utah on high alert. The suspect, Tyler Robinson, was now in Washington County—and he wanted to surrender peacefully.
Immediate Action and Coordination
The initial phone call lasted exactly one minute and 41 seconds. During that brief conversation, the retired detective provided critical information: Tyler Robinson was experiencing suicidal ideations and had considered going to a remote area of Washington County. His parents had convinced him not to follow through with those plans and assured him they would stand by him and help him surrender peacefully.
Sheriff Brooksby immediately called Sheriff Mike Smith in Utah County, who was at the incident command center. For about 40 seconds, Brooksby explained the situation: "I'm confident we have the shooter in Washington County. We're working on getting him to come in and surrender at my office."
Sheriff Smith was understandably shocked. "Wait, wait, what? What are you talking?" he asked. When questioned about the credibility of the information, Brooksby responded without hesitation: "I trust this guy that called me with my life, and I think it's time you need to get your people, the lead investigators, headed to Washington County."
Negotiating a Peaceful Surrender
The negotiations for Tyler Robinson's surrender required careful handling. Robinson knew that with all the law enforcement pressure, his picture in the news, and the gun on the news, it was inevitable that he would be caught. However, he was fearful of a SWAT team hitting his house or being shot by law enforcement.
Part of the agreement to bring him in was that law enforcement would treat the situation "as delicate and as soft as possible" to make Robinson feel comfortable enough to show up at Sheriff Brooksby's office. The sheriff agreed to these terms, viewing the peaceful surrender as worth the concessions.
"If at the end of the day we accomplish him surrendering peacefully on his own, I'm going to make some concessions to make that happen," Brooksby explained.
The Surrender
Within an hour of the initial phone call, the retired detective drove Tyler Robinson and his parents to the sheriff's office, where they were greeted by plainclothes detectives. Robinson arrived just before 9:00 p.m. He was not handcuffed. Instead, he was placed in a comfortable interview room with his parents, given water, and made to feel as relaxed as possible under the circumstances.
Sheriff Brooksby described Robinson's mood as "quiet and somber." He was not talkative, simply cooperative and subdued. The Washington County Sheriff's Office understood their role clearly: they were not the lead investigating agency. Their job was simply to get Robinson to surrender and then wait for the lead investigators to arrive.
"Our job was not to interview. Our job was just to get him here," Brooksby stated. For approximately two and a half hours, Robinson sat in the interview room with his parents, under supervision but without interrogation, until federal agents and state investigators arrived from Utah County.
The Investigation Handoff
The investigation was a joint effort between the FBI, State of Utah Department of Public Safety, Utah County Sheriff's Office, and UVU. Sheriff Brooksby described his office's involvement as "just a really long agency assist." They were not conducting interviews or leading the investigation—those responsibilities belonged to the lead agencies.
While waiting for the lead investigators to arrive, some of Sheriff Brooksby's detectives were asked to secure two locations: the parents' home in Washington City and the apartment where Tyler was living in St. George, along with the vehicle Tyler was likely driving at UVU. This was purely a security measure to preserve potential evidence until the lead investigators could arrive and conduct proper searches.
By approximately 2:00 a.m., Tyler Robinson was transported to Utah County, relieving Sheriff Brooksby of concerns about how to keep such a high-profile suspect safe in his facility overnight.
Protecting the Innocent
Sheriff Brooksby took the opportunity during the press conference to address false information circulating in the media. Early reports suggested that Matt Robinson, a retired corrections deputy with the Washington County Sheriff's Office, was Tyler Robinson's father and had physically put handcuffs on his son and brought him to jail. This information was completely false.
"Matt Robinson, my retired deputy, has been receiving harassment. He's had to leave his house at this point," Brooksby revealed. The sheriff pleaded with the media to help walk back this false narrative, as an innocent man and his family were suffering consequences for something they had no connection to.
The problem extended beyond just the retired deputy. Sheriff Brooksby mentioned that he had a second cousin with the last name Robinson who happened to be an optometrist in town. His office had been receiving threatening phone calls simply because of the shared last name, despite having no relation to Tyler Robinson's family whatsoever.
The Local Connection
One of the most shocking aspects of the case for Sheriff Brooksby was the local connection. Tyler Robinson was a Washington County native who attended the same high school as the sheriff—they were about 30 years apart, but the connection made the situation feel even more surreal.
"It's a double shock factor that one in Utah and then the suspect happened to be homegrown Washington County boy," Brooksby said. The fact that Robinson had come home rather than fleeing to another state was part of the surprise. Most people accused of such crimes would want to get out of the area as soon as possible, but Robinson returned to his roots.
The Role of Community Trust
Sheriff Brooksby credited the peaceful resolution entirely to the retired detective who made that initial phone call. The key factor was community relations and trust. Tyler Robinson's family trusted this individual because of their religious association—they knew he had been involved in law enforcement and felt comfortable reaching out to him.
Early reports suggested the family friend might have been a youth pastor or church leader, possibly a bishop in their LDS ward. Sheriff Brooksby clarified that while the retired detective was associated with the family through their religious community, he was not in any leadership position. The bishop of that ward had been incorrectly dragged into media reports and was not involved in the surrender.
"The community relations, right? Tyler's family trusted this individual. They knew he was involved in law enforcement at some point and enough community involvement there that they trusted that they could go to this individual and he could contact me directly," Brooksby explained.
Treating the Accused with Humanity
Sheriff Brooksby acknowledged the unusual nature of treating someone accused of such a horrific crime with such civility and care. Robinson sat on a comfortable couch, unrestrained, with a water bottle in his hand, accompanied by his parents. The approach was deliberately non-threatening—no hammer fist, no stormtrooper tactics.
"That's just part of the job. We do that on a regular basis, try to make people comfortable so they're relaxed and not bombarded with negativity," the sheriff said. The goal was a peaceful surrender, and the conditions had to be satisfactory to Robinson to make that happen.
Ongoing Concerns
Sheriff Brooksby expressed concern for the safety of Tyler Robinson's family and roommate when they eventually return to their homes in Washington City and St. George. "They need to lay low for a long time, unfortunately," he advised. The harassment of innocent people sharing the Robinson name demonstrated that the threat of misplaced anger and vigilante justice was very real.
The sheriff's office did not have jurisdiction over the city limits where the family resided, so any protective measures would need to be handled by St. George City Police or Washington City Police. However, the concern was clearly genuine, given the international attention the case had received and people mourning Charlie Kirk all over the world.
The Bigger Picture
The assassination of Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University sent shockwaves not just through Utah but around the world. Sheriff Brooksby noted that this was the kind of incident people say doesn't happen in Utah—except this time, it did. And the suspect wasn't an outsider but a local young man from Washington County.
The sheriff's office received no tips or hints that Robinson might be in the Washington County area during the manhunt. "He could have been anywhere," Brooksby said. The fact that Robinson came home was unexpected, making the retired detective's phone call all the more crucial and timely.
A Successful Resolution
Despite the tragic circumstances that led to the situation, Sheriff Brooksby expressed gratitude that the surrender occurred peacefully. The concessions made to ensure Robinson felt safe enough to turn himself in were worth it. No officers were put in danger, no additional violence occurred, and the investigation could proceed without the complications of a violent confrontation or standoff.
The video recording of Robinson's time in the interview room, standard procedure for the sheriff's office, would provide documentation of the peaceful nature of the surrender and the treatment Robinson received while in Washington County custody.
For Sheriff Nate Brooksby, the experience brought an unexpected level of media attention and scrutiny. But more importantly, it demonstrated the value of community relationships, trust in law enforcement, and the willingness to make difficult decisions in pursuit of a peaceful resolution. The retired detective who made that phone call at 8:02 p.m. deserved full credit for preventing what could have been a far more violent conclusion to the 33-hour manhunt for Charlie Kirk's alleged killer.
