Washington County Sheriff Nate Brooksby Describes the Phone Call That Led to Tyler Robinson's Surrender

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Utah County Prepares for High-Profile Trial in Charlie Kirk Assassination Case Involving Tyler Robinson

Utah County Prepares for High-Profile Trial in Charlie Kirk Assassination Case Involving Tyler Robinson

4:48

Criminal Defense Attorney Phil Harvey Analyzes Charlie Kirk Assassination Charges Against Tyler Robinson

Criminal Defense Attorney Phil Harvey Analyzes Charlie Kirk Assassination Charges Against Tyler Robinson

10:57

Utah County Attorney Jeff Gray Files Aggravated Murder and Death Penalty Charges in Charlie Kirk Shooting Case

Utah County Attorney Jeff Gray Files Aggravated Murder and Death Penalty Charges in Charlie Kirk Shooting Case

45:59

Washington County Sheriff Nate Brooksby Describes the Phone Call That Led to Tyler Robinson's Surrender

Washington County Sheriff Nate Brooksby recounts the night a retired detective and longtime friend called him at exactly 8:02 p.m. on September 11th, telling him he knew the identity of Charlie Kirk's shooter and that the suspect's family was working to bring him in peacefully. Brooksby describes calling Utah County Sheriff Mike Smith within minutes to report that Tyler Robinson was likely in Washington County, then negotiating the terms of a calm, low-key surrender to ease Robinson's fear of being shot by law enforcement or hit by a SWAT team. He details the roughly two-and-a-half-hour wait before federal and state agents arrived to take over the interview, the securing of Robinson's parents' home and his apartment, and the personal weight of learning that the suspect in an assassination drawing global mourning had grown up in his own community and attended the same Washington County high school he once did. The account offers a firsthand look at the tense hours between the shooting a

September 18, 2025

A 33-Hour Manhunt Ends With a Phone Call

Washington County Sheriff Nate Brooksby describes the hours following Charlie Kirk's assassination at Utah Valley University, where a roughly 33-hour manhunt was underway for the shooter. Just as he was winding down for the evening, at exactly 8:02 p.m. on September 11th, Brooksby received a call from a retired detective who had worked under him for years.

"I could tell his voice was kind of shaky. My first thought was, who died," Brooksby says. "I couldn't fathom what actually came out of his mouth."

"I Know Who the Shooter Is"

The retired detective told Brooksby he knew the identity of Charlie Kirk's shooter through a religious connection to the family, and that the suspect, Tyler Robinson, was in Washington County. During the call, which lasted a minute and forty-one seconds, Brooksby learned that Robinson had shown signs of suicidal ideation and had been heading toward a remote area before his parents convinced him to stay and work toward surrendering peacefully.

Calling Sheriff Mike Smith in Utah County

Brooksby immediately called Utah County Sheriff Mike Smith, who was at the incident command post for the investigation.

"I'm confident we have the shooter in Washington County. We're working on getting him to come in and surrender at my office," Brooksby told Smith, who responded with shock and asked how credible the tip was. "I trust this guy that called me with my life," Brooksby said, urging Smith to send lead investigators to Washington County.

Negotiating a Peaceful Surrender

Within the hour, the retired detective drove Robinson and his parents to Brooksby's office, where plainclothes detectives were waiting. Brooksby says Robinson understood his capture was inevitable given the law enforcement pressure and media coverage, but was afraid of a SWAT team raid on his home or of being shot by officers.

"He was truly fearful of being shot by law enforcement," Brooksby says, explaining that he agreed to keep the process as calm and low-key as possible to encourage Robinson to come in voluntarily. Once Robinson arrived, Brooksby's team waited roughly two and a half hours without interviewing him, since they were not the lead agency, until federal and state agents arrived. Detectives were also sent to secure Robinson's parents' home, his apartment, and the vehicle he had likely driven to Utah Valley University.

A Personal and Local Connection

Brooksby reflects on the broader weight of the case, noting the global mourning that followed Kirk's death and his own surprise that the suspect turned out to be a lifelong Washington County resident.

"This kind of stuff doesn't happen in Utah," Brooksby says he had often heard before. "Unfortunately, it did. And then to have the suspect be a Utah resident who literally went to the same high school I went to, thirty years apart, it's a double shock factor."

Comments

Be the first to comment on this video.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!