Up Next

Charlie Kirk Shot at Utah Valley University Rally in Critical Condition After Neck Injury During Campus Tour

Charlie Kirk Shot at Utah Valley University Rally in Critical Condition After Neck Injury During Campus Tour

6:19:35

Charlie Kirk Shot Dead in Utah: How Conservative Activist's Journey From High School Dreamer to MAGA Martyr Unfolded

Charlie Kirk Shot Dead in Utah: How Conservative Activist's Journey From High School Dreamer to MAGA Martyr Unfolded

29:47

Sage Steele Reflects on Charlie Kirk Memorial Service Where Erika Kirk Forgave Husband's Assassin

Sage Steele Reflects on Charlie Kirk Memorial Service Where Erika Kirk Forgave Husband's Assassin

5:09

Related Books

View All

Jack Posobiec and David Axelrod Reflect on Asymmetric Warfare Claims After Charlie Kirk Tragedy

Categories: News
September 13, 2025

Jack Posobiec, a close friend of Charlie Kirk, speaks about the void left by Kirk's passing and who could lead the movement Kirk helped build. Conservative voices debate whether America faces asymmetric civil warfare, while David Axelrod cautions against inflammatory rhetoric. From Utah Governor Spencer Cox's call for de-escalation to contrasting responses from political leaders, the nation grapples with political violence and the power of words in an increasingly divided media landscape.

Asymmetric Warfare: The Conservative Response

Jack Posobiec, a close friend of Charlie Kirk and Turning Point contributor, described the current political climate as asymmetric warfare in the aftermath of Kirk's murder. Speaking to CNN's Anderson Cooper, Posobiec sat in Kirk's studio, leaving Kirk's chair symbolically open as a tribute. When asked how to fill the void left by Kirk, Posobiec was clear: "There's no replacement for Charlie Kirk."

Kirk, a leading voice in right wing media, saw his peers quick to characterize his assassination as an act of war. Some conservative commentators raised questions about whether America is facing a civil war. "There's no question that we're clearly facing asymmetric civil warfare," one voice stated. "One of the key aspects of that is political assassinations. That being said, the idea that we're going to a classic Civil War scenario, I hope and I pray that that doesn't happen."

A Movement Mourns

Charlie Kirk's podcast continued on Friday without him, as friends and colleagues remembered his life's work. "I think the worst possible way to remember Charlie would be to turn these lights off, that this is his life's work," Posobiec said.

Outside Turning Point USA headquarters in Phoenix, a steady stream of fans came to pay their respects. "This was a really heartless act. I feel so sad and I feel like when we're trying to be silenced we need to come together as a whole and be a family," one mourner shared.

The Debate Over Responsibility

When asked about responsibility to bring the temperature down in political discourse, Posobiec responded: "I want people to be safe, but if you're someone who is part of a group that is fanning the flames of violence, that is encouraging this or celebrating this, then that's absolutely something that we have to tamp down 100%."

The suspect's perspective, as described by the governor, painted a stark picture. A family member stated that Kirk was "full of hate and spread" misinformation. Posobiec pushed back strongly: "Charlie Kirk represented everything they hated. He loved debate. He loved just talking things out. It's what he lived for. It's what he died doing. And this idea that Charlie is the one spreading this? He's got it completely backwards."

An Inflection Point

"I think we're at an inflection point right now," Posobiec said. "Just because you see an influencer online, just because you get mad at something they said in a second clip, that doesn't mean that you have to go and pick up a rifle and shoot them. That instead, as a country, that should mean, you know, come up with a better argument."

Erika Kirk was expected to speak publicly for the first time since the Wednesday tragedy, marking what would be her first public appearance since her husband's murder.

David Axelrod on Political Assassinations and Words That Matter

David Axelrod, former senior advisor to President Obama, provided historical context for the moment. "I remember that era. I was a kid, but I remember it very clearly and it felt like the world was coming apart," he said, referencing the assassinations of JFK, RFK, and Martin Luther King Jr. "We were able to navigate our way through that. I think it's harder now, in part because the media environment is such that it is inflaming."

Axelrod emphasized the tragedy of the situation: "It is tragic that Charlie Kirk, a young man with a family who was out there expressing himself, whether you agree with what he was saying or not, is dead today. And the whole world watched his cold blooded murder. That is terrible."

He also mentioned other victims of recent violence: "It's terrible that Melissa Hortman, the legislator from Minnesota, and her husband are dead today. It was terrible that a police officer outside the CDC was killed. We have a problem in this country and it's not going to be solved by throwing around words like war, which suggest that there's some legitimacy to picking up weapons. That can't be the answer."

Two Republican Messages

The response from Republican leaders revealed a sharp divide. Utah Governor Spencer Cox offered a message of de-escalation: "We can return violence with violence. We can return hate with hate. And that's the problem with political violence. It metastasizes because we can always point the finger at the other side, and at some point we have to find an offramp or it's going to get much, much worse."

President Trump, however, took a different approach when asked by a Fox anchor about violence on the far left and far right. "The radicals on the right oftentimes are radical because they don't want to see certain things happen. The radicals on the left are the worst, and they're vicious, and they're smart, and they're politically savvy," Trump stated.

The Power of Presidential Words

Axelrod responded to Trump's remarks with concern: "I listen to the governor, Governor Cox of Utah and his words, which I thought were magnificent and completely appropriate. And I thought, this is the message that you want from the president of the United States. He is the influencer in chief. He has more impact on people's thinking than anyone."

He continued: "It's not just now that he refers to all his political opponents and a whole political party as radical left lunatics, sick, evil, who hate our country. Those messages matter. Words matter. They're not just tactics for political advantage. They influence people. Especially when you have the platform of the president."

"What you want in this kind of very difficult period is you want your president to be a force for understanding, for reconciliation, and that's what we've seen in the past from Republicans and Democrats. But it's not how this president has approached this," Axelrod concluded.

Comments

Be the first to comment on this video.

Video Transcript

[00:00] Asymmetric warfare warfare. I'm

[00:02] That's what one prominent conserative

[00:04] says the political right

[00:05] is facing in the aftermath

[00:06] of Charlie Kirk's murder.

[00:08] Jack Posobiec,

[00:09] a close friend of Kirk's, is tal

[00:11] to CNN

[00:11] about who could lead the movemen

[00:13] that Kirk helped to build

[00:14] and how Republicans should respo

[00:16] to Kirk's murder.

[00:18] I mean, Anderson is out front.

[00:21] I think the worst possible

[00:23] way to remember Charlie would be

[00:27] to turn these lights off,

[00:28] that this is his life's work.

[00:31] Charlie Kirk's podcast

[00:32] continued on Friday without him.

[00:35] All right.

[00:35] Welcome back to the Charlie Kirk

[00:37] We're remembering our friend

[00:38] Charlie Kirk, his friend

[00:40] and Turning Point contributor.

[00:41] Jack was so sad in his studio,

[00:43] leaving Kirk's chair open as a t

[00:45] How do you fill this void?

[00:48] Oh, look, everybody's got to step up

[00:49] and there's there's no

[00:51] replacement for Charlie Kirk.

[00:54] Who was that?

[00:56] He was so big as a leading voice

[00:59] in right wing media,

[01:00] where some of his peers

[01:01] were quick to call Kirk's assass

[01:02] an act of war.

[01:04] Charlie Kirk's a casualty of war

[01:06] Do you think we're at war,

[01:09] my friends in a box right now.

[01:11] And it wasn't an accident.

[01:14] Or are we facing a civil war?

[01:16] Well,

[01:16] there's no question

[01:17] that we're clearly facing

[01:19] asymmetric civil warfare.

[01:20] One of the key aspects of

[01:22] that is political assassinations

[01:24] That being said,

[01:26] the idea that we're going to a,

[01:28] you know, classic Civil War scen

[01:33] I hope

[01:33] and I pray that that doesn't hap

[01:35] outside headquarters.

[01:36] For the past

[01:37] few days,

[01:37] a steady stream of fans

[01:38] have come to pay their respects.

[01:40] This was a really

[01:43] heartless act.

[01:45] I feel so sad and I feel like

[01:49] when we're trying to be silenced

[01:51] we need to come together as a wh

[01:55] and be a family.

[01:57] Do you feel any responsibility t

[02:00] bring the temperature down

[02:01] in this political discourse?

[02:04] I want people to be safe,

[02:05] but if you're someone

[02:07] who is part of a group

[02:08] that is fanning the flames of vi

[02:10] that is encouraging this

[02:12] or celebrating this, then that's

[02:15] absolutely something

[02:16] that we have to tamp down 100%.

[02:18] The governor this morning

[02:20] was describing the suspect

[02:21] having this family dinner.

[02:23] This is what the governor said.

[02:24] The family member also stated

[02:26] Kirk was full of hate and spread

[02:30] I mean, it's

[02:32] from that person's perspective.

[02:34] Charlie Kirk represented everyth

[02:37] they hated.

[02:38] He loved debate.

[02:39] He loved just talking things out

[02:42] It's what he lived for.

[02:43] It's what he died doing.

[02:45] And this idea that,

[02:46] you know, Charlie, is

[02:47] they're the one spreading this n

[02:49] It's he's got it completely back

[02:51] Now, turning point

[02:52] and the conservative right

[02:53] have to figure out

[02:53] where their movement goes from h

[02:55] I think we're at an inflection

[02:56] point right now.

[02:57] Just because you see

[02:58] an influencer online,

[03:00] just because you

[03:02] get mad at something they said i

[03:04] second clip,

[03:06] that that doesn't mean

[03:07] that you have to go

[03:09] and pick up a

[03:10] rifle and shoot them.

[03:13] That instead, as a country,

[03:16] that should mean, you know,

[03:19] come up with a better argument.

[03:24] And we are at a turning point

[03:25] headquarters here in Phenix,

[03:27] where people have continued to s

[03:29] these past few days with flowers

[03:31] and tributes for Charlie and his

[03:33] Erika is expected to speak from

[03:36] in about 45 minutes,

[03:37] which would make her first publi

[03:39] since this tragedy occurred on W

[03:41] So that is what we are

[03:44] expecting people to continue to

[03:46] to wait for here.

[03:47] And yeah, Nina, thank you very m

[03:49] And such an

[03:50] important and interesting conver

[03:52] which I so back

[03:54] David Axelrod is OutFront now.

[03:55] And, David,

[03:56] you know, this language

[03:56] about being at war and and obvio

[04:00] you know,

[04:00] you hear the frustration,

[04:01] a very somber words

[04:03] there from Jack was sobbing,

[04:04] but you heard others,

[04:05] who were inflamed

[04:07] and immediately firebombing. Rig

[04:10] Alex Jones among them. Right.

[04:11] Talking about being at war, how

[04:15] is this moment? Right.

[04:16] And you're looking at it

[04:17] in the context of having lived t

[04:19] a moment of political assassinat

[04:21] in America that are hard

[04:22] for many to understand.

[04:23] When you look at JFK

[04:25] and RFC and Martin Luther King J

[04:27] all, you know, happening

[04:29] in the same time frame.

[04:31] Yeah, I remember that era.

[04:33] I was a kid, but I remember it

[04:35] very clearly

[04:35] and it felt like

[04:36] the world was coming apart and w

[04:39] were able to navigate our way,

[04:42] through that.

[04:42] I think it's harder now, in part

[04:47] the media

[04:47] environment is such

[04:49] that it is in flaming.

[04:51] I mean, we don't know the whole

[04:53] about what provoked this young m

[04:55] to do what he did.

[04:57] it is kind of a perverse answer

[05:01] if you think someone is is is,

[05:03] disseminating hate

[05:05] the idea that you will go out,

[05:07] you should go out and kill

[05:08] that person is a perverse answer

[05:10] But there obviously,

[05:12] he lived in a world

[05:13] that we don't entirely, understa

[05:15] But, you know,

[05:16] listening to the the interview,

[05:20] I was thinking about the fact th

[05:23] it is tragic that Charlie Kirk,

[05:26] a young man with a family

[05:28] who was out there

[05:29] expressing himself,

[05:30] whether you agree with what he w

[05:31] saying or not, is dead today.

[05:33] And the whole world

[05:34] watched his cold blooded murder.

[05:36] That is terrible.

[05:37] It is.

[05:38] And he is as described in a box.

[05:41] It's terrible that Melissa Hortm

[05:43] the legislator from Minnesota,

[05:45] and her husband are dead today.

[05:48] It was terrible

[05:49] that,

[05:49] police officer outside

[05:51] the CDC was killed.

[05:53] And,

[05:54] because someone sprayed the buil

[05:57] we we have a problem in this cou

[05:59] and it's not going to be solved

[06:00] by throwing around words like wa

[06:02] which suggest

[06:03] that there's some legitimacy

[06:04] to picking up weapons

[06:06] that can't be the answer.

[06:08] No, no.

[06:09] While the word war being thrown

[06:11] quite loosely, in multiple conte

[06:14] in this country right

[06:15] now, but from Republicans,

[06:17] we heard two different messages

[06:18] just today. Two different ones.

[06:19] Okay. First, Utah Governor Spenc

[06:24] We can return violence

[06:26] with violent violence.

[06:27] We can return hate with hate.

[06:29] And that's the problem

[06:30] with with political violence.

[06:32] Is it metastasizes

[06:34] because we can always point the

[06:37] at the other side,

[06:39] and at some point

[06:40] we have to find an offramp

[06:42] or it's going to get much, much

[06:46] Okay, so that's the governor of

[06:48] President Trump, is is very diff

[06:51] He was asked by a Fox anchor

[06:53] about violence

[06:55] on the far left and far right.

[06:56] The question actually was phrase

[06:57] including both. Okay.

[06:59] So in that context,

[07:00] he answers a question

[07:01] about how to bring the country b

[07:03] as the president of the United S

[07:04] He answers it this way.

[07:07] The radicals on the right

[07:09] oftentimes are radical

[07:10] because they don't want to see c

[07:13] The radicals on the left are the

[07:15] and they're vicious, and they're

[07:17] and they're politically savvy.

[07:21] you mentioned Melissa Hortman, o

[07:23] some poses.

[07:24] A police officer

[07:24] showed up at her house

[07:25] tonight and assassinate her husb

[07:29] what do you make and what does i

[07:31] What does it mean that

[07:32] the president of the United Stat

[07:34] in this moment,

[07:35] chooses

[07:35] to conduct himself

[07:37] in that way and use those words?

[07:40] You know, Aaron,

[07:40] I listen to the governor,

[07:42] Governor Cox of Utah in his word

[07:45] which I thought were magnificent

[07:47] and completely appropriate.

[07:49] And I thought,

[07:49] this is the message that you wan

[07:52] from the president of the United

[07:53] He is the influencer in chief.

[07:56] He has more impact on on people'

[07:59] than anyone.

[08:00] And it's not just now, Aaron,

[08:02] that he refers to his all

[08:04] his political opponents

[08:05] and a whole political party

[08:06] as radical left lunatics.

[08:09] sick, evil, who hate our country

[08:14] those messages matter.

[08:16] Words matter.

[08:17] They're not just tactics

[08:18] for political advantage.

[08:20] They influence people.

[08:22] Especially when you have the pla

[08:24] of the president.

[08:24] What you want in this, in this k

[08:27] a very difficult period

[08:29] is you want your president

[08:30] to be a force

[08:31] for understanding, for reconcili

[08:34] and that's what we've seen in th

[08:36] from Republicans and Democrats.

[08:37] But it's not how this president

[08:39] has approached this.

[08:40] No, it's not how he's approachin

[08:42] But as you say,

[08:43] a very different view from the,

[08:46] Republican Utah governor, Spence

[08:48] who spoke very differently.

[08:49] Thank you so much, David Axelrod

[08:50] Appreciate you.

Link copied to clipboard!