Charlie Kirk on Why Progressive Christianity Contradicts the Bible and How Truth Equals Love

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Charlie Kirk Reveals the Five Fake Religions Seeking to Replace Christianity in America

Charlie Kirk Reveals the Five Fake Religions Seeking to Replace Christianity in America

1:01:45

Charlie Kirk on How to Love LGBTQ Friends While Sharing Biblical Truth About God's Design

Charlie Kirk on How to Love LGBTQ Friends While Sharing Biblical Truth About God's Design

3:58

Charlie Kirk Breaks Down the Four Greek Words for Love and Why Agape Is Highest

Charlie Kirk Breaks Down the Four Greek Words for Love and Why Agape Is Highest

0:42

Charlie Kirk on Why Progressive Christianity Contradicts the Bible and How Truth Equals Love

Charlie Kirk addresses a University of Oregon student's question about progressive Christianity, arguing that the movement's core premise contradicts biblical faith. Kirk explains that true Christian love isn't about being nice or soft, but about speaking truth even when uncomfortable. Drawing on Greek definitions of love and biblical references from Genesis and the Gospel of John, he challenges the modern conflation of niceness with genuine love, using a personal medical example to illustrate how truth-telling represents the highest form of caring for others.

December 16, 2021

The Core Problem with Progressive Christianity

When a senior at the University of Oregon asked Charlie Kirk about progressive Christianity and how to show progressive Christians biblical truth out of love, Kirk didn't mince words. He stated plainly that he doesn't believe you can be a true Bible-believing progressive Christian based on the fundamental meaning of the term itself.

Kirk traced the word "progressive" back to its Greek origins, explaining that it means constantly changing. The word of God, he argued, is not constantly changing. This core idea of progressivism stands inherently at odds with what he considers Bible-based Christianity. The very foundation of progressive Christianity contradicts the unchanging nature of Scripture.

Understanding the Greek Meanings of Love

Kirk then tackled the crucial question embedded in the student's inquiry: what does it mean to show someone truth "out of love"? He expressed frustration with the English language, calling it "a sloppy filler for the Greek" when it comes to the concept of love.

The Greeks had multiple terms for love, with four being the most famous:

  • Storge - The love between a parent and child, a familial bond
  • Eros - Romantic love, like the love Kirk has for his wife
  • Philia - Brotherly love (as in Philadelphia, the city of brotherly love), the affection between close friends or siblings
  • Agape - Something completely different from the others

Kirk emphasized that agape represents self-sacrificial love, referencing Scripture: "For God so loved the world, he sent his one and only son that he may die for you so you can have eternal life." This is the willingness to give down your life and status for another person.

Jesus as Logos: The Word and Truth

Kirk highlighted one of his favorite scriptural connections between Genesis 1 and John 1. Genesis 1 states "In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth," while John 1 declares "In the beginning was the word and the word was God and the word was with God."

The critical insight Kirk offered is that the word "word" in John 1 is "logos" in Greek, which means rational speech, otherwise known as truth. Kirk made a powerful observation: the people who love him most are those willing to tell him the truth. The people who don't actually love him are always trying to be vanilla, trying to exist falsely in the middle ground.

The Doctor Who Loved Enough to Tell the Truth

To illustrate his point about truth as love, Kirk shared a personal medical experience. He had to get his four wisdom teeth removed, describing it as "one of the most awful experiences" he's had, though he acknowledged his dentist did an amazing job. Kirk admitted he can't stand dentists.

When he went in for the procedure, the dentist told him: "This infection you have in your tooth could go to your brain in the next couple weeks." Kirk's initial reaction was that this sounded mean, callous, insensitive, and triggering. But upon reflection, he realized it was the most loving thing he'd heard from a doctor or dentist.

She loved him enough to tell him: "Charlie, I want you to keep on speaking and traveling the country, and I love you so much to tell you that if you don't go do something you don't want to do and get this removed from your body, you're not gonna be able to do what you want to do." That was loving.

Society's Confusion: Nice Versus Loving

Kirk argued that our society has conflated "nice" with "loving" and "soft" with "loving." Progressive Christianity, in his view, needs to better understand that sometimes Christians need to be ambassadors with grace—with a magnanimous way of saying things, not trying to offend, not having a heart to offend, not trying to make people feel less than or small.

However, when someone asks what you believe on a certain thing, Kirk insists on being willing to tell the truth. The truth will set you free—freedom from sin, freedom from bondage, freedom from certain patterns of behavior.

This represents Kirk's approach to engaging with progressive Christianity: speaking biblical truth with grace, understanding that genuine love sometimes requires uncomfortable honesty rather than pleasant avoidance.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!