Up Next
Donald Trump Jr. on the Most Amazing Political Comeback in American History and Why Exile Made Them Stronger
22:56
A Former Liberal Natalie Beisner Reflects on Political Violence, Free Speech, and Why America Changed Forever
16:48
Charlie Kirk Witnesses Trump's Triumphant Return and Unprecedented First Day Executive Order Blitz in Washington DC
9:00
Charlie Kirk is the Founder and President of Turning Point USA, the largest and fastest growing conservative youth activist organization in the country with over 250,000 student members, over 150 full-time staff, and a presence on over 2,000 high school and college campuses nationwide. Charlie is also the Chairman of Students for Trump, which aims to activate one million new college voters on campuses in battleground states in the lead up to the 2020 presidential election. His social media reaches over 100 million people per month and according to Axios, he is one of the "top 10 most engaged" Twitter handles in the world. He is also the host of “The Charlie Kirk Show,” which regularly ranks among the top news shows on Apple podcast charts.
Subscribe on YouTubeJosh Hammer and Andrew Kolvet Declare the Cold Civil War Over and America Won
Josh Hammer, senior editor at large at Newsweek and host of the Josh Hammer Show, joins Andrew Kolvet on The Charlie Kirk Show to make a bold declaration: the cold civil war is over, and traditional America has won. Hammer argues that Barack Obama declared war on America in 2008 with his promise to fundamentally transform the nation, initiating a cold civil war that reached its peak during the Biden administration's embrace of DEI and woke ideology. But Donald Trump's second term has brought a Reagan-style victory mentality that is transforming culture overnight. From sweeping executive orders eliminating DEI across government and beyond, to a vibrant young conservative movement dominating popular culture, Hammer and Kolvet examine why this moment represents the most transformative cultural paradigm shift in a generation and why the momentum appears built to last.
The Cold Civil War Has Been Won
Andrew Kolvet welcomed Josh Hammer onto The Charlie Kirk Show with an important observation: while Charlie Kirk was deployed with Vice President JD Vance, there was major news to discuss. Hammer, senior editor at large at Newsweek and host of the Josh Hammer Show, had written a compelling op-ed titled "The Cold Civil War is Over, We Won." While Kolvet acknowledged he wasn't ready to pop champagne just yet with much work remaining, he found the premise compelling and asked Hammer to make his case.
Hammer agreed that just because the enemy appears defeated doesn't mean it couldn't rise again, but argued that what we've witnessed in the opening week of Trump's second administration represents the most transformative, culture-shifting moment of our lifetimes. The key, he explained, lies in understanding how this cold civil war began in the first place.
Barack Obama Declared War on America
According to Hammer, Barack Obama declared war on America and instituted the modern American cold civil war. Obama famously said in February 2008 that he sought to fundamentally transform America. As Hammer pointed out, one does not seek to fundamentally transform that which he loves or seeks to conserve.
Throughout the Obama presidency, this war manifested in multiple ways: Obamacare represented the largest entitlement since Lyndon Johnson's Great Society. The administration beat up on cops and exacerbated racial relations. Attorney General Eric Holder used disparate impact theory, a predecessor to Ibram X. Kendi's anti-racism ideology. Foreign policy disasters like the Iran deal further damaged America's standing.
Obama tried repeatedly to declare war on the half of America he infamously called "bitter clingers," the same people Hillary Clinton would later label "deplorables" in 2016. This civil war was stopped for about three and a half years during Trump's first term, until George Floyd met Derek Chauvin in Minneapolis, Minnesota, triggering the riots of summer 2020 and ushering in what Hammer calls "peak woke."
The Biden Administration Represented Peak Woke
The past four years under Joe Biden represented peak woke, according to Hammer. Biden literally chose his vice president, Kamala Harris, because she was a "woman of color." He selected his Supreme Court Justice, Ketanji Brown Jackson, for the same reason. Time and again, as journalists like Chris Rufo reported, the administration weaponized the instrumentalities of the American administrative state to implement DEI programs that overtly discriminated against white people, Christians, Jews, and Asians in favor of blacks and Hispanics.
This was the moment woke reached its apex. But it has now been slain, because Donald Trump adopted a mentality going back to Ronald Reagan's famous approach to the Cold War.
Trump Adopted Reagan's "We Win, They Lose" Mentality
When Ronald Reagan was asked about his approach to the Cold War after coming into power in 1980, following the difficult 1970s with competing visions like Henry Kissinger's détente versus Cold War hawks, Reagan famously declared: "We win and they lose." People said he was crazy, a cowboy, a warmonger. But that mentality helped win the Cold War.
Donald Trump has taken that exact same mentality into his second term. Hammer suspects the galvanizing moment came around the time Joe Biden, Merrick Garland, and special counsel Jack Smith started prosecuting Trump, trying to throw him in jail, bankrupt him, ruin him of all his possessions, and deprive him of his liberty and livelihood. Or perhaps it was when Thomas Matthew Crooks in Butler, Pennsylvania came within millimeters of assassinating him before a global television audience.
At some point, Trump had his Clarence Thomas 1991 Anita Hill moment where he looked at all the radicalization around him and said enough is enough. Echoing Barack Obama's famous line, Trump essentially said: get me my pen, get me my phone, because this isn't going to fly anymore.
Executive Orders Are Transforming Culture Overnight
That's exactly what America witnessed in Trump's first week back in office. The sheer volume of executive orders has been staggering, covering DEI, gender ideology, birthright citizenship, and much more. But Hammer focused particularly on the DEI executive order, which doesn't just eliminate DEI in the executive branch but goes far beyond.
The order instructs the attorney general and Secretary of Education, along with the entire cabinet, to enforce Title VI and interpret the Supreme Court's affirmative action case in Students for Fair Admissions in a way that effectively bans DEI in any taxpayer-supported institution in America. This is the kind of action that wins culture wars overnight.
While Hammer emphasized the need for constant vigilance and keeping the foot on the gas pedal, what has been witnessed so far is the stuff of legends. He compared it to when the English took over what was then called New Amsterdam from Peter Stuyvesant and the Dutch in the 1600s, renaming it New York City. They famously took it over without firing a single shot through a pure, unmitigated demonstration of force, and the enemy yielded.
The Movement Has Staying Power
Kolvet raised the question of whether this transformation has staying power, noting Trump is the only president in American history with a higher approval rating at the start of his second term than he ever had in his first. A clear majority across five different polls shows Americans support deporting all illegal immigrants, not just some or the worst first. Main Street America is seeing the changes, seeing the momentum shift, and American malaise is out while self-constraint is abandoned.
Despite the trauma of 2020 and 2022 making it hard to fully believe, Kolvet asked whether we're at the beginning of an 8 to 12-year run. Hammer responded with an emphatic yes. JD Vance, at only 40 years old, is the natural heir to the throne, which is partly why Trump tapped him. This is a long-term play evidenced by Trump's cabinet picks. Pete Hegseth is only 44 or 45 years old. So many cabinet picks are very young people because this is a movement.
MAGA and America First represent what's cool right now. This is the anti-establishment mentality, the same way Barack Obama was considered irreverent, similar to how the "cool kids" in the 1960s were burning down college campuses over the Vietnam War. MAGA is basically that today—the middle finger to the establishment.
The Democratic Party Is a Rotting Carcass
The Democratic Party, according to Hammer, is a rotting carcass filled with octogenarians and septuagenarians who are literally two to three decades past their prime. Joe Biden perfectly encapsulates this reality. Meanwhile, the Republican Party is filled with young, up-and-coming people who have an inherent love of their country.
This is being reflected in popular culture everywhere. NFL and college football players are doing the Trump dance in the end zone after scoring touchdowns. Carrie Underwood went acapella at the inaugural address. Big tech oligarchs are coming around. The cultural moments keep accumulating.
Kolvet showed an image of Charlie Kirk casually sitting next to JD Vance on Air Force 2, calling it breaking news of them plotting the future blizzard of executive orders and actions that will take the country back. The movement is ascendant, and it's impossible to separate Trump's momentum from this entirely new generation of young leaders like Kirk, James Blair, Sergio Gor, JD Vance, Stephen Miller, Taylor Budowich, and countless others.
This new young core is assuming control both from a media standpoint and an actual power standpoint. The amount of transformational change possible is impossible to fully comprehend or appreciate at this moment. History will write about these days and these leaders who are transforming America back to the founders' intent, restoring the Americanism and dynamism of the people in the truest sense.
The Left's War on Fun Has Failed
Kolvet brought up a New York Magazine cover story titled "The Cruel Kids Table" by Brock Collier, a trans journalist who applied for press credentials at the Turning Point inaugural eve ball and was on the red carpet. The story featured pictures from the ball, and even this critical journalist admitted that conservatives are winning and culturally ascendant, now dominating realms of culture that would have been hard to fathom just a few years ago.
The magazine appeared to have cropped the photo to make it look more monolithically white than it actually was. But Hammer argued that a normal American looks at that photo and sees a bunch of good-looking young people having a great time, dressed nicely, clanking their glasses and saying cheers. There's nothing wrong with the picture.
This gets at what Hammer calls the left's "war on fun." They scold you for driving a gas-guzzling pickup truck or SUV. They call you a bad person for wanting to have numerous kids—God forbid you take the Book of Genesis seriously and be fruitful and multiply, having three, four, five, or more children who will consume oxygen and emit carbon dioxide. They hate when you teach your children about religion, the Bible, the things that actually built this country, the Founding Fathers, the Constitutional Convention.
The left has become a bunch of pearl-clutching, overtly faux-moralistic prudes. They hate looking at anyone more successful than them, which gets back to the roots of socialism and Marxism—the whole idea of envy, class envy, and individual envy. Hammer noted he was looking at the leftwing rally on the eve of inauguration, the Women's March with pink hats on the National Mall, and observed a bunch of typically ugly people, with obvious exceptions.
As Matt Walsh pointed out on Twitter, what really defines the left now besides purple-haired, nose-pierced, overweight young people screaming about some injustice they invented in a college laboratory? Young kids having fun, wearing flannel in the country, listening to country music—conservatives are the fun movement now.
The Left Must Disavow Obama to Recover
It's fascinating, Kolvet observed, that in 2008 the left's cultural ascendency promised so much but failed to deliver. Instead, it delivered a dystopian, puritanical scolding about invented injustices. This conservative movement can actually deliver on the promise of lifting everybody up and having fun.
Hammer agreed, noting that if the left has any chance of recovering—and thankfully it's not his problem as a man of the right—they must disavow the entirety of the Barack Obama legacy and his post-presidential legacy. They need to go back to the old Democratic Party of Bill Clinton and his predecessors who, whatever their flaws, focused on bread-and-butter issues, not woke propaganda.
Video Transcript
my name is Andrew kette honored to be
with you as always uh Charlie Kirk is
deployed right now with uh vice
president JD Vance uh I'm sure he's
going to have all kinds of updates for
us tomorrow I will just say I've seen
some of the pictures and it's pretty fun
want to welcome Josh Hammer uh onto the
show next he's a senior editor at large
at Newsweek host of the Josh Hammer show
Josh welcome to the Charlie Kirk show
how you doing Andrew I'm doing great my
friend uh you know it is morning in
America as a famous man once said about
four and a half decades ago and it's
really great to be back on the Charlie
Kirk show with uh with you my good
friend Andrew kulit yeah absolutely Josh
I'm so glad to have you um I mean
there's just so much to to discuss uh
but you know the the real impetus for
this was your oped and Newsweek um and I
I thought it was a really really fun
title for an oped first of all the cold
Civil War is over we won now Josh I want
to get I want you to make your argument
here but I you know I just want to say
I'm not uh you know I'm not popping
champagne just yet there's a lot of work
to do but I think the premise of your
article holds what why do you say we won
the cold Civil War what is the cold
Civil War make your
case Andrew let me first say that the
fact that the enemy is slayed at least
for the time being I agree does not
necessarily mean that it will not one
day God forbid possibly Rise Like a
Phoenix From the Ashes to create more
chaos in Mayhem and to sew the seeds of
discourse uh here in America so while I
am definitely celebrating I agree that
we should not rest on our Laurels it is
it is definitely time to keep the
momentum going but the reason that I
picked this very fun title I I'm glad
you agree with me I thought it was a
very fun title as well is that what
we've seen thus far in the opening week
or so of this second Donald Trump
Administration is the most
transformative culture cultural paradigm
shifting moment that I think we've seen
probably in our lifetimes and basically
in the column Andrew I I I take a step
back Barack Obama declared war on
America he declared war on America and
instituted our modern American Civil War
our cold civil Royal and cold Civil War
this happened because Barack Obama
basically said that he was doing it he
famously said in February 2008 that he
sought to fundamentally transform
America and one does not seek to
fundamentally transform that which he
loves or seeks to conserve and we saw
this time and time again throughout the
Obama presidency whether it came to
Obamacare the largest entitlement since
Lynden Johnson's Great Society whe when
it came to to to the issue of beating up
on Cops of exacerbating racial relations
of having Eric Holder his attorney
general use so-called disparate impact
theory that was kind of the predecessor
to ibrx kendi and anti-racism whether it
was all the foreign policy nonsense with
the Iran deal Barack Obama tried time
and time again to declare war on the
half America that he infamously called
bitter clingers that Hillary Clinton in
2016 referred to as deplorables and that
that Civil War was stopped for four
years by the Donald Trump Administration
or at least three and a half years or so
until George Floyd met Derek chovin in
Minneapolis Minnesota and we we all saw
what happened from there the the Riots
of the summer of 2020 and there and then
we got Peak woke the past four years
prior to Donald Trump getting back in
the Oval Office the Joe Biden presidency
this was Peak woke Andrew Peak woke he
literally chose a vice president of the
United States KLA Harris because she was
a quote unquote woman of color he
literally chose is one Justice on the
United States Supreme Court katoni Brown
Jackson because she is a quote unquote
woman of color time and time again as
folks like Chris rufo have reported they
weaponized all the various
instrumentalities of the American
administrative State and executive
branch to implement so-called Dei to
overtly discriminate against white
people against Christians Jews Asians in
favor of blacks Hispanics and so forth
there and just basically a everything
that we saw over the past four years
this this was the the moment that woke
reached I think it's a pathosis it's
been slate it's been slate because
Donald Trump Andrew adopted a mentality
to go back to the morning in America
line that I was saying a few minutes ago
he adopted an old reaganite Mantra and
what Ronald Reagan famously said when he
was asked for his approach to the Cold
War and he came into power in 1980
coming off the 1970s you had differing
opinions in 1970s there was Henry
Kissinger in Daytons there was kind of
the the the Cold War Hawks back then
Ronald Reagan famously said that his
approach the Cold War we win and they
lose people said that he was crazy that
he was a cowboy he was a warmonger but
that mentality Andrew helped win the
Cold War I think Donald Trump has taken
that exact same mentality to his second
term in office and I'm not entirely sure
what the exact moment was that
galvanized him to adopt this reaganite
Mantra I supect it was probably around
the time that Joe Biden mer Garland and
so-called special counsel Jack Smith
started to incarcerate him to prosecute
him try to throw him in jail bankrupt
him ruin him of all his possessions
basically deprive him of his Liberty and
his livelihood maybe it was around the
time that Thomas Matthew crook in Butler
Pennsylvania came within millimeters of
assassinating him before a global
television audience but at some point at
some point Donald Trump had kind of his
Clarence Thomas 1991 Anita Hill moment
where he looked at all this
radicalization around him and said you
know what this is enough I am over this
and you know what to quote Barack Obama
get me my freaking pen get me my
freaking phone because this crap ain't
gonna fly anymore come day one and that
was what we saw last week Andrew we saw
all these executive orders I mean the
the the Dei executive order alone just
focusing on that one executive order and
there's been so many amazing ones it's
hard to know even where to start there
been the gender ideology Birthright
citizenship it's amazing stuff coming
out of this white house but just the Dei
executive order it doesn't just get rid
of Dei in the executive branch it
actually goes way past that it instructs
the attorney general and the Secretary
of Education the whole cabinet to
enforce title 6 and to interpret the
Supreme Court's affirmative action case
students were Fair emissions so as to
effectively ban Dei in any taxpayer
support institution in America th this
is the kind of stuff that wins culture
wars overnight so again let's not
resting our Laurels I understand like
you know constant vigilance and let's
let's keep our let's keep our foot on
the gas pedal and keep on plowing Full
Speed Ahead but for now for now what we
have seen I is the stuff of Legends
frankly it kind of reminds me as as I
said in the column I remember when I was
a kid learning about how the English
took over what was then called New
Amsterdam and then they renamed it New
York City from Peter Stenson the Dutch
in the 1600s they famously took it over
without F without firing a single shot
because it was just a pure unmitigated
demonstration of force and the enemy
yielded at that demonstration of force
that's very much how I view what
happened over this past week I I I I
think that was extraordinarily well said
Josh um I you know and and I want to
believe that all of this is going to
happen without a single shot I mean and
what there's a lot of reason to believe
that
we have now become the dominant force in
culture and not just politically which
obviously we control the three baners of
the government but culturally
philosophically ideologically you can
feel the momentum behind more of a
traditional Americana this triumphant
Americana this Manifest Destiny whether
it be Greenland or Panama or Canada uh
or just retaking the Border Pete heg
said saying yeah we're going to get uh
operational control of our Southern
border you've got ice raids uh we we are
from a PR standpoint uh this
Administration is doing a fantastic job
projecting strength to the world you saw
this with Colombia and the little tip
that happened over the weekend how
quickly that was resolved and then and
then and then and on and on and on it
goes and I I I what I find
particularly uh instructive and
encouraging Josh is the polling you've
got Harry Anon at CNN going on in front
of you know Casey hunt or whatever the
host is going like hey these numbers are
extraordinary and just just for our
audience's sake consider this Donald
Trump is the only President in the
history of the country that has a higher
approval rating at the start of his
second term than he ever did in his
first term a majority of all Americans
support deportation of all not some not
the worst first which obviously Tom
homman budget constraints Manpower
constraint is starting with the worst
first but a majority a clear majority
across like five different polls say
that
Americans support deporting all illegals
this is a phenomenal phenomenal showing
and it shows Josh that the the Main
Street America average America is seeing
the changes already they're seeing the
momentum shift and American malaise is
out America's self- constraint is out
and so I do want to be really really
encouraged by this there there's a part
of me that just you know I think can't
get over the trauma of 2020 or 2022 and
and won't quite believe it but Josh do
you think this has staying power do you
think we are at the beginning of an 8
12E
run I do I I I absolutely do I I think I
think that JD Vance as vice president of
United States is kind of the natural air
to the throne and we obviously have that
debate I presume in in the year 2028 but
God will in the next four years will go
well and and JD who is literally only 40
years old is kind of a logical successor
there that's part of the reasons that
Donald Trump tapped JD Vance in the
first place right is because he's making
a long longterm play here I mean look at
his cabinet picks I mean you mentioned
Pete hexat Pete Heth is what 44 45 years
old I mean so many of these cabinet
picks are very very young people this is
a movement Andrew and what's so
fascinating is that Maga America First
Ju Just being on the right of center
right now in America more generally
speaking this is cool I mean this is
kind of the anti-establishment mentality
the same way that Barack Obama was was
considered irreverent and back in the
1960s all the quote unquote
self-professed pool kids you know were
burning down college campuses the
Vietnam War all that stuff Maga is
basically that today I mean this is kind
of the middle finger to The
Establishment the Democratic party is a
rotting carcass it is filled with
octogenarians septuagenarians people who
are literally two to three decades past
their Prime Joe Biden's obviously a
perfect encapsulation of that there and
the Republican party is filled with
young upand cominging people who have an
inherent love of their country there and
that being reflected in the popular
culture look at all the people in these
NFL playoffs and the college fo playoffs
were doing the Trump dance in the end
zone after getting a touchdown Carrie
Underwood going Acappella at at the
inaugural address there so many cultural
moments and these big Tech oars I mean
just on and on all right everybody I
want to show you something here um go
ahead and throw up this image this is
Charlie just casually hanging out with
the VP uh go ahead and throw that up uh
I think it's y there's uh Charlie this
is breaking news Charlie's just sitting
next to JD Vance there on Air Force 2
just uh casually plotting the uh the
future uh blizzard of other executive
orders and actions that will take this
country back uh our movement is
ascendant folks to to the conversation
that we were having with Josh we're
going to bring him back when we have
radio rejoin in just a second there is
so much positive momentum happening
right now and it is impossible to
separate the movement that Trump has
sparked the ascendency of it without
also including this entirely new
generation of Young Guns like Charlie
Kirk uh like James Blair like Sergio
Gore like JD Vance Steven Miller there's
almost too many to name Taylor budt
there's so many within this
Administration they're Staffing it from
top to bottom obviously Charlie's not
stabing it but he's you know within the
larger movement on this show in this
audience it it the the amount of
transformational change that is possible
with this new Young vibrant core of
leadership that that is assuming control
both from a media standpoint and an
actual power standpoint the Reigns of
actual power it's impossible to fully
comprehend or appreciate at this
juncture history will write about these
days history will write about these
leaders and they will transform America
back to the founders intent not to
create some corrupt muddled
Frankenstein uh that would that the
founders wouldn't uh even recognize but
they will restore the americanism the
dynamism of our people um in the truest
sense of the word and it's these are
extraordinary days that we live in these
are extraordinary times um and uh it is
a new dawn Josh I want to throw this
image up this is from New York the New
York Magazine uh it's kind of personal
for me actually through up 94 uh image
94 the cruel kids table is the way the
headline read this a cover cover piece
for New York Magazine uh by Brock colier
who is a trans journalist uh from the
New York Magazine I know this because
Brock uh also applied for press
credentials at the Turning Point uh ball
our inaugural Eve ball and was there on
the red carpet uh there's pictures of
our ball at in this story uh but you
know the the push back is is hilarious
about this piece but I think it's an
interesting even the journalist in this
piece Josh admits that we're winning
that that we are culturally ascendent
that we are now dominating Realms of
culture that would have been hard to
Fathom just a few years ago um and I I
believe that they've cropped this
picture to make it look right uh more
racist like it's only white kids or
something there's there's a whole bunch
of uh a whole bunch of that going on
here but it's like Josh take take this
picture as just one instance it's a
bunch of young successful happy kids
drinking a you know at a trendy
cocktail party and and you know I guess
if that's like cruel celebrating the the
dawn of a new Administration in new
America uh you know I I guess you know
cry harder Libs as my you know instant
reaction what do you make of this and uh
what does this tell
us well first of all Andrew I'm pretty
sure they did do exactly that which you
said they did which that they they
cropped out this photo they edited it
they they Photoshopped it to make it
look just more monolithically white than
it is there but you know I I think a
normal American looks at this photo
whether it's been photoshopped or
cropped or edited or not and says oh wow
these are a bunch of like pretty
goodlook young people having a great
time they're dressed nicely there
they're clanking their glasses they're
saying cheers there I'm sorry I'm not
seeing anything wrong with this picture
Andrew I'm I'm simply just not seeing
anything and and I think what kind of
the broader point is getting at here th
this is a point that I've made actually
for a few years now I think this is part
of the left's war on fun I actually
literally call the the war on fun you
know whether it's trying to call you a
scold for driving in a gas guzzling
pickup truck or an SUV whether whether
they're calling you a bad person for
wanting to have numerous kids you know
that whole be fruitful and multiply
thing right there from The Book of
Genesis God forbid you actually take God
at his word and and have three four five
you know God knows how many children who
are going to consume oxygen and spit out
carbon dioxide you know you're a very
you're a very very bad person like they
they definitely hate that Andrew you
know God forbid you actually teach your
children about religion about the Bible
about the things that actually built
this country about the founding fathers
about the Constitutional Convention you
can't have any of that either there I
mean the left has become just these
Pearl clutching bunch of of overtly faux
moralistic Pradas that's basically what
they become there and they hate looking
at anyone who is more successful than
them that obviously gets back to kind of
the roots of socialism and Marxism is
this whole idea of envy and class envy
and individual Envy that's definitely
part of this as well there but they're
just fundamentally just a bunch of just
of rag tag and and frankly Andrew if I'm
just being very blunt for a second here
you know I was looking at this at this
rally on the eve of the inauguration the
leftwing rally there with kind of those
pink hats whatever the women's marched
off there on the National Mall bunch of
ugly people I mean I'm probably gonna
get in trouble for saying that there but
like these are just typically obviously
their exceptions but a bunch of like
very ugly people honestly Josh I I mean
think about it you know and I think Matt
Walsh made this point on uh on Twitter
we like we like Matt a lot and and he
had a great uh role to play in you know
just that his film and so many other
things but what what reads his left wing
now besides like a bunch of
purple-haired you know nose piercing you
know many uh obese or at least
overweight young people screaming about
some injustice that they've invented at
a a in a college laboratory I mean
literally if if young kids having fun if
young kids you know wearing a flannel
and in the country you know listening
country music what whatever I mean we
are the fun movement and this it's a
very fascinating Point Josh and I'll
throw it back to you for 30 seconds uh
to react you know it seemed like in 2008
this cultural ascendency of the left
promised all of these things but failed
to deliver instead it it delivered this
dystopian uh puritanical
scolding uh you know from the left about
these invented injustices and this
movement I believe can actually deliver
on the promise of lifting everybody and
and having fun uh final reaction Josh
Hammer well you're totally right to take
it back to 2008 that's where I started
my cold Civil Wars over oped 2 because
they it does go back to Barack Obama and
his 2008 campaign Andrew if the left is
going to have any chance of recovering
and thank God it's not my problem I'm
I'm a man of the right obviously but if
the left is going to have any chance of
recovering Here Andrew they have to
disavow the entirety of the Barack Obama
Legacy and his post-presidential legacy
they need to go back to the old
Democratic party of Bill Clinton and his
predecessors who whatever their flaws
were they were focused on bread and
butter issues not this woke
PRP I agree Josh Hammer good man follow
him follow his stuff