Tucker Carlson Shares His Biggest Fear About Charlie Kirk's Assassination and America's Future
Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.
Up Next
Dave Smith Reveals Charlie Kirk's Final Letter to Benjamin Netanyahu: Wrestling With Israel Support
21:35
Josh Hammer's Suspicious Public Execution Tweet 16 Hours Before Charlie Kirk's Assassination Sparks Investigation
27:29
Glenn Greenwald and Analysis on Political Violence, Reactions, and the Dangers of Reactionary Totalitarianism
29:47
Tucker Carlson Shares His Biggest Fear About Charlie Kirk's Assassination and America's Future
Tucker Carlson appears on Megyn Kelly's podcast to process the shock of Charlie Kirk's assassination. He describes spending hours watching videos of people celebrating Kirk's death, wrestling with despair, and ultimately being reminded by his wife of the biblical call to love enemies. Carlson shares his concerns about the nation descending into greater violence and division, emphasizing the need for wisdom, restraint, and seeing others as God sees them. He discusses the temptation to embrace conspiracy theories, the importance of skepticism without jumping to conclusions, and his fear that this tragedy could become a tipping point leading America into something darker rather than serving as a catalyst for healing.
Tucker Carlson appeared on Megyn Kelly's podcast less than 24 hours after Charlie Kirk's assassination to share his raw, unfiltered reaction to the tragedy. Carlson described staying up until 1 in the morning texting people and scrolling through X, mesmerized by the reactions flooding social media. He admitted to watching approximately 15 videos of young women celebrating Kirk's death, initially assuming they must be manufactured attempts to divide the country. But upon closer inspection, he discovered they were real people with real names—an elementary school teacher from Idaho, a yoga instructor from West Hollywood—and the realization hit him hard about the depth of evil present in society.
Carlson described the experience as being unable to turn away, comparing it to pornography or snuff videos—a dark pull that kept him "marinating in the hate" despite recognizing how much it was hurting him. He questioned whether he truly knew his own country anymore, wondering what kind of place he was living in where such celebrations of violence could be so widespread.
A Biblical Reminder About Loving Enemies
When Carlson woke up the morning after the assassination, he received a group text from his wife to their family. Everyone in the family knew Kirk personally—he had recently visited their home. His wife sent Luke 6 to the family chat, the passage where Jesus teaches to "love your enemies, pray for your persecutors, and when someone assaults you, don't fight back."
Carlson acknowledged this teaching as "the most radical thing that anyone's ever said" and admitted it's impossible to live that way without supernatural intervention. He expressed deep admiration for this kind of humility and recognized that focusing on hate and conspiracy theories was pulling him away from what truly mattered: Charlie Kirk, his wife Erika, their children, and the things he should be meditating on and praying about.
The Danger of Collective Punishment
The discussion touched on the dangerous responses emerging from both sides of the political spectrum. On one side, liberals celebrating Kirk's murder create conditions that could bring about right-wing reactionary totalitarianism. Carlson and the commentary warned that if the left continues endorsing this senseless murder while also promoting controversial policies, it could pave the road for a version of right-wing authoritarianism far worse than anything imaginable—one that could emerge 10 years down the line.
On the other side, there's the temptation for the right to impose collective punishment against the entire left for the actions of one murderer. This approach, already being taken by some prominent conservative figures, threatens to stoke flames that could burn out of control. The emphasis throughout was on rejecting both directions of potential catastrophe.
The Need for Order Without Tyranny
Carlson discussed the importance of restoring order in the country, clarifying that order doesn't mean authoritarian behavior, eliminating constitutional rights, or racism. He described order as the key to happiness and peace, referencing how God creates order out of chaos at the beginning of Genesis. Order, he argued, is a prerequisite for joy, and the country desperately needs it after 50 years without it.
However, the discussion also emphasized that totalitarian order is just as bad as unmitigated chaos. What's needed is a society that protects individual rights and liberties, respects due process, doesn't launch endless wars, doesn't fleece the populace of its wealth, and doesn't impose inflation through central banks. Whether that's called order or chaos is less important than the substance of what it protects.
Skepticism and the Search for Truth
With 35 years of experience in journalism, Carlson emphasized that he never accepts the first explanation from anyone about anything. He stressed the importance of being skeptical of everything presented as a pat explanation, though he was careful to note that the official story can sometimes be right—it shouldn't be dismissed simply because it's official.
The discussion covered several observations about the assassination itself. The shooter used a .30-06 rifle, not the AR-15 (.223/5.56) commonly characterized as the most dangerous weapon. The .30-06, often referred to by politicians like Chuck Schumer as a "deer rifle," is actually a much larger round—an old-fashioned military round designed for maximum damage rather than wounding. This detail, along with other factors, suggested to Carlson that whoever committed the murder had thought about it extensively. It clearly wasn't some random person who got angry yesterday morning and decided to act.
However, Carlson stressed the importance of waiting for facts before jumping to conclusions, even while maintaining healthy skepticism of official narratives.
Historical Parallels and Propaganda
The conversation drew on historical examples of government propaganda and manipulation: the Iraq War, the war on terror, the COVID regime, Russiagate. These instances demonstrated how propaganda gets funneled to the American public through television to steer minds in directions counterintuitive to citizens but beneficial to the state.
Carlson acknowledged that part of the problem with living to 56 is having seen so much—growing up around many of these events and knowing the truth about some things while remaining ignorant about many more. He's attended enough dinners and conversations where he realized the people speaking had no idea what actually happened in various situations. This experience creates a mindset where radical transparency becomes essential, but it also requires wisdom to navigate.
The Fear of Civil War
Carlson expressed his belief that the country is currently in a form of civil war, with violence already a huge component of it. His greatest fear is that it could become an even bigger component. Having been around a couple wars, he emphasized that there are really no winners in such conflicts, and their effects last for generations, even centuries.
He worried aloud about whether Kirk's assassination could be a tipping point or turning point for the country in a negative way—the beginning of a descent into something even darker rather than a period at the end of terrible things that have been happening. This concern about violence spiraling out of control, similar to what happened after Martin Luther King Jr.'s assassination when riots and violent behavior followed, was central to his analysis.
The Most Important Text Message
Among the hundreds of texts Carlson received expressing sympathy and telling him to be safe, one stood out from his cousin Jake, whom he described as one of the wisest people he knows. Jake's message said: "I'm not praying for your safety. I'm praying that you would more fervently seek wisdom than ever before."
That message resonated deeply with Carlson. He emphasized that while being reasonable about safety is important, the real goal is wisdom. Seek wisdom more than ever before, and seek it fervently. He drew a parallel to Solomon from the Bible, who when given the opportunity to pray for anything, prayed for wisdom—and that's what everyone should strive for, especially in times like these.
Seeing Others as God Sees Them
When asked what the answer is to preventing further descent into violence and civil war, Carlson returned to the spiritual foundation he'd discussed earlier. The answer, he said, is to see one another as God sees us. This doesn't mean excusing inexcusable behavior or embracing moral relativism—it means exactly the opposite.
It means recognizing that all people are created by a creator, regardless of their views or appearance. Proceeding with that understanding doesn't mean excusing murder or any other terrible act. It means approaching even difficult situations with the perspective that people need to be transformed and see each other as human beings created by God, including their enemies.
Without that worldview, Carlson argued, society descends into hell—in fact, we already live there in some sense. The transformation required is supernatural, beyond what people can accomplish on their own, but it's what the moment demands.
Rejecting Both Extremes
The overarching message emphasized rejecting two dangerous paths forward. The first is the left's celebration of violence and political murder, which creates the conditions for right-wing authoritarianism. The second is the right's temptation to impose collective punishment, expand government powers, and pit segments of the population against each other in an existential war.
Both paths lead to disaster. What's needed instead is wisdom, restraint, focus on the Kirk family's loss, respect for due process and individual rights, and a rejection of using this tragedy as a catalyst for either political suppression or expanded state power. The example of Japanese internment after Pearl Harbor serves as a warning about what can happen when fear and collective blame drive policy.
The best path forward involves seeking truth, following the money, using reason to deduce disinformation from truth, and above all, maintaining the perspective that violence should become less, not more, a part of political discourse. This is especially important given that violence has been so normalized through US foreign policy, the drug war, and other government actions that it inevitably manifests domestically.
