Candace Owens and Ray J Debate Transgenderism with Trans Woman Danielle Alexis

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Senator Josh Hawley Confronts NCAA President on Biological Males in Women's Sports and Locker Rooms

Senator Josh Hawley Confronts NCAA President on Biological Males in Women's Sports and Locker Rooms

6:35

Billboard Chris Confronts Gender Clinic Practices and the Reality of Intersex Conditions at Campus Event

Billboard Chris Confronts Gender Clinic Practices and the Reality of Intersex Conditions at Campus Event

4:51

Cam Higby Debates a College Student on Gender Identity, Free Speech, and Transgender Medical Treatment

Cam Higby Debates a College Student on Gender Identity, Free Speech, and Transgender Medical Treatment

6:17

Candace Owens and Ray J Debate Transgenderism with Trans Woman Danielle Alexis

Candace Owens sits down with Ray J and trans woman Danielle Alexis for an honest conversation about gender identity, mental health, and the limits of self-identification. After Candace's controversial statements on Don Lemon's show, Ray J arranged this meeting to bridge the gap between opposing perspectives. The discussion tackles tough questions: Is transgenderism a mental disorder? Can someone be transracial? What's the difference between biological reality and lived identity? Danielle shares her two-decade journey from Perth, Australia, while Candace pushes back on the idea that feelings define reality. Despite fundamental disagreements, both sides engage with mutual respect in a rare example of civil discourse on one of today's most contentious issues.

August 6, 2024

The Setup: Why This Conversation Happened

Candace Owens begins by explaining the origin of this conversation. After appearing on Don Lemon's show where she stated that transgenderism is a mental disorder, Ray J reached out via Instagram. He felt Candace didn't have the full story and wanted to introduce her to someone who could provide a wider perspective. Candace agreed immediately, and they made it happen virtually overnight while she was in Los Angeles.

Ray J explains his motivation: his involvement with the trans community through television shows and personal relationships has educated him on new perspectives. He brought Danielle Alexis, a star on his new show "The Gworls Club" on the Zeus Network, because he felt her experience directly related to what Candace had said. Ray J emphasizes the importance of "bridging the gap" through education and open dialogue.

Danielle's Story: Growing Up Trans in Australia

Danielle introduces herself as being from Perth, Western Australia, which she describes as the most isolated city in the world. She explains that her trans experience dates back to age four, when she first verbalized feelings of being different to her mother. According to what her mother later told her, Danielle was comparing herself to her older sister and displaying certain characteristics that stood out.

Growing up in Perth 20 years ago, Danielle's journey was completely solitary. Her parents, who came from the country, had no knowledge about trans issues or the LGBTQ community. Everything Danielle saw on television was sensationalized and misrepresentative. She describes herself as a trailblazer for what she did because she was essentially the only one doing it for a while.

Danielle's parents divorced when she was six, with her mother remarrying. She maintained relationships with both biological parents and two step-parents. Her mother was always particularly close with her and acted as a listener, never shutting down what Danielle verbalized but also never pushing transition. Her father, described as a "very staunch Australian" like Crocodile Dundee, struggled more with communication but was ultimately accepting and understanding.

The Silence Years: Primary Through High School

Danielle reveals a crucial detail: after initially being open about her feelings, she completely internalized everything from late primary through all of high school. Once she realized at school that her feelings weren't "normal" and could lead to bullying, she never brought the topic up again to her family until after graduation.

Despite her silence, Danielle was consistently perceived as feminine by others. She describes being called "she" and "her" by strangers throughout her school years, not because she was actively presenting as trans, but because of her natural appearance and mannerisms. Even in a standard school uniform, people would greet groups she was in with "good morning, ladies." She emphasizes this was a visual response, not an act or performance.

Interestingly, Danielle notes that even gay boys in her school were treated differently than she was. The community seemed to instinctively recognize something different about her, treating the feminine gay boys as one category and her as "the she" – a distinction that matched her internal feelings even when she wasn't vocalizing them.

The Decision to Transition

Danielle vocalized her trans identity at 17 while attending Kingsway Christian College, a prestigious Christian school where her family had enrolled her so she could focus on her studies and graduate. Being around devout Christians, going to church, and doing Bible study during this time helped her clarify her feelings and what she needed to do.

In Australia, graduation falls when students turn 18, which is the legal age of majority. Danielle began her transition at 18, emphasizing this wasn't a snap decision but the culmination of over a decade of internal struggle. Her first surgery was breast augmentation at 19 and a half, followed years later by sex reassignment surgery (also called SRS, being post-op trans, sex change, or gender reassignment surgery).

Candace challenges Danielle on the breast augmentation choice, pointing out that choosing large breasts as the first step seems like someone playing dress-up rather than someone who genuinely understands womanhood. Danielle admits this is a fair criticism – she later realized she had hormone-induced breast growth equivalent to a B cup and didn't actually need the augmentation. She acknowledges this was about aesthetics and what she thought would make her "more beautiful" rather than a necessity.

The Mental Disorder Debate

Candace presses the fundamental question: Is transgenderism a mental disorder? She compares it to her own experience with anorexia, which she openly identifies as having been a mental disorder. She argues that acknowledging something as a mental disorder isn't an attack – it's simply recognizing when someone's mental state is "out of order."

Danielle counters by citing the American Psychiatric Association (APA), which states that being transgender is not a mental disorder. According to the APA and World Health Organization, what exists is gender dysphoria – the feeling of distress about one's gender. Danielle goes further, explaining that she doesn't even experience gender dysphoria anymore because she never feels like or sees herself as male. She argues that every individual is different, which is why blanket statements don't work.

Candace remains unconvinced, pointing out that the APA only recently updated their manual and predicts they'll continue updating it to accommodate other identities, including potentially "minor-attracted persons" (a term replacing pedophile). She argues that conservatives must guard against the erosion of objective reality, insisting that mental disorders exist regardless of whether the APA chooses to classify them as such.

The Rachel Dolezal Question

Candace introduces what becomes the most challenging question of the conversation: Is Rachel Dolezal black? Rachel Dolezal is the woman who wore dark makeup, grew her hair into an afro, and led the NAACP while claiming to be black, only for her very white parents to expose the truth.

Ray J immediately responds that Rachel Dolezal is not black. Danielle also agrees she is not black, calling it "costuming." But Candace presses the point: What's the difference? Both Rachel and Danielle believe internally they are something they weren't born as. Both took external steps to present as that identity. Both could share similar narratives about feeling different from a young age and being perceived by others as their chosen identity.

Danielle struggles with this comparison, repeatedly returning to the idea that Rachel is "costuming" while her own experience is genuine. She argues that the key difference is that she openly acknowledges she's not a biological woman – she identifies as a trans woman. When Candace points out that Rachel could say she's "transracial" just as Danielle is "transgender," the logical consistency becomes harder to maintain.

Ray J suggests they need to "analyze the question" more thoroughly, acknowledging it's a "very powerful question" that puts up a conceptual wall. Candace argues this discomfort exists because the question exposes a fundamental inconsistency: if feelings and personal identity override biological reality in one category, why not in others?

The Social Contagion Concern

Candace explains why conservatives feel they must be vocal about this issue: the concern about social contagion among children. She references the explosion in young people identifying as non-binary or transgender, noting these numbers were nowhere near this high in previous generations. She uses the analogy of cigarette smoking – how advertising made it popular, then counter-advertising reduced it dramatically.

Candace shares that she did an interview with Briana Ivy, a person who transitioned, had complications, and realized they were just a gay man. It was the only time Candace almost cried on her show, hearing Briana's regret about irreversible procedures and wishing they had heard voices warning them to wait. She expresses concern that shows like Ray J's contribute to a culture that makes transitioning seem easy and consequence-free.

Ray J acknowledges the complexity, distinguishing between people who are genuinely trans versus those following a trend. He emphasizes the importance of education through his various ventures: the Gage Agency, Gay RP, Ray Pride (a C3 organization), and The Gworls Club. His goal is creating spaces for straight, gay, and trans people to have conversations and reach understanding.

Danielle partially agrees with Candace's social contagion concern, shocking her by admitting that she sometimes sees people claiming to be trans who don't seem genuine. She describes seeing people hiking while presenting as men with beards who identify as trans, which doesn't align with her understanding of the trans experience. However, she maintains that genuine trans people exist and their experiences shouldn't be dismissed because of others who may be following trends.

The Slippery Slope Argument

Candace articulates the conservative fear: once you say there's no objective reality and anyone can identify as anything, everything becomes possible. This includes the 60-year-old man who identifies as 13 and commits acts of pedophilia, or people who identify as different ages or even different species (like those who identify as babies or animals).

Danielle finds this offensive, not wanting these extreme examples lumped together with trans identity. But Candace insists they're ideologically identical if we abandon objective reality. She argues that the only defense against the slippery slope is maintaining that objective biological reality exists and that feelings don't override facts.

This leads Candace to emphasize why she uses the term "mental disorder" – not to be cruel, but to maintain a framework where society can distinguish between reality and delusion. If being transgender isn't acknowledged as a mental disorder while anorexia and body dysmorphia are, it creates an inconsistent standard that could eventually be used to justify age identity, species identity, or any other disconnection from objective reality.

Parenting and Personal Identity

When discussing how they would handle their own children expressing trans identity, Ray J shares a vulnerable moment: he once put on a wig and found himself attracted to his own reflection, which shocked him so much he immediately removed it. He explains he wants to be the parent his kids can tell anything to, emphasizing support and open communication.

However, when Candace asks if he'd support his child doing heroin or pornography, Ray J clarifies he means he wants his children to feel comfortable telling him about problems so he can help them, not that he'd support any choice they make.

Candace brings up the examples of children claiming to be different things – her son saying he's a princess (she corrected him to prince), or wanting to be a merman like his sister is a mermaid. She emphasizes that children say ridiculous things constantly, which is why she finds it troubling when parents like Charlize Theron take a child's statement in the bathtub as definitive proof of trans identity.

Finding Common Ground

Despite fundamental disagreements, the conversation ends with mutual respect. Danielle acknowledges that she and Candace won't see eye to eye on everything but appreciates the opportunity for specific, nuanced conversation rather than broad generalizations. She emphasizes that trans individuals are not a monolith – what's true for her may not be true for another trans person.

Candace appreciates Danielle's willingness to acknowledge she's not a biological woman and doesn't claim to be one. This distinction matters to Candace because she sees many in the trans community as being dishonest about this fundamental reality. She finds Danielle's transparency and willingness to have a difficult conversation brave.

Ray J emphasizes the importance of continuing these conversations, even when they're uncomfortable. He believes that education happens through dialogue and that the LGBTQ community and the "straights" (as he jokingly puts it) need more opportunities to sit down together and work toward understanding.

The conversation concludes with information about The Gworls Club (spelled g-w-o-r-l-s), now streaming on Tronics Network. Ray J explains their goal isn't to benefit from drama but to uplift talent and tell stories correctly. He hopes this conversation will give people insight into how to have productive debates about controversial topics.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!