Up Next
Charlie Kirk Debates College Student on Abortion: When Life Begins and Why DNA Matters
12:24
Charlie Kirk Debates Pro-Choice Christian College Student on Abortion, Viability, and Human Rights
15:45
Charlie Kirk Explains Why Human Life Begins at Conception in Powerful Campus Debate on Abortion
10:17
Charlie Kirk Challenges College Students on When Human Life Begins and Abortion as Birth Control
Charlie Kirk engages college students in a thought-provoking discussion about when human life begins, receiving answers ranging from conception to birth. The conversation becomes increasingly intense as Kirk presents data revealing over one million abortions occur annually in America while two million families wait to adopt. Students grapple with defining personhood, consciousness, and fetal development, while Kirk challenges their logic on whether abortion has become a form of birth control. The exchange exposes deep philosophical divides on life, responsibility, and the consequences of separating sexual freedom from reproductive outcomes.
Defining the Beginning of Life
Charlie Kirk opens the conversation by asking a group of students a fundamental question: when does human life begin? The responses reveal significant disagreement even among those who share similar political leanings. One student suggests life begins at birth, arguing that cells can form in the uterus but a person isn't fully human until born. Another pins it to the heartbeat, which occurs around six weeks of pregnancy. A third student frames the question as identifying consciousness and personhood, suggesting around 30 weeks when most fetal development has occurred.
Kirk counters with scientific facts: heartbeats emerge around six weeks, brain waves even earlier, full ultrasound imaging shows a complete being around 12 weeks, and babies can now survive outside the womb as early as 25-26 weeks. He challenges the use of the term "fetus," noting it simply means "little human" in Latin, and suggests the terminology serves as a psychological coping mechanism to avoid acknowledging what abortion actually terminates.
The Subjectivity of Life and Consciousness
One student admits lacking scientific education on the biology but maintains that life is subjective—distinguishing between when an infant's body starts functioning versus when they perceive consciousness. This participant confesses uncertainty about when consciousness begins, highlighting a common challenge in the abortion debate: the inability to definitively identify when personhood emerges.
Kirk presses the point by comparing developmental stages, noting that a nine-month-old isn't the same as a one-month-old, yet development is continuous. The real question, he argues, is when does it start? He presents conception as the only logical answer to when life begins, since that's when the unique genetic code and continuous development process initiates.
Miscarriage, Knowledge, and Tragedy
The conversation shifts when students raise the point that many women experience miscarriages without even knowing they were pregnant, sometimes presenting as a heavy menstrual cycle. Kirk acknowledges this reality but maintains it doesn't diminish the life that was lost. He draws a crucial distinction between miscarriage and abortion: while both result in the loss of life, a miscarriage is typically not an act of human will, whereas abortion deliberately terminates a pregnancy.
When asked if he mourns an unknown miscarriage the same as an abortion, Kirk clarifies that while they're not mourned identically, a miscarriage remains a tragedy. The key difference lies in intent and action—one is often beyond human control, while the other represents a conscious choice to end a developing life.
The Million Abortion Reality
Kirk presents startling statistics that shift the conversation's trajectory: over one million abortions occur annually in America. When students guess tens of thousands, the actual number shocks even those familiar with the issue. One student suggests the real number could be even higher when accounting for unreported chemical abortions using mifepristone and Plan B, especially in states where abortion is restricted.
However, Kirk counters with Texas data showing a 90% abortion reduction rate where restrictions exist, challenging the claim that abortions simply go unreported. He then introduces another critical statistic: two million people actively wait on adoption lists in America. This means twice as many families want to adopt as there are abortions performed, undermining the argument about unwanted children having nowhere to go.
Poverty, Suffering, and the Death Sentence Question
A student raises the emotionally charged scenario of a woman who was assaulted or lacks resources, asking whether a child deserves to be brought into the world "just to suffer." Kirk rejects the premise that being born into poverty or difficult circumstances constitutes a guaranteed life of suffering. He emphasizes that abortion itself is a certain death sentence, whereas life—even in challenging circumstances—offers possibilities.
The discussion touches on the tension between acknowledging that some abortions occur for frivolous reasons while maintaining that this shouldn't justify blanket prohibition. Kirk challenges this logic by comparing it to murder: should murder be legal simply because defining exact circumstances is complex?
Informed Consent and Personal Responsibility
Kirk raises an interesting parallel about informed consent, comparing women seeking abortions to drug addicts. He questions why, if women aren't given proper informed consent about abortion's consequences, only abortion providers should face legal consequences rather than the women themselves—similar to how society treats drug dealers versus users.
A student responds that drug addiction creates chemical dependencies that impair choice, but Kirk counters by asking how often society has honest conversations with women about abortion's psychological aftermath. He cites increased risks of depression, anxiety, and medication dependence following abortion. When students argue that childbirth carries similar risks like postpartum depression, Kirk distinguishes between temporary conditions and the permanent ending of a life.
Is Abortion Birth Control?
Kirk presents data from the Guttmacher Institute showing that 97% of abortions are not performed due to life-threatening circumstances for the mother. He poses a direct question: has abortion become a form of birth control? While students resist the characterization, arguing that tens of millions of women use actual contraceptives, they struggle to deny that abortion functions as a backup when other methods fail or aren't used.
The conversation reaches its most contentious point when Kirk frames the issue in stark terms: people want the pleasure of sex without accepting responsibility for potential pregnancy. Students push back on this framing, with one noting the "orgasm gap" between men and women, suggesting women aren't even primarily motivated by pleasure. Kirk maintains his position that many seek a "loosey goosey lifestyle" without consequences, willing to end a developing life rather than accept responsibility for their choices.
Video Transcript
0:00
I'm just curious. When would you guys
0:01
say human life begins?
0:04
That's like a philosophical question for
0:06
the ages.
0:07
When there's a heartbeat.
0:09
When there's a heartbeat.
0:10
Or no, I guess.
0:12
See, now we have three different
0:13
answers. So, I'm just We have a I will
0:15
presume a group of women because we all
0:17
you all self-described as women. I'm
0:19
kidding. Um, when does life begin?
0:22
Heartbeat.
0:24
I'm going still say at birth. Even
0:26
though I know that your cells can be
0:28
warm in a brain. in the uterus. Um, but
0:31
yeah, I think you're not fully a human
0:33
until you're born.
0:35
Okay. And you said heartbeat, right?
0:37
Okay.
0:38
I think it's very difficult to answer. I
0:40
think mostly consciousness and
0:41
personhood is really what people are
0:43
seeking to identify and I believe how
0:45
would you have I'm sure you haven't know
0:46
how long is like how many weeks is a
0:48
full term of pregnancy?
0:50
It's it's a good question. I know very
0:51
well. Uh it's uh it's about 38 39 weeks.
0:54
40 is like at the furthest of just
0:56
40 weeks. So as far as I know like
0:57
around 30 weeks is when you see like
0:59
typically like most development of the
1:01
fetus has taken place. So I would say
1:03
like around that but yeah no I mean so
1:05
heartbeat is right around 6 weeks. Brain
1:07
waves are even before that. Um and you
1:10
could do an ultrasound at right around
1:12
you could start do ultrasounds at 8
1:13
weeks and you can see the full full
1:15
being uh right around 12 weeks and right
1:17
around 25 26 weeks are now the earliest
1:20
cases we have of babies that are able to
1:23
survive outside of the womb. Does anyone
1:24
have any other answers on that
1:27
of when?
1:28
No, I mean um I'm not like educated
1:31
scientifically enough about the biology
1:34
of all of it, but I agree. I think that
1:36
um life is a very subjective term. You
1:40
know, you could say uh when does the
1:42
infant's body in the womb start
1:44
functioning or you could say when do
1:46
they start perceiving
1:49
their consciousness? Um, and for me it's
1:53
when they start perceiving their
1:55
consciousness, but truly I have no idea
1:57
when that is.
1:58
Do you think it's Do you think it would
2:00
be important to Let me ask you this. If
2:02
if you knew for certain the baby, Would
2:04
you agree it's a baby?
2:06
Is that a good term to use if it's in a
2:08
a womb? Is that a baby?
2:09
I think most people would say fetus.
2:11
Fetus. Yeah.
2:12
Okay. So, what does fetus mean in Latin?
2:15
I think a fetus is a growing child. It's
2:17
a development,
2:18
right, Molly? You know, it means a
2:19
little human.
2:20
Yeah. Um, it's just using fetus is
2:22
nothing more than a cope for what you
2:24
know it is. It's a baby, right? So, it's
2:26
just
2:26
obviously not if we're here debating it.
2:28
I don't think it's a
2:29
You don't have to use the word fetus. It
2:30
makes people feel better. It's obviously
2:31
a baby.
2:31
No, I mean obviously you wouldn't take
2:33
like you know a fetus that just has like
2:36
a heart and like their brain isn't fully
2:38
formed and be like that's the same as
2:39
like a one-mon-old like we obviously see
2:42
differences between development from
2:43
then and there.
2:44
So, but then how about 30 weeks?
2:46
That's where it becomes a lot more
2:47
contentious. But the point being is that
2:49
we don't look at a fetus from its
2:51
beginning stages and be like, "Yeah,
2:52
that's the same thing as my like
2:54
3-month-old cousin."
2:55
Hold on. That's a 9-month-old is not the
2:57
same thing as a one-month-old.
2:58
Okay. So, you can go through the
3:00
progression of development continues.
3:02
The question is when does it start?
3:04
Yeah, that's a million-dollar question.
3:06
I agree with that. Do you think
3:07
conception?
3:08
Of course. That's the only answer.
3:10
Most women, I don't believe even know
3:12
that they're pregnant before 6 weeks. So
3:14
like around like these the heartbeat
3:16
the the knowledge of your pregnancy
3:17
doesn't mean that you're not pregnant.
3:19
No, no, no. That's not what I'm saying.
3:20
But I'm saying like practicalitywise,
3:22
there are many instances of women who
3:24
act who have miscarriages without even
3:27
ever knowing because it might just
3:28
present as like a very heavy cycle that
3:30
month.
3:30
That's fine. But it doesn't make it any
3:32
less life, right? Sure. Go ahead, Molly.
3:34
No, but do you do you mourn that
3:36
miscarriage in the same way you mourn an
3:38
abortion like a
3:39
not the same way? No, it's not the same
3:41
way. No, but it's still it's still a
3:42
tragedy. A miscarriage is a tragedy, but
3:45
an abortion,
3:45
even if she doesn't know about it,
3:47
but an abortion is an act of human will.
3:49
A miscarriage most times is not. Now,
3:52
sometimes it can be a miscarriage
3:54
because you drank alcohol and you didn't
3:55
know you were pregnant or you might have
3:56
taken a drug that have side effects, but
3:59
yes, a mis a miscarriage is a tragedy.
4:01
Yes.
4:01
I have a question. Um, so
4:04
do you care about the children once
4:06
they're born?
4:07
I mean, I care a lot about them. Yeah.
4:09
So how so if a if say a woman got rword
4:14
worded or something say like she didn't
4:16
have a good life do you still think that
4:18
child deserves to be brought into the
4:20
world just to suffer?
4:21
Well so it's not a guarantee of
4:23
suffering number one sec the answer is
4:26
yes the life should be brought into the
4:27
world there are twice as many people on
4:29
the adoption waiting list than so many
4:32
people let me ask you guys and I I don't
4:34
I'm just curious how many abortions do
4:36
you think there are a year in America? I
4:37
have
4:37
tens of thousands, I assume.
4:39
Any other guesses?
4:40
No, I have no clue.
4:42
What if I told you there was over a
4:43
million abortions every year?
4:44
That wouldn't surprise me at all.
4:46
But you went from tens of thousands to a
4:48
million.
4:48
I mean, there's billions of people on
4:50
the on the
4:51
Yeah, there's 340 million in America.
4:53
That's right. No, but do you think does
4:54
it
4:54
as far as like reported ones? Because
4:56
even just reported data is going to be
4:57
incomplete because
4:58
it doesn't count mythopressinone, which
5:00
is the chemical abortion that people
5:02
have at home. It doesn't count plan B,
5:03
right? And even if like abortion were
5:05
illegal, for example, we stopped
5:06
gathering data on like who procures
5:08
abortions, there would be so many.
5:10
There's so many now, even with states
5:12
where it's still legal.
5:13
Texas, it's gone down dramatically. So
5:14
hundreds of
5:15
No, they're still happening. It's just
5:17
not being accounted for. 90% of
5:19
women are just doing it to themselves,
5:20
right? It's a 90% abortion reduction
5:22
rate in Texas. I don't want to dwell on
5:23
that too much, though. I'm just So
5:25
there's a million abortions every single
5:27
year, and there's twice as many people
5:30
on the adopt there's two million people
5:31
actively on the adoption waiting list.
5:33
So there's really no such thing
5:35
currently, there could be, but currently
5:36
of an unwanted child. So there's 2
5:38
million people wanting to adopt and
5:41
there's a million people that have
5:42
abortions every single year. So there's
5:44
twice as many people that want to get a
5:46
child. Now, there's a longer
5:48
conversation about making it less
5:49
bureaucratic without allowing bad people
5:51
to adopt kids for bad reasons. I'm
5:54
perfectly open for that conversation,
5:55
but um to answer your question, I don't
5:58
love the premise. It's a good It's a
6:00
really good question because a lot of
6:01
people have it. I don't necessarily
6:03
believe being born in poverty is a death
6:06
sentence or is a reason to terminate.
6:08
No, no. I But abortion is a death
6:10
sentence.
6:10
I think there are frivolous reasons to
6:12
procure abortions, but I don't believe
6:13
that that just because there are
6:14
frivolous reasons to get them, that
6:15
means it should be outlawed.
6:17
But should murder be outlawed?
6:19
Yeah. But like you were saying, you even
6:22
though you believe that those women have
6:24
a hand in committing the murder and
6:25
infanticide basically of their own
6:27
children, they shouldn't go to jail.
6:28
They have not been given informed
6:29
consent. Do you have that opinion with
6:31
people who are addicted to drugs?
6:33
Do you think only drug dealers should go
6:34
to jail but not people who actually try
6:36
to buy drugs and consume them?
6:37
It depends. It depends what drug it is.
6:38
It depends the category, the class, the
6:40
Is there a single drug where you would
6:41
say that somebody who is buying and
6:42
consuming drugs that they are addicted
6:44
to should not be going to jail, but
6:46
they're only their drug dealer should be
6:47
going to jail.
6:48
I mean, I think fentanyl and heroin
6:50
potentially, but it's a completely
6:51
separate issue because a lot of people
6:53
know the informed consent of heroin and
6:54
fentanyl. It's not like we have PSAs, we
6:56
have billboards, stop using fentanyl,
6:58
stop doing fentanyl. How many times have
6:59
you heard that? Have you ever
7:00
But they have a chemical deficiency now
7:02
that prevents them from being able to
7:03
make that choice.
7:04
How often have we ever had an honest
7:05
conversation with women in this country
7:07
saying that having an abortion increases
7:09
the threat the chances for depression,
7:11
anxiety, medication, dependence. Um, so
7:14
does having a kid.
7:15
What?
7:16
Having children carries all of those
7:18
same risks.
7:19
You think having children goes into you
7:21
think having children
7:22
No, don't mischaracterize me. That's not
7:24
true.
7:24
I'm not going to say that having a child
7:26
necessarily gives you depression. And
7:27
then that's what she said.
7:29
It can come with it. Like postpartum
7:31
depression for example is extremely
7:32
common.
7:32
It's temporary and shortlived. And
7:34
obviously
7:35
not always
7:38
temporary and shortlived. That's not
7:40
permanent.
7:41
But when years of living with postpartum
7:43
depression can simply constitute a
7:45
temporary medical issue.
7:47
Let's theoretically even grant. So So
7:49
you're saying because of potential
7:50
postpartum depression or financial
7:52
burdens, the moral answer is allow women
7:55
to go in.
7:56
No, that was never my argument. This had
7:57
nothing to do with morality. This was a
7:58
completely separate question. I'm only
8:00
saying that I feel like you're
8:01
trivializing and downplaying how serious
8:03
conditions like postpartum depression
8:04
can be when you want to write it off as
8:06
like a temporary medical obviously when
8:08
it can be yearslong battle.
8:10
Having children is a serious choice out.
8:12
So what percentage of abortions
8:14
according to the Gutmcker Institute are
8:16
not not life of the mother. What
8:18
percentage would you say?
8:19
Probably the vast majority.
8:20
97%. So is abortion now birth control?
8:23
Yes or no?
8:25
No, I don't think so. I think that's uh
8:27
situational to each and every
8:29
Molly. Do you think that birth control
8:31
it could be called birth control in
8:32
certain
8:33
because you're talking about over a
8:34
million abortion, but there's tens of
8:35
millions of women that are on birth
8:37
control that are that have IUDs that
8:39
take birth control pills. So obviously
8:41
that's not the only reason why.
8:42
But it's a form of birth control, isn't
8:44
it?
8:44
It's a form of birth control, but it's
8:46
you acknowledge that it's not the
8:48
predominant form of birth control.
8:49
No, I didn't say that. No, hold on. I
8:50
said it's birth control.
8:51
Yeah, but we're not disagreeing with the
8:52
category. I'm talking about the
8:53
prevalence of If it's birth control,
8:55
then why would we allow it to continue
8:58
if it's not if you put the life the
9:01
mother who we can debate?
9:02
I didn't.
9:03
But no, I'm going to put that aside for
9:04
a second. Then why should we allow a
9:06
horrific procedure
9:08
to continue that has such heavy and dire
9:11
consequences and results in a child not
9:13
being able to live outside of the womb?
9:15
You're loading it so much by saying a
9:16
horrific procedure. Most women who
9:18
procure abortions actually report being
9:21
happy longterm because they made the
9:22
choice. Because there's many different
9:24
reasons why women get abortion. Some
9:25
women aren't in a financial position to
9:26
have a child at that time and actually
9:28
decide to have children later.
9:29
How'd they get pregnant?
9:30
What do you mean? They had sex
9:31
unprotected or an accident.
9:33
So they they want the orgasm without the
9:35
responsibility.
9:36
Do you think the majority of women are
9:38
having orgasms and sex? Are you serious?
9:41
Have you seen the studies on orgasm gaps
9:43
between men and women? I'll
9:44
be honest. So they want all the
9:45
pleasure. They want all
9:47
but it's it's you want you want all the
9:49
loose lifestyle but none of the
9:51
responsibilities.
9:52
Now now you're you're framing it like
9:53
the punishment for have it should like
9:55
orgasm should be punished. No no the way
9:57
that you're framing it which is not a
9:59
punishment. You want the loosey goosey
10:00
parts of sex like the orgasm but you
10:02
don't want the responsibility of a
10:03
child. It's like yeah some people want
10:04
to be able to have sex.
10:06
Okay. No you you articulate it
10:07
perfectly. You I'm going to be able to
10:09
have sex how I want and if I have to go
10:11
put a dagger through have someone put a
10:12
dagger through a child for me then so be
10:14
it.
Related Books
Browse Conservative Books
