Charlie Kirk Confronts Student Who Shifted from Opposing to Supporting the LGBT Community on Gender Identity
Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.
Up Next
Charlie Kirk Challenges College Student on Gender Ideology and Biological Reality in Revealing Campus Exchange
3:27
Charlie Kirk Debates Student on Gender Identity, Transgenderism, and Objective Truth at Campus Event
7:06
Charlie Kirk Confronts Student on Transgender Suicide Rates and Transition Regret Community
1:06
Charlie Kirk Confronts Student Who Shifted from Opposing to Supporting the LGBT Community on Gender Identity
A college student approaches Charlie Kirk to discuss a personal shift in perspective regarding the LGBT community, specifically asking about Blair White, a trans woman. What begins as a seemingly genuine question quickly turns into a tense debate about the nature of gender, gender dysphoria, and whether pronouns reflect biological reality or social constructs. Kirk challenges the student's definitions and arguments, ultimately ending the exchange when the conversation breaks down into accusations of rambling and personal jabs.
A student opens the conversation by explaining a personal transformation. Growing up, the student didn't particularly like the LGBT community, but over recent years, that perspective shifted to one of support and appreciation. The student wanted to ask Charlie Kirk about a specific person in that community: Blair White.
Kirk admits he hasn't thought about Blair White in a while, then clarifies his understanding. The student confirms that Blair White is a trans woman who appeared on a Jubilee debate with Ben Shapiro. Kirk immediately reframes the discussion, calling Blair White "a fake woman" and then clarifying: "a man who masquerades as a woman."
The Restaurant Hypothetical
The student presses Kirk on how he would refer to Blair White in a public setting, like a restaurant. Kirk responds that just because someone might appear a certain way doesn't change biological reality. He draws a comparison: someone could wear blackface, but that doesn't make them Black. The student seems to suggest that if Blair White looks like a woman, one would naturally refer to her as such.
Kirk pushes back, stating that the student is describing "a man who wears the costume of a woman." The student deflects by saying, "if you believe that value system then I guess."
What Is a Woman?
Kirk then asks the fundamental question: "What is a woman?" The student initially gives a flippant answer about someone who needs a man to open a pickle jar, then mentions opening his girlfriend's pickle jars. The audio becomes difficult to hear, and Kirk asks him to repeat himself multiple times.
When Kirk asks if that's the student's final answer, the student shifts tone and says, "Obviously the Bible says that a woman is a person with a vagina, obviously." However, the student then adds that he believes gender dysphoria is a real thing and scientifically proven.
Mental Disorder or Soul in the Wrong Body?
Kirk agrees that gender dysphoria is real, but frames it as a mental delusion. The student objects to the word "delusion," preferring "disorder." Kirk accepts that framing but questions whether what a person believes they are actually matches reality.
The student then offers a definition: "a trans woman is a person with a woman's soul and a man's body." Kirk points out the contradiction in the student's earlier definition of a woman being someone who can't open a pickle jar. If a trans woman is biologically male, then by the student's own logic, they could open a pickle jar, making the definition collapse.
The student insists he doesn't think lowly of women and believes that if someone has gender dysphoria and looks like a woman, they should be referred to as such. Kirk responds that this reduces womanhood to appearance—"put on a bra with a dress and makeup"—and that this is actually a low view of women.
Pronouns as Social Constructs
The student argues that pronouns are a social concept. He says that when you see someone who looks like a woman, you call them "she," and that's just how society works. Kirk challenges this by asking: "If you can't pick your adjectives, why can you pick your pronouns?"
The student struggles to respond coherently as the crowd noise increases. Kirk suggests that calling someone by the wrong pronoun because they're wearing a costume is like being tricked by someone in a Halloween outfit. The person is suffering from a mental disorder, and society shouldn't pander to that suffering.
Truth as Liberation
Kirk offers his perspective: instead of affirming someone's delusion, society should offer them a way out by telling the truth. He argues that this truth liberates people from the path of medical transition, including surgeries and hormone treatments like Lupron.
The student says he can't hear Kirk due to crowd noise and asks him to repeat. Kirk begins to restate his point but the student interrupts, claiming Kirk was "rambling." Kirk takes offense and says, "If you're going to be a jerk, we're done. Next question."
The Final Jab
As the conversation ends, Kirk delivers a parting shot: "By the way, you don't get to pick your adjectives. You aren't very tall and you can't change that." The exchange concludes with Kirk calling for the next question.
