Charlie Kirk Explains Why College Is a Scam and Defends Absolute Truth on Gender Ideology

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Charlie Kirk Tells Math Major Why AI Will Replace Actuaries and College Is a Scam

Charlie Kirk Tells Math Major Why AI Will Replace Actuaries and College Is a Scam

9:30

Charlie Kirk Challenges UNLV Student: Is College Actually a Scam or a Smart Investment?

Charlie Kirk Challenges UNLV Student: Is College Actually a Scam or a Smart Investment?

9:03

Charlie Kirk Challenges the College-for-Everyone Myth and Calls for More Trade School Focus

Charlie Kirk Challenges the College-for-Everyone Myth and Calls for More Trade School Focus

2:00

Charlie Kirk Explains Why College Is a Scam and Defends Absolute Truth on Gender Ideology

Charlie Kirk addresses disagreements on housing policy, college enrollment, and gender ideology in this candid exchange with students. Kirk argues that Europe isn't succeeding with centralized policies, contends that America has too many people attending college with a 41% dropout rate, and defends the need for more welders and plumbers over post-modernism students. He tackles the slippery slope fallacy, explains why biological reality matters in the transgender debate, discusses immigration moratoriums, and outlines what conservatives need to build for the future. Kirk doesn't hold back on controversial topics, from Disney's transformation into what he calls a "child predator operation" to why he believes weed legalization made Colorado messier and less enjoyable.

June 1, 2023

The College Enrollment Crisis

When challenged by a student who believed America should follow Europe's centralized college policies, Kirk rejected the premise entirely. He pointed out that America's national college graduation rate sits at just 59%, meaning 41% of students who enroll in college never complete their degree. When he asked the audience how many knew someone who dropped out of college, every hand went up.

Kirk's solution is radical: dramatically decline college enrollment across the country. He argues that America needs more welders, plumbers, electricians, police officers, and entrepreneurs—people who work with their hands—and far fewer students studying post-modernism in classrooms. He compared the current higher education system to a Bernie Madoff-style scam, pointing out that students are forced to take classes with no relevance to their degrees.

The fundamental problem, according to Kirk, is that college makes young people poorer, less happy, and less likely to flourish. He describes it as a generation that "borrowed money they don't have to study things that don't matter to find jobs that don't exist." His proposed solution involves eliminating federal and state subsidies, forcing colleges to support themselves through donor funding rather than taxpayer money.

Germany Gets One Thing Right

Kirk acknowledged one area where he agrees with European policy: Germany's emphasis on technical education and skilled trades. He lamented that muscular labor has been insulted and talked down to in American culture, with suburban families quietly admitting they don't want their children working construction or sweating for a living. This cultural shift has created what Kirk calls a "hyper-educated, very unwise generation that's super in debt and has pieces of paper that mean absolutely nothing."

He noted that France is actually moving away from American-style woke universities, with Emmanuel Macron running on a platform to reject American woke ideology seeping into French institutions. Kirk used this as evidence that even Europe is rejecting what has infected American higher education.

Defending Absolute Truth on Gender

When a student asked Kirk to give a straight yes or no answer on whether the acceptance of queer people in society is a good thing, Kirk asked for definitions of both "acceptance" and "queer." The exchange quickly moved to the fundamental question: "What is a woman?"

The student responded that a woman is someone who identifies as a woman. Kirk pressed further, asking if someone who can become pregnant would be defined as a woman. When the student said it depends on whether they identify as a woman, Kirk drove to the core issue: "Do you believe that truth is objective or subjective? Do you believe in absolute truth?"

Kirk argued that if absolute truth exists, society should have absolute terms for what an infant-bearing person is—otherwise known as a woman. He questioned why society should accept people identifying as different genders but not accept people who identify as younger ages, pointing out that both involve brain formation issues and could be classified as disorders.

The NCAA Swimming Controversy

Kirk brought up the University of Pennsylvania swimmer who transitioned from male to female, moving from the 462nd best male swimmer to NCAA Champion as a female swimmer. When the student suggested NCAA rules make competition fair for people who transition, Kirk argued the swimmer was a narcissist who transitioned to gain a competitive advantage.

He framed this as a moral question: men and women have biological differences, including testosterone levels and physical strength. Women have lower testosterone and can be easily exploited by men, making it incumbent on men to protect women against exploitation by men who think they are women.

The Slippery Slope Isn't Always a Fallacy

A biology student asked Kirk about the slippery slope argument, noting it's often dismissed as a logical fallacy but observing that society moved from "let us get married" to "we want to teach sexuality to your elementary schoolers." Kirk acknowledged that technically it is a logical fallacy because it cannot be scientifically or mathematically applied to every situation. However, he insisted that slippery slopes are real and happen throughout history.

He provided multiple examples: seatbelt laws that stopped being intrusive, abortion moving from "safe, legal, and rare" to late-term and even post-birth abortion in some states, and the progression from same-sex marriage to forcing bakers to make cakes to teaching graphic sex education to five-year-olds. Kirk encouraged the student to add nuance to the argument—while it's not applicable to every issue, the erosion of liberty, decency, and virtue through incremental steps is demonstrably real.

What Conservatives Need to Build

When an anarchist plumber asked what young people can do beyond voting to push the country in the right direction, Kirk emphasized the importance of building. He outlined several key areas: having bigger families, supporting churches and pastors who proclaim truth, and creating conservative-owned businesses that share their values and are cancel-proof.

Kirk praised Elon Musk as a builder, noting his appreciation for people who create rather than just complain. He challenged the audience to think ambitiously: "Are we going to build the next Disney?" He pointed out that someone in the room has the potential to build a multi-billion dollar company, suggesting they could start the next Starbucks or create a conservative version of TaskRabbit.

He used his own story as evidence that American entrepreneurship is still alive: starting Turning Point USA at age 18 with no money or connections in the suburbs of Chicago, now present on thousands of campuses with over 250 staff members. Kirk emphasized that conservatives need to think positively and take risks, building things that are ambitious and beautiful—families, communities, churches, and businesses.

The Ron DeSantis Model

When asked how conservatives can create unified counter-narratives when they're more atomized than the left, Kirk pointed to Florida Governor Ron DeSantis as a three-and-a-half-year test case of what conservatism should look like. He listed DeSantis's accomplishments: banning critical race theory, not allowing kids to be taught divisive content in schools, maintaining law and order with no-bail policies, funding police and fatherhood initiatives, refusing lockdowns, rejecting vaccine mandates, and pushing back against congressional mask requirements.

Kirk argued that woke policies are so unbelievably stupid and unpopular that they will face an "extinction event" politically. He noted that normal everyday people, especially Hispanic voters, are rejecting messages about defunding police, eliminating prisons, and claims that men can become pregnant. This shared opposition to woke ideology is creating unity similar to how conservatives unified against the Soviet Union in the 1980s.

Immigration Moratorium and Assimilation

Kirk called for a complete moratorium on immigration, arguing that America needs to slow down and "digest the meal" to allow assimilation to happen. He pointed to the 1950s and early 1960s when America ratcheted back to almost zero immigration as a precedent, noting this was done to ensure World War II veterans had good wages and jobs.

He criticized the current legal immigration system for prioritizing people who don't share Western values while excluding those who do. Kirk specifically called out Minneapolis as unrecognizable after accepting large numbers of immigrants, citing the city council's approval of a call to prayer and Representative Ilhan Omar's election as examples of failed immigration policy. He argued that Omar, despite being rescued from a Kenyan refugee camp through American generosity, speaks nothing but negative things about the country.

Kirk proposed that America should implement an English language test for immigrants, prioritize certain countries that share Western values over others, and ensure immigrants believe in the Constitution. He emphasized this isn't racial but value-based, noting that Cubans make some of the greatest Americans. The fundamental question should be whether immigration makes America more free while fulfilling obligations to current countrymen.

Christian Response to Gender Ideology

When asked how Christians should interact lovingly with people struggling with gender ideology while maintaining absolute truth, Kirk's answer was simple: don't lie. He explained that love isn't giving people what they want but helping them get toward things that are true, good, and beautiful. Assisting or subsidizing someone to chemically castrate themselves is not the right thing in any form.

Kirk noted that suicide rates are extremely high for people who transition, and there are over 30,000 people in an open Facebook group who regret their transition and wish they could reverse it. He said Christians should pray for people struggling with gender dysphoria to have an encounter with Jesus Christ and realize they've been living a lie. From a Christian perspective, everything should be done with both grace and truth—wanting people to be born anew but refusing to lie, including refusing to call somebody something they aren't.

Why Weed Legalization Failed Colorado

Though not the main focus, Kirk shared an unpopular opinion about marijuana legalization in Colorado. He stated he was against it when it happened and remains against it now, believing weed does not improve the human condition and makes people less free, not more free. Having visited Colorado his whole life, he observed that the moment the state legalized marijuana, the place became messier, dirtier, and less enjoyable.

When asked about psychedelic drugs for therapy, Kirk admitted he doesn't know enough about the topic in general. However, he specifically mentioned ketamine therapy—administered intravenously in controlled medical environments—as showing phenomenal data for helping people with alcohol addiction, depression, and anxiety. He warned strongly against Ayahuasca, a psychedelic used in Central and South America, saying he's seen it destroy people's lives despite claims it's for medical purposes.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!