Riley Gaines Shares How Lia Thomas Stole Her National Championship and Exposed Himself in the Locker Room

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Charlie Kirk and Senator Josh Hawley Discuss the Crisis of Masculinity and Biblical Manhood in America

Charlie Kirk and Senator Josh Hawley Discuss the Crisis of Masculinity and Biblical Manhood in America

1:05:49

Charlie Kirk and Barry Meguiar on Finding Joy in Faith, Tucker Carlson's Spiritual Battle, and Igniting Your Life for Christ

Charlie Kirk and Barry Meguiar on Finding Joy in Faith, Tucker Carlson's Spiritual Battle, and Igniting Your Life for Christ

1:16:16

Riley Gaines Testifies Before Senators on Competing Against Biological Male Lia Thomas at NCAA Championships

Riley Gaines Testifies Before Senators on Competing Against Biological Male Lia Thomas at NCAA Championships

5:24

Riley Gaines Shares How Lia Thomas Stole Her National Championship and Exposed Himself in the Locker Room

Riley Gaines details her experience competing against biological male Lia Thomas at the NCAA swimming championships, where she was forced to tie for fifth place and give up her trophy for a photo opportunity. The former University of Kentucky swimmer describes the trauma of sharing a locker room with a six-foot-four male who exposed his genitalia, the conspiracy of silence from coaches and officials, and why she transitioned from dental school to fighting the transgender movement full-time. Speaking at Dream City Church's Freedom Night in America, Gaines calls out the NCAA, University of Pennsylvania, and other institutions for sacrificing women's safety and fairness to validate one man's delusions.

Categories: Charlie's Faith
September 7, 2023

Welcome to Freedom Night in America

Pastor Luke Barnett opened the evening at Dream City Church, welcoming attendees to Freedom Night in America on a Wednesday evening. He shared a parable about a father who instructed his son to move a massive boulder, illustrating how we often try to handle life's challenges on our own instead of asking God for help. After leading a salvation prayer for those who wanted to accept Christ, Barnett explained that the evening's offering would support rescuing victims of human trafficking and outreach to those on the streets of Phoenix.

Barnett made a bold declaration that drew applause: if authorities try to implement lockdowns again, Dream City Church will not comply with government mandates regarding masks or church shutdowns. He emphasized the importance of having a church home that stands firm on biblical principles.

Charlie Kirk Introduces the Transgender Crisis

Charlie Kirk took the stage to address what he called a cultural revolution happening in America, comparing it to Mao's revolution in China. He explained how the transgender movement went from something on the fringes to a state-run religion of the federal government, with Pride flags at the White House and CDC officials claiming biological men can give birth and lactate.

Kirk referenced the famous question posed by Matt Walsh: "What is a woman?" He noted that tonight's speaker would be the first woman ever at Freedom Night in America. Kirk read from Deuteronomy 22:5, which states that a woman shall not wear a man's garment nor shall a man put on a woman's cloak, for whoever does these things is an abomination to the Lord. He also quoted Genesis, where God created male and female in his image, emphasizing that these distinctions keep us free.

Riley Gaines Takes the Stage

Kirk introduced Riley Gaines, the former University of Kentucky swimmer who had a national championship stolen from her. Gaines began by joking that she might be the first woman to participate in this event, but apparently today you can identify as whatever you want. When asked "What is a woman?" she gave the biological textbook definition: an adult human female, someone who has the capabilities to produce eggs or ova, with XX chromosomes.

Eighteen Years of Sacrifice

Gaines shared her journey as a competitive swimmer, starting at age four and competing until graduation at 22—eighteen years of her life dedicated to the sport. She described the grueling schedule: six hours in the water daily, swimming ten miles, with three hours before 8 AM. Practice ran from 5 AM to 8 AM, then class, then practice again from 1:30 to 4:30 PM, followed by dinner at 4:45 PM, icing shoulders, homework, and bed, only to repeat it all the next day.

Her sophomore year, just three days before national championships in March 2020, coaches pulled the team out of the water and told them to pack and leave that night. Everything shut down due to COVID-19. She had to swim in a lake in Tennessee every single day wearing a wetsuit. When she returned junior year, she finished seventh in the country, earning All-American honors. But she knew her senior year she wanted to become a national champion—the fastest female in the country in her event.

The Mysterious Lia Thomas

Senior year arrived, and Gaines was ranked third in the country, trailing by only hundredths of a second behind someone she knew well. But the person leading the country was a name she had never heard: Lia Thomas. Multiple red flags appeared. This was supposedly a senior from University of Pennsylvania, not a school known for producing fast swimmers. This person was leading the country by body lengths in the hundred freestyle and all freestyle events up to the mile—an impossibility, as you don't have your best 200-meter runner also be your best marathon runner.

When Gaines looked up Lia Thomas on the USA Swimming database, which tracks swimmers from age eight onward, there was no history. She continued searching until an article revealed that Lia Thomas was formerly Will Thomas, who swam three years on the men's team at University of Pennsylvania before switching to the women's team. Gaines felt relief, thinking the NCAA would see the obvious injustice—a mediocre man ranked 462nd the year prior when competing against men.

But the NCAA saw nothing wrong. They announced that Thomas swimming with the women was non-negotiable.

The Day Everything Changed

On the first day of competition, Gaines watched from the side of the pool as Thomas swam to a national title, beating Olympians and American record holders by body lengths. The second day featured the 200 freestyle, the event both Thomas and Gaines competed in. They swam prelims, both qualified top eight, and returned that evening for finals.

They dove in, raced, and touched the wall. Impossibly, they had tied—the exact same time down to the hundredth of a second. Gaines noted the divine providence: "God has his hand on this."

Behind the awards podium, where competitors receive their trophies and are named All-Americans, an official looked at Thomas (six-foot-four, despite Wikipedia claiming six-foot-one) and Gaines and said: "Great job, but you guys tied and we only have one trophy. Sorry Riley, we're giving this trophy to Leah."

Gaines, heart rate and adrenaline still high, asked the question no one dared ask all season: "Why? I know we tied, but why are you adamant on giving this trophy to a man in the women's 200 freestyle?"

The official's face sank. He didn't believe what he was saying, his eyes looked saddened, but he told her: "Riley, we've been advised when pictures are being taken, Leah has to have the trophy. You can pose with this one but you give yours back. Leah takes the trophy home. End of story. There's nothing we can do."

The Locker Room Violation

That moment pushed Gaines over the edge. The NCAA reduced everything the women worked their entire lives for to a photo op to validate the feelings and identity of a male at the expense of their own. But there was more—the locker room situation and the silencing.

The athletes were never forewarned they would be sharing a locker room. The only time they became aware they would be undressing inches away from a six-foot-four man who was fully intact with exposed male genitalia was when they were inches away from a six-foot-four man who was fully intact with exposed male genitalia.

Gaines described the scene: swimming locker rooms aren't places of modesty. Racing suits are skin-tight and take about fifteen minutes to put on—fifteen minutes of poking, prodding, and tucking until your nail beds bleed. It's typically a loud environment, buzzing with chatter as top athletes from around the country reunite.

Gaines had her back turned when suddenly everything went dead silent. She turned around and looked up—there was a man undressing out of his women's swimsuit. The experience was awkward, embarrassing, uncomfortable, but most importantly, traumatizing. Not just because of what they had to see, but because of how easy it was for authority figures to totally dismiss their rights to privacy.

Gaines immediately left and approached an official on the pool deck: "I know the guidelines that allowed Thomas at the meet—twelve months of hormone replacement therapy. But what are the guidelines that allowed a man into our locker room?"

The official nonchalantly replied: "We actually got around this by making locker rooms unisex."

Gaines realized two things. First, by admitting they changed the rules, they were admitting Thomas isn't a woman. Second, making locker rooms unisex meant any man—any coach, parent, official, or pervert—would have had full access to their changing area. And they weren't even told about it.

The Twilight Zone of NCAA Competition

At the same meet, there was another trans athlete: a female identifying as a man. Athletes were told to use he/him pronouns for this individual, formerly Izzy, now Isaac, who swam only in a speedo. Picture the finals of the hundred freestyle: a woman in a speedo and a man with a bulge in a women's swimsuit racing next to each other.

Izzy/Isaac finished fifth in the country in the hundred freestyle. If this were really based on gender identity, why was this athlete competing with the women? Because Izzy/Isaac would never be able to compete at that level against men. As a top-five female in the country, this athlete now finishes dead last competing against men. Gaines watched one meet where the only males this athlete beat was a male swimmer with one arm—highlighting what's at stake.

Standing on the Podium

Standing on that podium holding a trophy she knew she had to give back, Gaines had a realization: if women weren't willing to stick up for themselves, how could they expect someone else to stick up for them? They were standing there applauding and smiling, waiting for some hero to save them. But this had to come from them.

Gaines graduated with her degree in human health sciences and health law. She had already accepted her seat into dental school and put her deposit down, planning to do endodontics (root canals). Instead, she found herself thrust into what she calls an even more painful fight.

The Conspiracy of Silence

Gaines and Kirk discussed how this wasn't just one person—it was a conspiracy of silence involving the University of Kentucky, University of Pennsylvania, the NCAA, and political figures. Athletes faced emotional blackmail. They were told they couldn't take a stance because their school had taken a stance for them. They were warned they would never get a job, never get into grad school, would lose friends, scholarships, and playing time. This would follow them forever—they'd be labeled transphobes.

When Thomas's teammates sent an email—sixteen of them plus parents—expressing discomfort about the locker room, their university responded with counseling resources, suggesting they needed help for feeling uncomfortable seeing male genitalia. They were forced to attend mandatory LGBTQ education meetings weekly to learn how just by being cisgender they were oppressing Lia Thomas.

Athletes were told that if they spoke out and any harm came to Thomas—physical, mental, emotional, through social media—they would be solely responsible, potentially causing a death, making them murderers. The message was clear: be quiet and listen to those who know what's best.

NCAA Woman of the Year Nomination

After everything, Gaines was nominated for NCAA Woman of the Year, the most prestigious honor for collegiate female athletes. She had accomplished incredible things: twelve-time All-American, five-time SEC Champion, SEC record holder in the 200 butterfly. She scored in the top percentile of the dental admissions test, graduated with high honors, and was SEC Scholar Athlete of the Year and SEC Community Service Leader of the Year for her work with the Special Olympics swim team.

Each university gets one nominee. University of Kentucky had the number one WNBA draft pick, Abby Steiner breaking world records in track and field, a national championship volleyball team, and a national championship rifle team. They chose Gaines.

Then the full list was released—it wasn't exclusive to women. Lia Thomas was University of Pennsylvania's nominee. The award became meaningless to Gaines.

She decided to attend the NCAA conference where they would announce the winner. After sending letters and emails with no response, she brought a legal demand letter expressing that if they don't stop discriminating on the basis of sex, there will be legal action. She also bought a booth at the convention hall (after being denied twice under her real name and accepted under an alias), where she distributed bracelets about Title IX and pamphlets.

Every single athletic director who walked by heard her story about the locker room, the silencing, the unfair competition. Every single one said, "Thank you for doing what you're doing. Keep going." At first she felt encouraged, but as it continued, she grew frustrated. If everyone agreed, where was the discrepancy?

When she asked if they would put their name to it, they quickly turned: "We can't have lawsuits. I'm the breadwinner for my family. I can't risk losing my job."

Even the NCAA president, who publicly released a statement saying "I unequivocally stand in my decision to allow Lia Thomas to swim with the women because it's based in evolving science," privately told Gaines at the same conference: "Keep going, keep fighting, thank you for doing what you're doing." The irony—he was the one they were fighting.

Gaines concluded: the people enforcing this don't even believe it. They're cowards, spineless, with no backbone.

The Alphabet Mafia

Kirk called the transgender movement an "alphabet Mafia" that extorts, blackmails, and threatens. He referenced "The Godfather"—you wake up with a horse's head in your bed. Today, you wake up with a rainbow flag on your mailbox, marked for extermination. These are zealots who will hunt families down. Kirk has full-time security because the trans lobby wants to murder him.

They tried to take Gaines hostage at a Turning Point event. These aren't peaceful or polite people—many are pharmaceutically deranged, mentally disturbed people given powerful pharmacological compounds. Some go on to shoot up schools, like in Nashville, or attempt to, like in Colorado. Kirk asked where the Nashville trans shooter's manifesto went—it mysteriously disappeared.

These are zealots, not "live and let live" people. They're mentally disturbed individuals who want to murder many Americans. Kirk urged people to stop acting like this is a debate and prevent these individuals from participating in athletics and entering locker rooms. Stop cowering to the mafia. Stop giving terrorists what they want. They're holding the entire country hostage.

This Is Widespread

Gaines emphasized this isn't isolated—it's happening in every sport, every state, every level, every division. She gets messages daily from young girls in sixth grade playing basketball with boys on their middle school team. She gets calls from parents crying, watching their daughters get obliterated in their sport, knowing their daughter is being exploited in a locker room. She gets messages from coaches who don't know how to defend their athletes.

She could list a hundred examples off the top of her head. She travels state to state testifying on behalf of fairness in women's sports bills. The opposition always argues they only have a few trans athletes in their state—it's a lie. There are only recorded trans athletes, but there are many more, like the D3 diver she just heard about and the male on the Syracuse lacrosse team.

A Call to Men and Pastors

Kirk addressed the men in attendance: men must stand up against these psychopaths. Feminism has tried to make women into men and the next extension is women "becoming" men. Feminism wants men to become women, and they've succeeded in making America less masculine. In a properly structured society, it's the man's job to say no, to enforce rules, order, discipline, and boundaries.

Kirk called out pastors: if you don't mention trans zealotry as a pastor, resign from the ministry. This is one of the biggest issues in America.

Riley's Spiritual Awakening

Gaines shared that she's fortunate to have a strong family foundation—two parents who love each other and stayed together, three siblings, all grandparents still living. She grew up in church with a spiritual foundation, but this past year she's been spiritually awakened. She's seen clearly how God works and moves, how he has his hand on her. Just as clearly, she's seen how his opposition works—how he deceives, manipulates, and lies.

This is no longer a battle of right versus wrong or good versus bad. This is moral versus evil. She looked evil in the eyes in San Francisco—it's soulless, vengeful, violent, hateful, and they do it in the name of love, inclusion, tolerance, acceptance, and welcoming.

Gaines constantly refers back to the term "true love." Truth and love are synonymous. It's loving to say the truth. Anything else isn't compassionate. Would we tell an anorexic person who believes they're fat that they're actually fat? Would we tell someone with schizophrenia that the voices they hear are real? Would we affirm a manic episode? No, but that's what's happening now.

She struggled at first, wanting to live a Christ-like life. People told her, "You say you're a Christian but this isn't what God would do. Our God loves all." While she knew this was true, she struggled with whether she was doing the right thing. She talked to people strong in their faith—youth pastors and others—who reassured her: "Of course we have a God who loves, but we have a God who hates sin and holds people accountable."

These people are desperately looking to put their identity into something, but as Christians and humans, the only place we find satisfaction is putting our identity in Christ. From John 10:10: "The enemy comes to lie, steal and destroy, but I Jesus have come to give life and life more abundantly."

Question and Answer Session

Kirk and Gaines took questions from the audience. Topics included fighting against boys competing in girls' sports in Arizona, forgiveness for those who leave the homosexual lifestyle (which Kirk clarified is a behavior, not an identity), creating a third category for trans athletes (which Gaines rejected, saying it would just be another place for men to win), officials being pressured to overlook gender issues at meets, and how men can defend their daughters.

One swimming official shared they've been asked to overlook gender issues with hints they may not be asked to officiate if they comment. Gaines revealed that Georgia Tech's host representative was messaged by the NCAA prior to the meet stating they weren't allowed to speak out in opposition or face consequences. The only rule the NCAA created after her tie with Thomas was a tiebreaker rule giving the trophy to whoever is older—not banning men from women's sports.

Kirk encouraged the official to consider walking away from refereeing such meets, noting that if referees refused to sign on, they could kill this movement. He compared it to recent victories where exposure and pressure caused institutions to back down.

A father asked what men can do besides being involved in school board meetings and befriending elected officials. Gaines emphasized standing firm in truth and being willing to defend daughters. Just as importantly, teach sons masculinity. She quoted: "Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, weak men create hard times." She noted the last time society had strong men was the 1940s during World War II. She shared a tweet: "In the 1940s we had men lying about their age so they could enlist in the draft. Now we have men lying about their sex so they can get into women's sports."

Kirk added that conservatives have underutilized civil disobedience, which is biblical (Daniel 6). There are rules: it must address injustice from a tyrant, you must be willing to accept punishment, and you must win over other people. He suggested creative peaceful ways like basketball teams sitting on the court refusing to play against biological males, filming it, and putting it on Twitter.

Fighting Back

An Arizona Christian University professor asked what to tell upcoming pastors about transforming culture with truth. Kirk referenced Romans 12:2: "Do not conform to the ways of this world but be transformed by the renewing of your mind." He explained that pastors must reject conforming to trans zealotry, hookup culture, and other cultural sins, allowing themselves to be transformed by renewing their minds. Jesus wants us to be salt and light—transforming agents that change what they come in contact with.

A student asked about Fellowship of Christian Athletes being forced off campus while other religious groups remained. Gaines encouraged garnering support and making it public, noting that public opinion matters and institutions want something—finding leverage is important. Kirk noted that schools are weaker than they appear, citing recent victories where exposure led to institutions backing down. He encouraged holding the line, calling out hypocrisy, and not giving in.

A mental health professional asked about mandatory blood tests for hormonal levels. Gaines explained the IOC (International Olympic Committee) has a level of five nanomoles per liter of testosterone to compete in the opposite sex, but this isn't comparable to women's levels. Men have twenty times more testosterone on average. Asking men to reach the average woman's level (0.8 to 2.5 nanomoles per liter) would be dangerous. Moreover, differences outside testosterone contribute to athletic success: lung capacity, height, limb size, foot size, heart size—none of which change with testosterone suppression.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!