The Takeout Panel of Young Republicans and Democrats Reflects on Charlie Kirk's Death and Legacy
Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.
Up Next
Charlie Kirk Revealed on the Iced Coffee Hour How He Wanted to Be Remembered
2:15
Jack Posobiec and David Axelrod Reflect on Asymmetric Warfare Claims After Charlie Kirk Tragedy
8:52
Eyewitness Raydon DeChene Describes Chaotic Shooting Attack on Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University
4:12
The Takeout Panel of Young Republicans and Democrats Reflects on Charlie Kirk's Death and Legacy
On The Takeout, the host revisits Charlie Kirk's mission of drawing young people into political dialogue through Turning Point USA, the organization he founded as a college student in 2012 that has since grown to more than 800 college chapters and 1,000 high school groups. The segment includes a clip from one of Kirk's signature "prove me wrong" debates, recorded before he was fatally shot at Utah Valley University while engaged in exactly that kind of exchange. A panel then brings together Dillon Burns and Stella Ross of Indiana University's Republican Club and Christian Martin, vice president of the University of Alabama's Democratic Club, to discuss what Kirk meant to them personally and politically. The conversation covers Kirk's ability to connect with young voters rather than simply talk at them, his persuasive style even among people who disagreed with him theologically and politically, and a shared, cross-partisan grief over his death, closing with a warning about political violence and historical comparisons to the collapse of past republics.
Charlie Kirk's Turning Point USA and His "Prove Me Wrong" Debates
The host opens by noting that Charlie Kirk's motivation in politics was to bring young people into the dialogue and make them more politically active than they otherwise would be, which he pursued through Turning Point USA, an organization he founded while a college student in 2012. Kirk never finished college, the host notes, but the group he founded now has more than 800 chapters on college campuses and more than 1,000 high school groups. When Kirk was fatally shot at Utah Valley University, he was engaged in one of his "prove me wrong" debates, in which he invited audience members to challenge his point of view face to face. A clip is shown of one such exchange, in which Kirk asks a debate partner whether his brother was a human being while still in their mother's womb, and the other person answers that on his moral compass, he believes he was.
A Bipartisan Panel Remembers Kirk
The host brings together Dillon Burns, president of Indiana University's Republican Club, Stella Ross, a member of that club, and Christian Martin, vice president of the University of Alabama's Democratic Club, joining separately by Zoom. The host jokes that Burns and Ross have promised not to gang up on Martin during the conversation.
Burns says Kirk was more than a leader to him, calling him someone who impacted countless lives and inspired an entire generation of young conservatives working to advance the movement and spread his message, offering condolences to Kirk's family as everyone grieves together. Ross adds that what made Kirk special was his willingness to go onto college campuses and engage directly with their generation, crediting him with moving the vote in the 2024 election and pointing to civil discourse with students as something that inspired a generation to speak out.
What Made Kirk Different, According to Young Republicans
Asked to explain Kirk's particular communication style, Burns argues that while Democrats and liberals were largely talking to voters, telling them what they thought people should hear, Kirk connected with voters instead, which he says is what built Kirk's base and made him effective enough to draw thousands of supporters onto campuses across the country. Ross adds that Kirk stepped onto college campuses when others wouldn't, holding open dialogue with students and sitting with them for hours to hear out opposing views, which she says helped form the connection that built his movement.
A Democrat's Perspective on Kirk's Persuasive Power
Christian Martin describes attending a Kirk event while a senior in high school in Northport, Alabama, near Tuscaloosa, and says he could see Kirk's effectiveness firsthand, particularly in drawing in young men who might otherwise be politically disengaged, and in his skill at short-form digital content. Martin says he has profound disagreements with Kirk on policy and theology, but calls him very skilled and convincing, adding that the event's aftermath, with a widow and two young children who saw their father die in front of them, is heartbreaking. He paraphrases U.S. Senate candidate and Texas legislator James Talarico, saying that regardless of policy disagreements, a child of God has passed away in front of the country's eyes, and says his heart and those of the University of Alabama's College Democrats mourn for Kirk.
Asked what Democrats might take from Kirk's persuasiveness, Martin says Democrats sometimes over-intellectualize and preach at people rather than talk to them, and that Kirk's ability to entertain alongside persuading, and to use emotion to connect with his audience, is something worth learning from.
Carrying the Movement Forward
Asked how they'll carry this forward personally, Burns says the moment is still being processed, calling it unspeakable to see someone so youthful, a father and husband, taken this way, and frames it as a call for conservatives across campuses nationwide to use their own voices to support Kirk's movement now that his has been silenced. Ross adds that having their club on campus gives conservative students a place to connect with others who share their values and a support system during a painful time, extending condolences to Erika Kirk and the Kirk family.
A Closing Call for Unity and Against Political Violence
Given the last word, Martin first clarifies he meant no disrespect in describing Kirk as connecting rather than talking at people. He then offers condolences to everyone affected, Republican, Democrat, bystander, first responders, medical personnel, and Kirk's children and widow, saying he has been praying rosaries and Hail Marys for them. He draws a comparison to the shooting of Democratic state legislators in Minnesota, arguing the country has no room for political violence of any kind, warning that this is how republics historically degenerate, invoking the fall of the Weimar Republic and the fall of the Roman Republic, and asks everyone, whether religious or not, to reflect on the health of the country and engage across the aisle respectfully.
