I Watched Every Minute of Turning Point USA's AmericaFest So You Don't Have To

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Stephen A. Smith Sits Down With Candace Owens On Israel, Iran, Trump's Betrayal Of MAGA Movement

Stephen A. Smith Sits Down With Candace Owens On Israel, Iran, Trump's Betrayal Of MAGA Movement

58:37

Charlie Sykes and Tom Nichols Dissect Charlie Kirk's Astonishing Historical Illiteracy and Modern Conservative Dysfunction

Charlie Sykes and Tom Nichols Dissect Charlie Kirk's Astonishing Historical Illiteracy and Modern Conservative Dysfunction

43:01

The Soy Pill Examines Charlie Kirk's Life, Views, and the Reactions to His Assassination

The Soy Pill Examines Charlie Kirk's Life, Views, and the Reactions to His Assassination

21:42

I Watched Every Minute of Turning Point USA's AmericaFest So You Don't Have To

What happens when you sit through four days of speeches from Charlie Kirk, Tucker Carlson, Matt Gaetz, and other conservative figures at Turning Point USA's AmericaFest conference? A video essayist endures the entire event to uncover what the Republican Party actually stands for in the post-Trump era. What he finds isn't a coherent policy agenda or political vision, but something far more concerning: empty performative rage, fascist propaganda techniques, and billionaire-funded spectacle masquerading as grassroots activism. From bizarre musical numbers about James O'Keefe to panels claiming Critical Race Theory turns white kids trans, this deep dive reveals how modern conservatism has abandoned policy for pure culture war theatrics.

Categories: Liberal Opinions
May 17, 2022

The AmericaFest Experience

In December, thousands of conservative activists descended on Phoenix, Arizona for AmericaFest, a conference organized by the right wing activist group Turning Point USA. The event was billed as a gathering aimed at taking America back and featured some of the biggest names in conservative politics and media. Despite knowing it would be painful to watch, a video essayist decided to sit through every single minute of this four-day conference to answer one question: what does the Republican Party stand for after Trump?

Republican politics have been defined by Donald Trump's presidency for years. Whatever Trump wanted was what the party wanted, and the GOP's central function became protecting their leader. But the problem with cults of personality in politics is that eventually the cult leader loses. Without a clear ideology or policy agenda to unite around, you end up with a bunch of people wondering why they're still wearing red hats.

Day One: Vibes Over Policy

The conference opened with technical difficulties during the national anthem, resulting in an unsettling audio nightmare, before moving straight to pyrotechnics. AmericaFest was not a grassroots organization event. Turning Point receives millions of dollars every year from right wing mega-donors like the Koch brothers, Foster Friess, and Bernard Marcus. The conference itself was sponsored by the Koch Brothers Heritage Foundation and the Murdoch family's Fox Nation. The entire event was essentially billionaires paying millionaires to pretend to hate the ruling class.

Charlie Kirk, Turning Point co-founder, kicked things off by going after the GOP's favorite punching bags: Critical Race Theory, wokeism, diversity equity and inclusion, trans people, and Dr. Fauci. The bulk of Kirk's speech focused on the pandemic, peddling dangerous and ineffective treatments like ivermectin, hydroxychloroquine, and various vitamins. But Kirk made clear that the conference wasn't really about policy. He argued that the deeper game being played was simple: are you thankful that you're an American, or are you angry that you're an American?

Tucker Carlson followed with a speech that started normally enough, making fun of Biden for being old and complaining about mask and vaccine mandates while defending the January 6 rioters. But then Tucker did the same thing Kirk did, arguing that the difference between Left and Right isn't about policy at all. He claimed there's a spiritual dimension, that Democrats are seized by a spirit of destruction. Tucker argued that the left wants to control people because they secretly hate themselves, describing them as having a huge hollow space inside that can't be filled.

Both Kirk and Tucker framed conservatism not as an ideology or set of policy preferences, but as a vibe. Are you a creator or a destroyer? Do you love America or hate it? Are you a tough dog or scared dog? The whole thing sounded less like a political action conference and more like a lifestyle brand or New Age church. Day One ended with Tucker encouraging people to flee liberal cities, move to the countryside, and await the dawning of a new, more righteous era.

Day Two: Darkness and Performance

Donald Trump Jr. opened Day Two describing a country completely taken over by the radical left, claiming they control pop culture, sports, academia, law enforcement, and the military. He hit all the classics: Critical Race Theory, a transgender swimmer at the University of Pennsylvania, and somehow still Jussie Smollett. Then things got darker. Don Jr. brought up Kyle Rittenhouse and celebrated the fact that one of the people Rittenhouse killed had been previously convicted of sexually abusing a child, saying if someone's going to get shot, it might as well be a pedophile. He defended the January 6 riot and specifically condemned Republicans who spoke out against the insurrection.

Sarah Palin's interview with Kirk was light on substance, heavy on conspiracy theories. Kirk stopped talking to Palin entirely at one point to go on an unprompted rant against trans people, claiming teachers are recruiting students into transgender lifestyles. Marjorie Taylor Greene followed, successfully avoiding her QAnon and anti-Semitic talking points while sticking to the script: build the wall, end abortion, and creepy homophobic and transphobic content. Most of her speech defended January 6 rioters, peddling a conspiracy theory that the insurrection was actually a false flag operation designed to start a communist revolution, calling it a fed-surrection.

A panel discussion titled How Cultural Marxists Hijacked America featured three speakers who demonstrated they had never read a book in their lives. Halfway through, James Lindsay, a man frequently cited as an expert on wokeism and cultural Marxism in right wing media, argued that the point of Critical Race Theory is to make straight white guys so ashamed of being white that they choose to become queer to become minorities. He then claimed that sexual grooming is happening and that communists have a handshake agreement with pedophiles.

Congressman Jim Jordan, who has been credibly accused of turning a blind eye to molestation of his own students while working as a wrestling coach at Ohio State, spoke briefly about how the left doesn't like America. Byron Donalds, a Florida congressman who voted against certifying the 2020 election, claimed he wanted to talk about real issues like immigration, spending, debt, inflation, and Afghanistan, but instead focused on the importance of being allowed to share memes. His main economic argument was that Michael Jordan didn't make him buy Air Jordans as a kid, and he advocated for more domestic oil drilling, unsurprising given that he, like AmericaFest itself, is heavily funded by the oil and gas industry.

Large portions of the conference were commercials for companies that advertise on Charlie Kirk's podcast, including Good Ranchers, a raw meat subscription service, and Patriot Mobile, a pro-America cell phone service with terrible reviews calling it a scam. Fox News host Jeanine Pirro delivered one of the most policy-focused speeches of the entire conference, focusing on law and order and blaming the recent rise in homicides on the defund the police movement while fear mongering about fentanyl crossing the border. Day Two closed with Congressman Matt Gaetz, another Republican credibly linked to allegations of sex with minors, delivering a fire and brimstone speech promising that if Republicans retake power in the midterms, every committee gets an investigation, every Biden agency gets a colonoscopy, and Hunter Biden gets a subpoena. He never explained what these investigations would be about or what they would accomplish, but declared that the radical left deserves confrontation, contempt, and condemnation, not civility.

Day Three: Heroes and Villains

Day Three opened with a 20-minute musical about James O'Keefe's life, narrated by him, featuring hired dancers and rented rehearsal space. The musical had no speech attached, just the performance. Benny Johnson, a plagiarist who got fired from BuzzFeed and demoted at IJR before becoming a full-time Tucker Carlson impersonator, delivered a speech arguing that the problem with leftists is they're not cool enough to be movie heroes. He showed clips from Star Wars, Home Alone, and The Lion King, asking the audience to imagine how bad these movies would be if the main characters were libs. He closed by encouraging people to grab their guns and defend their country like Kevin in Home Alone.

An entire panel about how the election was stolen featured two congressmen who helped incite the January 6 riot. Lauren Boebert delivered a speech that was mostly name calling, saying she's tired of having brother marrying, violence inciting, parmesan smoking, terrorist supporting, child sniffing commies wreck the country, before immediately transitioning into prayer. She claimed she was bought and paid for by the blood of Jesus, though she was actually bought and paid for by her husband's oil and natural gas company, a fact she tried to hide despite introducing bills that would personally enrich her family.

Kyle Rittenhouse, just a month after being acquitted for his killings in Kenosha, walked on stage to a standing ovation. Weeks earlier he had been sobbing about how traumatized he was by his decision to gun down civilians. Now he was receiving a hero's welcome and promising to take revenge on media outlets that covered his trial. Jack Posobiec, a neo-Nazi collaborator who tweets Nazi propaganda and hangs out with neo-Nazi organizers, spoke next. Ted Cruz closed out Day Three by starting off sounding like he might discuss real policy issues, mentioning assaults on constitutional liberties, free speech, and the Second Amendment, but never got specific about what assault he was talking about. He fell back on the same schtick as everyone else, complaining that the left is unhappy, shrill, angry, and pissed. Day Three ended with Ted Cruz, one of the most powerful members of the U.S. Senate, begging the audience to subscribe to his podcast.

Day Four: The Final Message

The final day started with another glitching national anthem and a panel on wokeism in the American war machine featuring straight white guys arguing that the war machine is good, they just don't want it to be trans. Charlie Kirk returned to the stage for the final speech, giving a dire warning about America's youth being the most depressed, most suicidal, most drug addicted, most childless generation in American history. Instead of addressing any systemic problems or policy solutions, Kirk's answers were: read the Bible, use your phone less, don't waste money on college, start a business, and listen to his podcast. AmericaFest ended not with a policy vision for improving the country, but with a Jordan Peterson-style demand to focus on yourself and stop complaining.

The Ten Pillars of Fascism

In his book How Fascism Works, philosopher Jason Stanley outlines ten pillars of fascist thinking, the themes that show up over and over in fascist movements. All of them appeared at AmericaFest: obsession with law and order, hatred of academics and intellectuals, victimization by minorities and outsiders, intense paranoia around gender and sexual predators, fear of cities overrun by thugs and criminals, and the distinction between real Americans and anti-Americans.

At the heart of fascist propaganda is the idea of a perfect enemy: a left that is both scared and weak but also in control of every aspect of society. A left that wins elections not through strength of ideas but through lies and cheating. A left motivated not by policy differences or selfishness or stupidity, but by a spirit of destruction, a deep inexplicable desire to hate their country and destroy what doesn't belong to them.

The point of fascist propaganda isn't to win elections but to lay the groundwork for rejecting them. If a deranged mob were trying to wreck your house, you wouldn't put it up for a vote. You would defend your house, grab your gun, mow them down. In fascist propaganda, elections start to feel undemocratic, just another way the lying cheating left takes advantage of the silent majority. This explains why nearly every speaker at AmericaFest voted to overturn the results of the last election, and why at both Q&A sessions, the first question wasn't about winning over moderates or what policies to enact, but when can we start shooting them.

Empty Politics

What was most surprising about AmericaFest wasn't the fascist rhetoric, which has been bubbling up on the right for years. It was how empty it all felt. For a political action conference billed as being about taking America back and returning power to everyday Americans, after four days of speeches, there was still no clear vision of what that should look like. There was almost no talk of political action at all. Barely any mention of economic policy, healthcare policy, student debt crisis, medical debt crisis, housing crisis, infrastructure, or why the rich keep getting richer while bosses steal billions from workers. Even on COVID, there was lots of complaining about masks and vaccine mandates but no explanation of what the government should be doing instead or why America has one of the worst COVID mortality rates for wealthy countries.

Instead of policy ideas, attendees got Fox News content about Jussie Smollett and Hunter Biden's laptop and only women can become pregnant. Instead of coherent ideology, they got middle school fantasy about libs being unfunny and conservatives being sexy heroes. This wasn't identity politics in the traditional sense. Identity politics are usually about getting something done. Queer people band together to secure legal protections. Racial minorities band together to fix racist policing practices. What happened at AmericaFest was identity instead of politics, all resentment and fake patriotism with no real political project attached.

Even politicians seemed to be arguing that politics is nothing more than a big show. Matt Gaetz defended the Freedom Caucus for using performance as a tool, saying Reagan was an actor, and arguing that stagecraft is statecraft. The operative question is not whether representatives are performers, they all are, but for whom.

Fascism and Capitalism

In Right Wing Culture In Contemporary Capitalism, Mathias Nilges argues this type of empty performative virtue signaling is actually one of the central functions of fascist propaganda: taking people's legitimate feelings of frustration and anger and channeling them towards meaningless apolitical content. The extreme right has traditionally relied on a semblance of rebelliousness, billing itself as a political mass movement while ultimately depoliticizing the public sphere. This obfuscates structural problems and puts pseudo political slogans, disinformation campaigns, and conspiracy narratives in place of political analysis, debates, and programs.

Fascist propaganda takes anger that should be directed at the ruling class and launches it in the wrong direction, creating the illusion of rebellion without actually challenging people in power. This hijacking was everywhere at AmericaFest. Speakers railed against the medical industrial complex when talking about vaccines, but Republicans fight against legislation that would regulate pharmaceutical companies. Speakers railed against special interest influence in politics, but Republicans have squashed every effort to pass campaign finance reform, and nearly every speaker was bankrolled by super PACs or the oil lobby.

During the cultural Marxism panel, after the bizarre rant about queer theory, one panelist argued that cultural Marxism is the greatest gift to the super elite left. Corporations can post a black square on Instagram and do horrible things without treating warehouse workers or black people well. They can send a check to Black Lives Matter instead of having equitable distribution of wealth to workers. It's not a bad argument. Corporations do pay lip service to woke causes while exploiting workers. Corporate Democrats make symbolic gestures instead of passing legislation to improve working class lives. But in the context of AmericaFest, it's deranged. The right doesn't care about regulating corporations or redistributing wealth. Republicans have spent 20 years passing corporate tax cuts and rolling back worker and labor union protections.

This paradoxical combination of anti-capitalism with policies benefiting the ultra wealthy is central to right wing strategy. These strategies protect the economic elite whose interests are threatened by anti-capitalist sentiments that current crises generate, but fascism collapses those sentiments into concern with culture and identity, fostering a grotesquely distorted version of a mass movement whose aims are contracted to hatred and violence.

Individual Solutions to Systemic Problems

In fascist thinking, politics isn't about taking care of each other or even ourselves. It's about dunking on the enemy. Arrest Fauci, defeat communism, there are only two genders. These phrases function like build the wall and lock her up, not as statements of political goals but as slogans to signal which side you're on.

But what happens when dunking on the enemy isn't enough? When tormenting trans people and arresting Fauci doesn't make you less sick or broke or miserable? Instead of political solutions, fascism offers purely individual ones. Got COVID because you had to work during a pandemic to pay rent? Take Advil or ivermectin. Feel powerless facing giant corporations that exploit you? Give your money to conservative corporations that will also exploit you. Feel desperate in an economy rigged against the working class? Invest in gold, silver, crypto, or any scam promising to protect you from free market horrors. And when that doesn't work, when you're still hopeless and anxious, living paycheck to paycheck while billionaires get more tax cuts, pray to God, love your country, clean your room. Do anything other than question whether the radical leftists they warn about are actually the ones screwing you over.

This is why fascists and capitalists always end up on the same side. The Nazis were supported by big businesses and corporations that bankrolled the party. Right wing billionaires give people like Charlie Kirk millions of dollars for events like AmericaFest. Not because the ultra rich care about the Jewish question or gender question, but because fascists and capitalists want the same thing: a public that thinks of politics as nothing more than the Hunger Games. A spectacle of cruelty and revenge where you cheer for your team and take joy in enemy suffering, but never truly threaten people in power.

Operating under the false assumption that there are only individual solutions to socially produced problems, neoliberal fascism renders human beings numb and fearful, immune to demands of economic and social justice, increasingly divorced from politics, ethics, and social responsibility, all while becoming increasingly susceptible to political shocks and seductive pleasures of manufactured spectacle.

What Can Be Done

Fascism is a virus that destroyed entire countries of fully educated adults. Head empty fascism can't be beaten with facts and logic. You can't beat it by appealing to compromise or civility. You can't even beat it by just passing popular policies. The content at AmericaFest is basically indistinguishable from what happens on Fox News every night, and Fox has been the number one cable news network in America every year for the past 20 years.

For all that fascists get wrong, and they get nearly everything wrong, what they get right is understanding that when people are angry, vibes matter more than good governance. The reason young people turn to fascism instead of Marxism is that while Marxism presents them, fascism represents them. The appeal of focus on identity lies in the sense of personal validation and recognition it offers. Fascism understands that the desire for representation is a powerful tool for depoliticization of the working class, positing folk and fatherland as substitute for their own thinking.

Fascism may not offer solutions to people's problems, but it offers a simple us versus them story, easy targets for people to direct anger at. Humans are deeply emotional, ego-driven creatures. If you don't give them somewhere to put their anger, they'll aim it at whatever marginalized group fascists tell them to blame first.

What's needed is a better story, a better them for us to rage against. A political project that takes people's legitimate feelings of resentment and frustration and channels them not towards empty nonsense but towards real revolution. Reforms that will actually challenge the ruling class and improve material conditions of people's lives. Economic antagonism. Good old fashioned class war. We are a country on the verge of real democratic collapse with a government incapable of doing the bare minimum to take care of its people. Rage is the correct response to how things have been going. The only question is which side gets to claim and wield it. And it should not be the side of mega-corporations and oil barons cosplaying as revolutionaries.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!