Up Next

Charlie Kirk and Josh Hammer Reflect on High-Profile Israel Debate at Turning Point USA Summit

Charlie Kirk and Josh Hammer Reflect on High-Profile Israel Debate at Turning Point USA Summit

17:08

Candace Owens Debates Rabbi Shmuley Boteach on Piers Morgan About Zionism and Israel Gaza Conflict

Candace Owens Debates Rabbi Shmuley Boteach on Piers Morgan About Zionism and Israel Gaza Conflict

40:35

Eric Metaxas on Faith, Joy, and the Murder of Charlie Kirk: Finding Hope in Tragedy

Eric Metaxas on Faith, Joy, and the Murder of Charlie Kirk: Finding Hope in Tragedy

1:05:43

Norman Finkelstein Reveals the Truth About Gaza That Almost Destroyed His Academic Career

October 31, 2025

Norman Finkelstein, son of Holocaust survivors and renowned scholar, shares the history of Gaza that cost him his academic career. After October 7th, Candace Owens began an honest inquiry into the modern state of Israel and discovered shocking truths about Gaza's 75-year reality as what UN officials, economists, and even Israeli security chiefs have called a concentration camp. Finkelstein explains how Gaza became home to 80% refugees from the 1948 expulsion, why he was blacklisted from academia despite his credentials from Princeton, and how a billionaire class uses financial blackmail to silence criticism. This conversation exposes the pressure campaign that followed October 7th, the money behind pro-Israel influencers, and why prominent voices refuse to debate Finkelstein if he's actually wrong.

The Scholar They Tried to Silence

Norman Finkelstein sits across from Candace Owens with a story that should trouble every American who values truth and academic freedom. The son of Holocaust survivors—both his parents survived the Warsaw Ghetto, Majdanek concentration camp, and Auschwitz—Finkelstein earned his PhD from Princeton University and became widely credited with exposing a major bestselling book on Israel-Palestine as a fraudulent hoax. Despite his credentials and groundbreaking scholarship, he never had a real academic career.

"I never had an academic career," Finkelstein explains plainly. "I was in academia. It's called being an adjunct. An adjunct basically means you're hired from semester to semester. It's the equivalent of literally the equivalent of a substitute teacher in a public school system except a substitute teacher is paid significantly more than an adjunct."

When he briefly secured a tenure-track position at DePaul University in Chicago, Professor Alan Dershowitz of Harvard Law School made a determined public attempt to stop him, including a Wall Street Journal editorial. After being denied tenure in 2007, Finkelstein was completely unemployable. "I literally couldn't volunteer to teach," he reveals. "There were places where in high schools, a charter school for example in East Harlem where the father the principal was a friend of mine and his daughter, the principal, who was really wonderful and she ran a tight ship that was a darn good school. I said, 'I'll volunteer.' No."

October 7th and the Pressure Campaign

Candace Owens describes her own awakening: "October 7th took place and I remember immediately after there was sort of this peer pressure campaign to get everybody to make a statement about what had happened in Israel. And frankly, I was happy to make a statement about how tragic those events were, but I didn't I couldn't actually make a statement regarding why these events took place. I didn't know what had happened prior to that day. I didn't know the history of the modern state of Israel."

When Owens began what she calls "an honest inquiry" into the history of the modern state of Israel, she faced immediate backlash. "People that I thought were my friends were telling me not to pursue this route. I didn't comprehend what they meant when they said not to pursue this route. They were calling me names, saying that I was flirting with anti-semitism by wanting to read books and speak to people that were on the opposite side of that issue."

She got into serious trouble when she hosted Finkelstein on her previous show. "And I got into a lot of trouble, and I mean a lot of trouble from people that I thought were my friends," she says. "And the things that he told me about Gaza were shocking. It was especially shocking because this wasn't from someone that they could easily describe as anti-semitic."

The History of Gaza They Don't Want You to Know

Finkelstein provides the historical context that changed Owens' perspective entirely. "The place to begin is 1948. The state of Israel is created. In the course of its creation, about 90% of the indigenous Palestinian population of Israel was expelled. About 750,000 people. Of those 750,000, about 300,000 were expelled to Gaza. And that's when Gaza kind of became Gaza."

Right now, about 80% of Gaza's population are refugees from the 1948 war or descendants of those refugees. Under international law, descendants of refugees are still counted as refugees. Gaza is also about 50% children.

What struck Finkelstein most in his research was a consistent pattern: "From the moment Gaza came under Egyptian administration after the 1948 war, one of the things that struck me was each time somebody goes to Gaza, they describe Gaza as a huge concentration camp."

He provides a devastating chronology:

  • Elmo Burns, the main UN official in Gaza, wrote a book called "Between Arab and Jew" describing Gaza as "a huge concentration camp"
  • In July 1967, Senator Al Gore Sr. testified before the US Congress, describing Gaza as "a huge concentration camp on the sand"
  • In 2002, Baruch Kimmerling, one of Israel's leading sociologists, wrote a book called "Politicide" describing Gaza as "the biggest concentration camp ever"
  • In 2004, Giora Eiland, head of Israel's National Security Council, described Gaza as "a huge concentration camp"—and this was before Israel imposed the blockade

The Blockade and Calculated Starvation

"In 2006, Israel imposes a blockade on Gaza," Finkelstein explains. "It decides what goes in. It decides what goes out. It decides who goes in. It decides who goes out. They put Gaza on what they call a humanitarian minimum diet. You know what that meant? It meant they calculated, literally, we're not talking about hyperbole now, poetry. They calculated the caloric diet of everyone living in Gaza and they admitted just enough food to avoid scenes of starvation."

The restrictions were absurd and cruel: "They prohibited baby chicks from going into Gaza. They prohibited chocolate from going into Gaza. They prohibited potato chips from going into Gaza. They prohibited condiments from going into Gaza. No cinnamon allowed in Gaza. Why? They wanted to create such intolerable conditions that the population of Gaza would overthrow the government that they elected."

By October 6, 2023, The Economist magazine described Gaza as "a human rubbish heap." The leading UN official on Gaza described it as "a toxic dump." Sixty percent of young people in Gaza were unemployed. "All they have to look forward to when they get up each morning is to pace the perimeter of this tiny parcel of land. 26 miles long, the length of a marathon, 5 miles wide," Finkelstein says. "They were born into, they languished in, and they were destined to die in a concentration camp."

Understanding October 7th Through History

Finkelstein doesn't minimize what happened on October 7th. "What happened October 7th was awful. There's no doubt in my mind about that. The magnitude was significant. 1,200 people killed, about estimates, it's not an estimates, close to 800 of them civilians, 400 combatants, Israeli IDF members of the Israeli Defense Forces."

But he asks Americans to understand it through their own history, specifically the Nat Turner rebellion—the largest slave revolt in American history. "Nat Turner gave the order which he never denied: kill all white people. And that's what they proceeded to do. They went on what you might call a 48 hour rampage, and hacked men, women, babies. It was brutal."

One historian, Steven Oates, tried to understand Nat Turner's motivation. "He said there was this huge gulf for Nat Turner, very smart guy, between what he aspired to be in life and what he was destined to be because he was a slave. That huge gulf. He knew he was smart and yet he also knew that this was his only earthly existence. He was born into, languished in, and would die a slave. And that was the people, the young people in Gaza."

Finkelstein makes a powerful point: "Imagine an account of Nat Turner that doesn't mention he was a slave. Just this crazy religious fanatic. That's how they talk about Hamas—only focus on religious fanaticism and not mention the guy is a slave."

The Billionaire Blackmail Machine

The conversation turns to how criticism of Israel is systematically suppressed through financial blackmail. Owens reveals: "The first thing that happens is financial blackmail. And a lot of people want to know, well, why is this person doing this or why are they not saying it? I'm like, at the end of the day, they let you know, you'll lose everything."

Finkelstein describes the assault on academic freedom: "Not one, not two, three Ivy League presidents were toppled. There's never been anything like it. This massive assault, how was it conducted? It started with people like Bill Ackman, the billionaire. He threatens Harvard. 'You don't crush the encampments. You don't get alumni money.' That was very straightforward. It was pure blackmail."

He details the money involved: "If you look at the Harvard report on anti-semitism, one alumni, one Jewish alumni gave Harvard $200 million. One alumni gave Harvard $300 million. Ackman $50 million. And then there was a petition organized—the original version of the petition, 1,200 Jewish alumni from Harvard threatened to withhold their alumni contributions."

When President Magill was deposed from the University of Pennsylvania, someone approached her to express sympathy. "She replied with two words," Finkelstein reveals. "'Money talks.'"

Paying Influencers to Control the Narrative

The financial manipulation extends beyond academia. Finkelstein shares a shocking personal experience: He was asked to debate on Lex Fridman's show and agreed to debate Benny Morris, Israel's senior historian. But Fridman insisted on also including a streamer called Destiny. Finkelstein reluctantly agreed.

"A few months later, I'm having a conversation with a friend of mine and he says to me, you know, Destiny was paid to be on with you," Finkelstein recalls. "He described it as an Israel advocacy group had groomed him to debate me and paid him handsomely to debate me. And it's an unimpeachable source."

Owens confirms this pattern: "I know for a fact because I know someone who took the money. They're paying people $7,000 for each post in support of Israel. Life-changing money for most influencers. You can tweet 10 times a day and have $70,000."

She reveals that around May, after the Ted Cruz-Tucker Carlson debate, "there was a billionaire that went out and offered what they said to me was an obscene amount of money for people to begin influencing by creating anti-Candace and Tucker videos."

The operation works through layers of charity to hide the source: "What they do is they'll flood the zone and they'll give money to like the International Fellowship of Christians and Jews or put money into a church and then those individuals will then give money to influencers."

Benjamin Netanyahu's Brazen Admission

Owens points to Netanyahu's recent on-camera statements with American influencers as proof of the operation. "A couple of years ago, if you said that Jewish people held power in media, you'd be referred to as an anti-semite. Fast forward to today and you have BB Netanyahu sitting down saying that 'we need this deal to go through on TikTok because that is a weapon that we need to be able to use' in a room on camera with American influencers."

Netanyahu openly discussed how to combat Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson, revealing the game completely. "What does that say when you have a foreign country leader BB Netanyahu saying that on camera?" Owens asks.

The Slaves Who Wear Yellow Ribbons

The discussion turns to high-profile figures who promote Israel despite having no apparent personal stake. Finkelstein focuses on Van Jones, who received $100 million from Jeff Bezos.

"Why does he come on TV with his yellow ribbon?" Finkelstein asks. "I live in an old Jewish neighborhood in Ocean Parkway, Brooklyn. There's literally a synagogue in every block. In some blocks, there are two synagogues. You walk up and down Ocean Parkway, it's all Jewish. I don't see anyone wearing a yellow ribbon."

The symbolism is stark: "Why is Van Jones advertising the flag? He's just advertising 'I'm a slave.' If there were any truth in advertising, he would wear a dollar sign here, a dollar gold pin because it's just money."

Finkelstein describes Jones appearing on Bill Maher's show with Tom Friedman: "Two Jewish supremacists, and they're laughing about dead Gaza babies. And the thing is, Van Jones knows they're not just laughing with him, they're laughing at him. He's our slave. He doesn't have even that minimum selfrespect and dignity. He makes jokes about dead Palestinian babies."

Jones claimed on the show that if you open TikTok, all you see is "dead Palestinian babies, dead Palestinian babies, dead Palestinian babies" because "the Iranians and Qatar are behind it, manipulating the media."

Finkelstein offers another explanation: "Maybe there are a lot of dead Palestinian babies. In fact, just the very first month, just October 2023, more Palestinian children were killed just that first month than all the other war zones in the world combined in 2019, 2020, or 2021. Now it's about the minimum estimate, 20,000 children killed."

Targeting Children

The United Nations Navi Pillay Commission report documents something even more disturbing. "They report Israel targets children. Targets them in the head and in the chest. Israel targets toddlers, that's the word they use, targets toddlers in Gaza," Finkelstein explains.

"They said in the report that children who are suffering from malnutrition need a special infant baby formula, a high protein infant baby formula. Israel bans it."

Jewish Supremacy as State Policy

Finkelstein defines Israel not through his own opinion, but through the words of Israeli human rights leaders. "The head of Israel's main human rights organization, B'Tselem, Hagai El-Ad, was a Harvard trained PhD in physics. Serious fellow. He put out a report probably 10-15 years ago now. And he said here are the basic facts. There's one state from the Mediterranean to the Jordan. There's no Israel and occupied territories. There's just one state. And he said that state, its foundation is Jewish supremacy."

This Jewish supremacy, Finkelstein argues, explains why Israeli intelligence dismissed warnings about October 7th. "For the people of Israel, Gazans are vermin. They're garbage. They're human refuse. And so when you're getting intelligence reports from Gaza that they're going to launch an operation, Israeli intelligence establishment is thinking, what are you talking about? They're going to outsmart us? This vermin is going to be able to pull this off?"

The supremacist mindset pervades Israeli society. "If you look at the polls, half of Israeli Jews believe Israel should commit a genocide in Gaza. About 70 to 75% say there are no innocents in Gaza. No innocents. Half of the population being children."

The Problem Isn't Just Netanyahu

While many critics focus on Benjamin Netanyahu, Finkelstein insists the problem runs deeper. "Netanyahu is the longest sitting prime minister in Israeli history. Every few years they report Netanyahu is going. Netanyahu is out. Netanyahu is finished. No, he's not. And do you know why? Because he's an obnoxious, narcissistic Jewish supremacist. And that's Israeli society. Obnoxious, narcissistic Jewish supremacist. When they see him, they see themselves."

Owens met an Israeli who moved to Tennessee who confirmed this. "He said, 'I absolutely love you and I want you to know that we learn this stuff from the time we are children. From the time we are children, we learn to hate.'"

American Jews Are Waking Up

Despite the billionaire class and the state of Israel, Finkelstein notes positive developments among American Jews. "The Jewish showing since October 7th, broadly American Jewish showing, has actually not been bad. I'm actually very surprised. The most recent poll from the Washington Post found that 61% of American Jews say Israel has committed war crimes in Gaza. 40% say Israel has committed genocide there. About half are opposing what Israel is doing in Gaza."

He credits Jewish activists: "If you remember the first demonstrations against the genocide in Gaza, the biggest ones were led by Jews at Grand Central Station, at the Statue of Liberty. It was deeply moving and they were very active. Jewish students were very active in the encampments around the country."

The Assault on Free Speech

The conversation turns to the systematic assault on freedom of speech, particularly on college campuses. Finkelstein describes a recent court decision involving students arrested by ICE for criticizing Israel.

"There were several young people. They were noncitizen immigrants here. People like Mahmoud Khalil at Columbia University and they were rounded up, sent off to strange places in some cases for things like literally writing an op-ed in the school newspaper critical of the administration because of its support of Israel."

A Reagan-appointed judge, Judge Young, wrote a 161-page decision defending the students. "He said noncitizen immigrants, they have the right to free speech. That's in our jurisprudence. Number two, he said they didn't say anything that crossed any line. They supported the Palestinians. They didn't support Israel. This is America. You have the right to free speech."

The judge noted that the Supreme Court has ruled Americans have the right to advocate for the violent overthrow of the government, the right to burn the American flag. "During the war in Vietnam, there were large numbers of demonstrators, myself included. We chanted 'Ho Ho Ho Chi Minh, the NLF is going to win.' Nobody got arrested for that. Nobody got pulled off the street for that. There were literally millions of people chanting things like that."

Yet students chanting "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free"—a slogan Finkelstein personally dislikes but defends as protected speech—face deportation. Judge Young said ICE was "terrorizing people's right to free speech" and when they put on masks, he compared them to "cowardly desperados acting like the Ku Klux Klan."

Charlie Kirk's Final Days

Owens reveals explosive information about Charlie Kirk's transformation before his death. "I released this week the text message chain 48 hours before he died where he said, 'They've left me no choice but to abandon the pro-Israel cause.' And I really think that the best person that put it very plainly: if you lost Charlie Kirk who was actually so committed to Israel for him as he started as an evangelical Christian, and then he couldn't unsee."

Kirk stated explicitly in his message that it was "because of Jewish behavior." Owens clarifies: "He didn't mean all Jews in America. It's like that power that we are talking about that happens and the way they were treating him. He woke up and realized like I did. Oh, I thought that you guys were supporting me because you were my friends. I thought you supported me because I will pursue the facts. And then when you turned around and realized, well, wow, I was just a slave to you."

Bob Shillman took $2 million away from Kirk when he wouldn't peddle the correct talking points about Israel. When Netanyahu called and invited Kirk to Israel, "Charlie said no. And yet BB then rushed to lie or to not tell the whole truth when he says 'I called him two weeks ago and invited him to Israel.' It's like, and what did he say BB? What did Charlie say back to you?"

The Experience of Being Used

Owens describes her own realization about being platformed by Jewish supremacists. "Going back to your slave analogy, which is actually not an analogy, what it feels like to me: when these Jewish supremacists supported me and platformed me when I was attacking BLM, I recognized this Marxist strand and I stood up to my own people. I wrote an entire book. 'You're amazing, Candace. Let me get you this platform, that platform, fly you here.' And then when I was like, 'Oh yeah, and I know this is going to be hard for you, but you guys are now going to have to stand up to the Jew.' Get out of here. You are gone. You were banned from Australia for speech."

The betrayal cuts deep: "So what was I to you actually? There was a difference here. You didn't agree with me principally on BLM stuff. If the principles held, if you said 'I believe in free speech and you have to sometimes stand up in your own identity box and say something is wrong,' they didn't agree with me principally. That troubles me."

Glenn Loury's Betrayal

Finkelstein shares his own experience of betrayal. After writing a book on cancel culture, Glenn Loury invited him on his show. "I didn't want to talk about Gaza. I didn't want to talk about Israel-Palestine. I had left it behind. Glenn Loury says, he begins the show, 'I would be remiss in my responsibility if I didn't ask you about your views on Israel-Palestine.' I didn't bring up the subject. He brought up the subject."

Finkelstein answered Loury's questions, then they discussed the book. "Next week he does a program, doesn't tell me anything. He and John McWhorter devote about 20 or 30 minutes" to attacking Finkelstein. "The smarminess, the fact that they didn't alert me to what they were going to do. The African-American spiritual: 'Scandalize my name. I gave my brother my right hand and as soon as ever my back was turned, he scandalized my name.'"

They psychoanalyzed Finkelstein behind his back, despite barely knowing him. The betrayal was complete.

A Jewish Supremacist Billionaire Class

Finkelstein summarizes the situation: "There's a problem here. A billionaire class of Jewish supremacists are now flagrantly using money as a blackmail weapon to silence not just criticism of Jews, but silence criticism of an ongoing genocide."

The operation is now blatant. "Bill Ackman, a hedge fund manager, decides on his own who is going to be president of Harvard University. There's nothing like that in our history. Just the brazenness of it."

Owens notes the shift in public awareness: "Before they were a little less arrogant and they wanted to be less obvious that that's how it worked. And now there's a panic happening. And so in their desperation, and this is what's happened over the last 2 years, they've just been sort of in your face. We're throwing money at the cause. We control everything and we don't care if you know about it."

Public Opinion Is Shifting

Despite the money and the pressure, both Finkelstein and Owens see hope. "It does seem as though we are reaching this inflection point where the correct people who and the honest people rather have been telling the truth for a very long time are finally getting their day," Owens observes.

Finkelstein agrees: "Public opinion is shifting for sure."

The conversation ends with a call for honesty and courage. As Owens puts it: "I would rather lose everything as I've proven, take it all, than to speak something that is untrue because I know that my soul will pay a consequence for that."

Comments

Be the first to comment on this video.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!