Charlie Kirk Debates Students on Trump, COVID Response, Immigration and the Economy at Campus Event

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Tucker Carlson and Charlie Kirk Expose the Real Battle for America's Soul and Future

Tucker Carlson and Charlie Kirk Expose the Real Battle for America's Soul and Future

1:41:42

Charlie Kirk Debates Angry College Student on Deportations, Due Process, and Abortion Rights at Campus Event

Charlie Kirk Debates Angry College Student on Deportations, Due Process, and Abortion Rights at Campus Event

22:19

Charlie Kirk Defends Donald Trump Against Claims of Divisiveness at College Campus Event

Charlie Kirk Defends Donald Trump Against Claims of Divisiveness at College Campus Event

8:01

Charlie Kirk banner
2,279 videos 1,365,173,983 views US Joined Aug 30, 2018

Charlie Kirk is the Founder and President of Turning Point USA, the largest and fastest growing conservative youth activist organization in the country with over 250,000 student members, over 150 full-time staff, and a presence on over 2,000 high school and college campuses nationwide. Charlie is also the Chairman of Students for Trump, which aims to activate one million new college voters on campuses in battleground states in the lead up to the 2020 presidential election. His social media reaches over 100 million people per month and according to Axios, he is one of the "top 10 most engaged" Twitter handles in the world. He is also the host of “The Charlie Kirk Show,” which regularly ranks among the top news shows on Apple podcast charts.

Charlie Kirk Debates Students on Trump, COVID Response, Immigration and the Economy at Campus Event

Charlie Kirk fields challenging questions from college students at a campus event, defending Trump's record on COVID-19, economic policy, and immigration. Students press Kirk on fact-checking, Project 2025, housing costs, and the situation in Springfield, Ohio. Kirk argues that this generation faces worse prospects than their parents across every metric, from home ownership to mental health, and explains why he believes Trump's policies offer better solutions than the current administration on wars, borders, and economic opportunity.

October 3, 2024

Addressing Concerns About Trump's Rhetoric and Fact-Checking

Charlie Kirk engaged with students who challenged him on various aspects of Donald Trump's presidency and campaign. When confronted about whether Trump's statements contain lies, Kirk pointed to issues with fact-checking itself, citing an example from a recent debate where fact-checkers claimed late-term abortion was illegal everywhere in the country. Kirk countered that nine states actually allow late-term abortion, demonstrating what he sees as flawed fact-checking.

Kirk distinguished between intentional falsehoods and memory recall errors, citing Trump's reference to the governor of West Virginia when he meant Virginia regarding comments about making babies comfortable after delivery. Kirk argued this represented a minor mistake rather than deliberate deception.

Rejecting Hitler Comparisons and Defending MAGA

When a student suggested Trump's "Make America Great Again" slogan was borrowed from Adolf Hitler, Kirk dismantled the comparison using logical reasoning. He pointed out that Hitler saying "Make Germany Great Again" doesn't make the concept inherently evil, just as Hitler being a vegetarian or owning a dog doesn't make all vegetarians or dog owners Nazis. Kirk called this a logical fallacy.

Kirk explained why so many students wear MAGA hats: they recognize they're entering a country far worse off than what their parents experienced. He supported this claim with extensive data points, noting that this generation faces higher rates of suicide, drug addiction, alcohol addiction, depression, and anxiety than previous generations, while also having lower home ownership rates, income levels, and overall quality of life metrics.

COVID-19 Response: Kirk's Critique From the Right

In a surprising turn, when asked if Trump handled COVID well, Kirk criticized Trump from the opposite direction the student expected. Kirk argued there were too many restrictions under Trump, stating the country never should have locked down, never should have rushed vaccine development, and instead should have trusted people with agency for early interventions. He emphasized that schools never should have closed.

Kirk pointed out that more people died of COVID under Biden than under Trump, despite Biden having access to vaccines. He criticized the CDC extensively, noting they called ivermectin "horse dewormer," claimed masks had utility then later admitted they didn't, and told everyone to stay six feet apart before admitting three years later they "just made that up."

When the student suggested trial and error was acceptable for figuring out pandemic response, Kirk asked a fundamental question: Is the government's role to keep citizens safe from an invisible virus or to protect freedom? The student answered "both," which Kirk challenged by asking what liberty would then be acceptable.

Government Role and Individual Freedom

Kirk used driving deaths as an example—55,000 people die on roads annually despite regulations. He asked if the government should ban cars to keep people safe. When the student talked about containing COVID, Kirk labeled this a "dangerous central planning desire," arguing that countries like Sweden that had no lockdowns, used early interventions, and allowed herd immunity fared better.

Kirk called the school closures and CDC guidance one of the greatest mistakes in American history, noting that students missed proms and homecomings and saw friends take their own lives because of lockdowns. He expressed hope that students never took the vaccine, stating the government lied and committed human rights violations.

When the student suggested they would have supported even stronger COVID restrictions if it meant protecting people, Kirk firmly stated the government has no right to tell citizens they can't leave their homes. This revealed a fundamental worldview difference between government-mandated safety and individual liberty.

Wisdom Versus Knowledge

Kirk made an important distinction between wisdom and knowledge when discussing how to evaluate government claims. While knowledge is about facts, wisdom involves experience and understanding things that never change. Kirk explained that wisdom comes from great books, experience, or being around wise people—not just accumulating facts.

He argued that during COVID, leaders should have used wisdom to ask deeper questions: Who should be protected first? Kirk contended that society failed by trying to sacrifice children for adults, reversing the natural order. He criticized Anthony Fauci's statement that "if just one life is spared then it is all worth it," calling it rubbish and insane.

Kirk stated that a free society cannot exist without negative, unfortunate, and tragic events occurring. Leaders must use wisdom to navigate these challenges, but America's leaders lack wisdom because "wisdom begins with the fear of the Lord." As America becomes less religious, Kirk argued, it becomes less wise.

Project 2025: Separating Fact From Fiction

A student named Patricia asked Kirk to clarify Project 2025, which has been attributed to Trump despite his denials. Kirk explained that Project 2025 was authored by an outside group called The Heritage Foundation, not the Trump campaign. While it contains some good ideas and some "wacky" ones, Trump is now being blamed for every part of it.

Kirk compared this to a hypothetical scenario where a Democratic think tank created suggestions for what they think Kamala Harris should do in a second term, called it "Project 2025," and then Harris had to defend it despite not knowing about it. He emphasized that Trump should only be held accountable for what's on his website and in the Republican platform: drilling on day one, securing the border, and ending the Russian-Ukrainian war.

Kirk argued people don't need to wonder what Trump would do because they can look at his four-year record: no new wars, people getting richer, and a secure border. He dismissed Project 2025 as a distraction, stating Trump's real agenda involves lower energy costs, lower home prices, and a stable country.

Housing Costs and Economic Reality

When Patricia shared that her parents easily bought a house during Biden's administration after saving for just two months with a good loan, Kirk questioned the interest rate. Though she didn't know the exact number, she insisted it was "really low." Kirk countered that interest rates were 2% under Trump and are now 10%, suggesting perhaps her father was part of a special program.

Kirk presented data showing home ownership is declining dramatically while renting increases. He explained that when many people try to buy restricted goods, simple supply and demand dictates prices go up. Under Trump, the country averaged a couple million new homes being built annually, which is not the case currently.

The stark reality Kirk presented: under Trump, the average interest rate for a 30-year mortgage was 2%, now it's 10%. Someone earning $90,000, $110,000, or even $115,000 annually in Denton cannot afford to own a home. Kirk expressed how insane this is, noting many students probably thought earning six figures would guarantee their piece of the American dream, but the numbers show otherwise according to Zillow data.

Employment and Economic Collapse

Patricia asked about employment challenges people face finding jobs. Kirk agreed that people are finding it hard to get jobs and warned the country is on the precipice of economic collapse after years of cheap money monetary policy. His solutions included lowering energy costs through drilling, which makes it easier for employers to hire and would create many jobs in Texas where drilling is easy.

Kirk noted that employment numbers keep getting revised downward—announcements of great employment are later corrected to show 100,000 jobs actually lost. He stated the country has lost 1.3 million jobs so far this year and it will get worse. However, he pointed to Trump's record: lowest ever Black unemployment, lowest ever Hispanic unemployment, and lowest ever Asian-American unemployment.

Kirk asked students to remember the Trump years when life was not as financially hard, things were less expensive, and it was easier to take vacations and own homes. He attributed this to building the economy from the middle class, which makes things work better, contrasting it with the current economy built on a house of cards.

Immigration and Springfield, Ohio

A student who leans liberal on most issues, particularly immigration, asked Kirk about Haitians in Ohio and the reports about pets. Kirk confirmed the pet reports are true and provided context: the country has accepted 5% of Haiti's entire population in the last couple years. While having nothing against Haitians personally, Kirk argued that accepting 5% of any country's population, in addition to all other mass migration, is unsustainable.

Kirk emphasized a fundamental principle: government must fulfill its obligation to provide a better life for its own citizens before opening borders to non-citizens. He reiterated that everyone in the audience is seeing their future worse off than their parents for the first time since George Washington—a historic breakdown of the American promise that usually each generation does as well or better than the previous one.

Three Reasons for Liberals to Vote Trump

Kirk presented three core arguments for why even liberals should vote for Trump. First, home ownership: to own a home currently requires making $125,000 per year just to get the mortgage, not counting medical expenses, student debt, or credit card expenses. Under Trump it was $75,000 per year because millions of new homes were being built and incomes were rising. Kirk blamed Kamala Harris and Joe Biden for spending six to seven trillion dollars in unnecessary federal spending, flooding the economy and inflating asset prices.

Second, war: Kirk noted that as a liberal, the student likely opposes endless wars. Trump was the first president in 40 years with no new wars—no Iraq war, no Syrian war, no Russian-Ukraine war. Under Biden and Harris, there's the Russian-Ukrainian war with $250 billion spent, plus the situation in Israel and Gaza. While Kirk stated he's pro-Israel, he acknowledged it's not a favorable situation with significant human suffering. Under Trump, none of that happened; instead, he brought peace to the Middle East through the Abraham Accords and maintained international stability.

Third, the border: Under Trump, the southern border was the most secure in American history with border crossings at an all-time low. Under Harris, 10 million people have crossed into the country with no one knowing who they are, bringing increased crime into communities and, yes, eating ducks, geese, and cats in Springfield, Ohio.

Addressing Misinformation Claims

When the student said he'd looked up the Springfield pet situation and found "no proof," Kirk insisted there is extensive proof including videos of residents saying their cats were taken by Haitians and grilled on open fires. He explained these aren't accepted as police reports because they're classified as animal control problems rather than criminal matters.

Kirk posed a simple question: either all the residents are lying and coordinating a massive conspiracy, or there's truth to their claims. He emphasized he's not asking people to vote for Trump based on pets being barbecued, but it raises the question of whether the country can sustain 10 million people entering. To illustrate the scale, Kirk noted 10 million people equals the entire population of New Jersey—an unsustainable amount.

World War III Warnings and the War Party

Kirk warned students they are closer to World War III than ever before and might be drafted under current circumstances. He noted the audience consists of military-age individuals and insisted he wasn't fearmongering. His evidence: the people endorsing Kamala Harris include Dick Cheney, Leon Panetta, and Liz Cheney—the war mongers from 20 years ago who got the country into failed wars.

Speaking on September 11th, Kirk reminded the audience to remember what happened on that day and then remember the terrible reaction—the decision to invade Iraq and Afghanistan. He called for never doing that again, never invading sovereign countries, expressing confidence the liberal student would sympathize with that position. The student agreed.

The New Political Realignment

Kirk explained why Bobby Kennedy, Elon Musk, and Tulsi Gabbard—card-carrying Democrats—are now voicing support for Trump. He described what's happening in the Democratic Party as a sinister combination: a party of censorship, war, and open borders that stands against actual traditional liberal values. This represents a significant political realignment where traditional liberals find more alignment with Trump's policies than with the current Democratic establishment.

By the end of the exchange, when Kirk asked which way the student was leaning, the student responded by asking for a MAGA hat—a conversion Kirk celebrated as representing the open-minded inquiry he encourages on college campuses nationwide.

Comments

Be the first to comment on this video.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!