Charlie Kirk Explains Why White Privilege Is Racist, A Lie, and Divides America Based on Skin Color
Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.
Up Next
Charlie Kirk Rejects White Privilege as Racist, Points to Asian American Success Since Internment Camps
0:46
Charlie Kirk Challenges Student on White Privilege, Police Brutality, and Economic Disparities in America
2:08
Charlie Kirk Debates White Privilege and Immigration Enforcement With Student Over SB 1070
1:00
Charlie Kirk Explains Why White Privilege Is Racist, A Lie, and Divides America Based on Skin Color
Charlie Kirk responds to a Latino audience member's question about white privilege, arguing that the concept itself is racist because it categorizes people by skin color. Kirk points to Asian Americans as the wealthiest demographic in America despite facing historical discrimination, proving that outcomes are based on choices, not race. He contends that African Americans are worse off today than in the 1960s not because of increased racism, but because government welfare policies incentivized destructive behavior and created dependency. Kirk dismantles the white privilege narrative by examining statistical realities and the role of individual choices in determining success.
When a Latino audience member asked Charlie Kirk about white privilege, Kirk's response was unequivocal: white privilege is racist, a lie, and a myth. Kirk explained that as soon as you begin to categorize certain individuals based on skin color, that in essence is racism. The act of saying someone is privileged because of their skin color generalizes an entire group of people without knowing their background or upbringing.
Kirk defined racism as putting a specific definition onto a group of people based on their skin color—a prejudice based solely on their skin color. Whether it's a good prejudice or a bad prejudice, that is racism. The white privilege narrative does exactly this by making assumptions about individuals based solely on their racial category.
The Asian American Success Story Destroys the White Privilege Myth
Kirk pointed out a statistical reality that demolishes the white privilege argument: Asian Americans are the wealthiest, most productive, and least likely to commit crimes of any demographic in America. Where is their privilege? Is their privilege based on skin color? Absolutely not. Their success is based on making good choices.
Asian Americans entered the United States mostly in the 1940s and 50s, fleeing communism and Marxism. They came into the American community widely discriminated against. In fact, Kirk noted, if you ask your grandparents or great grandparents what they think of people from Asia, they won't say very nice things. Despite this discrimination, Asian Americans made very good choices. They followed the three things you need to do to stay out of poverty in America according to Ben Shapiro: graduate high school, get a job, and get married before you have kids. Over the last 67 years, they are by far the richest group in America by race.
The Divisive Nature of Racial Categorization
Kirk explained that categorizing people based on skin color is extraordinarily divisive. When you categorize people just based on their skin color, they become nothing more than that racial group. They're not an individual. It's not saying that you could rise above your circumstance or make good choices. It's not saying that you might have been born behind and can get ahead.
Kirk posed a challenging question to illustrate this point: Are Jewish people privileged? Are Jewish people white? The discussion revealed the complexity—Jewish people are technically considered Semites from the Middle East historically, though many identify as white. Kirk asked whether Jewish people really had a privileged 20th century, noting they had an extermination order put up against them across an entire continent.
The point is that if we try to segregate the American populace based on skin color, that is the very definition of everything we have tried to fight against in this country. The white privilege narrative is anti-individual and promotes a racial group collective mentality that is extraordinarily harmful. It creates a victimhood mentality that pits one group against another and does not reward what America truly is—a place where good choices will eventually be rewarded.
The Poverty Statistics That Don't Fit the Narrative
Despite historical and statistical trends, the white privilege narrative just isn't true, Kirk argued. There are twice as many white people living in poverty in America than black people. While black people live in poverty at a higher rate, in aggregate numbers it doesn't reflect a simple white privilege story.
Why African Americans Are Worse Off Today Than in the 1960s
When the audience member asked whether the systematic oppression of the 1960s and before has any effect on African American communities today, Kirk acknowledged that it did have an effect, but then posed a critical question: Didn't the internment camps against Asian Americans in the 1940s have an effect on them? They rose above it.
Kirk asked another essential question: Is America more racist today than we were in the 1960s? The answer is clearly no. America is much less racist in every single metric. Then why are blacks worse off today than they were in the 1960s? It's not because we're a more racist country. It's because we've incentivized bad behavior over the last 60 years.
Black single motherhood was 18% in 1965. It's now 71%. What happened? Did we become a more terribly racist country? No. Did we get more racist laws? No. We actually got rid of most of them with the Civil Rights Act. What happened is that we incentivized really bad behavior. The government said to single mothers: go ahead and have kids and we'll give you a check every single month, but don't get married. As soon as you get married, you lose the check.
The government put African Americans in urban areas and housing projects that incentivized bad behavior. This was the advancement of the American welfare system, probably also coupled with failing public schools run mostly by teacher unions that were not properly incentivized to try to get people out of poverty.
Every Metric Shows Decline, Not Progress
By every single metric, African Americans are worse off today than they were in the 1960s—crime, prison rates, single motherhood, employment, wealth, capital, everything. There's only one possible explanation for that, Kirk argued. It's not that America got more institutionally racist. It's that there was a set of policies put forth by one president and continually supported by an entire political party to keep a whole segment of the population poor and routinely voting Democrat. That's Lyndon Baines Johnson and the American Democrat Party.
The Pattern Across All Ethnic Groups
If you want to talk about systemic oppression and racism, Kirk noted, there are lots of other examples of ethnic groups that went through that too. Almost every single ethnic group except African Americans and Native Americans have risen above historical oppression statistically. The only thing African Americans and Native Americans have in common is absolute total government interference and involvement in their lives.
Kirk's argument is that the white privilege narrative is not just false—it's actively harmful. It promotes racism by categorizing people by skin color, ignores the success of other minorities who faced discrimination, and obscures the real problems facing struggling communities: government policies that incentivize dependency and destructive behavior rather than the values that lead to success.
