Up Next
Trump’s State of the Union: Confrontation and Conservative Triumph
15:14
Victor Davis Hanson Reveals Charlie Kirk's Secret to Mobilizing Young Conservative Voters in America
6:24
Andrew Kolvet and Thought Crime Crew Defend Charlie Kirk Against Postmortem Smears and Context Manipulation
44:09
Related Books
Browse Conservative Books
Matt Walsh Defends Charlie Kirk Against Racism Claims Over DEI Pilot Comments and Merit-Based Hiring
Matt Walsh addresses the controversy surrounding Charlie Kirk's comments about DEI hiring practices in the airline industry. When Kirk expressed concern about whether pilots are hired based on merit or diversity quotas, thousands attacked him as racist, including some conservatives. Walsh argues Kirk simply said out loud what DEI policies clearly imply: when airlines announce intentions to decrease white male pilots and increase minority representation, they're admitting something other than merit factors into hiring decisions. This creates inevitable questions about qualifications that wouldn't exist under purely merit-based systems.
The Controversy That Made Charlie Kirk Trend
Charlie Kirk found himself trending on social media after comments he made on his show about DEI hiring practices in the airline industry sparked widespread accusations of racism. The controversy erupted when Kirk stated that seeing a Black pilot now makes him wonder if they're qualified, attributing this reaction directly to DEI policies rather than personal prejudice. Thousands attacked him online, and what particularly frustrated observers like Matt Walsh was that numerous conservatives joined the pile-on instead of defending someone on their own side.
Walsh questions why conservatives feel compelled to publicly distance themselves from Kirk when thousands are already criticizing him. He argues that adding another voice to an existing chorus of 10,000 critics serves no purpose except virtue signaling. The incident raises broader questions about conservative solidarity and whether public figures should defend allies even when they make controversial statements.
What Charlie Kirk Actually Said
In the original clip, Kirk discussed how United Airlines' DEI story resonates with travelers who have experienced turbulence and felt reassured seeing a competent-looking pilot enter the cockpit. He then made his controversial statement: "I'm sorry if I see a Black pilot I'm going to be like boy I hope he's qualified." He immediately clarified that this reaction wouldn't have existed before DEI policies, stating it's not what he personally believes but rather the reality that left-wing policies have created.
Kirk's point centered on how DEI initiatives have fundamentally changed the assumptions people can make about hiring practices. When airlines explicitly announce goals to change the demographic composition of their workforce, they're acknowledging that factors beyond pure merit are influencing hiring decisions. This creates an environment of uncertainty that didn't previously exist.
The Merit-Based Hiring Argument
Walsh argues that Kirk's comments, while uncomfortable, reflect the logical implications of DEI policies. When airlines announce their intention to increase the number of minority and female pilots while decreasing white male pilots, they're explicitly stating that demographic characteristics are being factored into hiring decisions. This introduction of non-merit factors is the core problem, regardless of whether companies claim to still prioritize qualifications.
The reality, according to Walsh, is that any Black pilot could fall into several categories: someone hired before DEI existed, someone who would have been hired on merit alone even with DEI in place, or someone who received the position partly due to demographic considerations. Because observers cannot determine which category applies, a degree of uncertainty enters the equation that wouldn't exist in a purely merit-based system.
The Unintended Consequences of DEI
One of the ironies Walsh identifies is that DEI policies designed to reduce bias may actually create new forms of bias. When people know that certain demographics are being actively recruited to meet quotas while others face reduced opportunities, they may develop greater confidence in those who succeeded despite facing institutional disadvantages. A white male pilot who obtained his position during an era of explicit DEI policies aimed at reducing white male representation must have been exceptionally qualified to overcome those barriers.
This creates a perverse situation where DEI policies simultaneously harm the groups they're intended to help by casting doubt on their qualifications, while potentially increasing confidence in the very demographic the policies aim to disadvantage. Walsh notes that white males and Asian males in most industries become the only groups whose qualifications aren't questioned, since no programs exist to artificially boost their representation.
Who Bears Responsibility
Walsh places the blame for this situation squarely on DEI policies themselves, not on Charlie Kirk for articulating the obvious implications. He argues that if people find these implications uncomfortable or objectionable, the solution is to eliminate DEI and affirmative action in all forms, not to attack those who point out the logical consequences of such policies.
The way forward, according to Walsh, requires companies to make clear, unequivocal statements about their hiring practices. If United Airlines announced that their sole recruitment goal was to hire 100% of the most qualified people regardless of demographic characteristics, and actually implemented such a policy, the entire controversy would disappear. Without such a change, questions about merit versus diversity hiring will remain legitimate concerns.
The Conservative Solidarity Question
Walsh expresses particular frustration with conservatives who joined in criticizing Kirk. He questions why anyone would feel the need to add their voice to an already massive pile-on, especially against someone who shares their political orientation. Even if someone disagrees with Kirk's approach or phrasing, publicly joining with thousands of critics serves no constructive purpose.
This behavior pattern reflects a broader challenge within conservative circles: the tendency of some to signal their own reasonableness by distancing themselves from controversial figures on their own side. Walsh suggests this approach is both strategically foolish and morally questionable, prioritizing personal reputation over movement solidarity.
Video Transcript
[00:00] okay something a little bit different
[00:00] for wwal WR um only because this is a
[00:04] topic I wanted to cover in the headlines
[00:05] and I ran out of time so I'm just doing
[00:06] it here and it's my show I can do what I
[00:08] want so rather than was Walsh wrong it's
[00:10] a little different this is you know
[00:12] maybe we'll call this was Kirk wrong
[00:13] because Charlie Kirk has been trending
[00:16] with um lots of people attacking him and
[00:18] calling him racist for something that he
[00:20] said on his show this week and uh the
[00:22] thing that annoys me about this is that
[00:25] plenty of conservatives were jumping on
[00:28] the dog pile and calling Kirk a racist
[00:31] as well for this and so let's watch the
[00:34] clip um and we'll find out if Kirk was
[00:38] wrong is he racist let's
[00:41] listen and that's why I think this
[00:43] United story in the Dei story hits so
[00:47] hard because we've all been in the back
[00:49] of a plane when the turbulence hits or
[00:51] when you're flying through a storm and
[00:52] you're like I'm so glad I saw the guy
[00:55] with the right stuff and the square jaw
[00:57] get into the cockpit before we took off
[00:59] and I feel better now think I mean like
[01:01] you want to go thought crime like I'm
[01:02] sorry if I see a black pilot I'm going
[01:05] to be like boy I hope he's qualified
[01:07] well that's the you wouldn't have done
[01:08] that you wouldn't have you wouldn't have
[01:09] done that before that's not an immediate
[01:11] you would who I am that's not what I
[01:14] believe it is the reality the left
[01:17] has okay so uh I know we're supposed to
[01:19] read comments here but I don't think
[01:20] that's necessary whole bunch of comments
[01:22] calling Kirk a racist for that you can
[01:24] imagine fill in the blanks uh like I
[01:26] said plenty of people on the right
[01:28] joining in which always find disgusting
[01:31] uh you know look even if you think he's
[01:33] wrong and he's not but you don't you
[01:36] don't jump on a dog pile against the guy
[01:38] on your own side um why do you even need
[01:42] to you know if there's already 10,000
[01:45] people screaming this is racist he's
[01:47] awful why do you need to chime in like
[01:50] yes I too believe this I also disagree
[01:52] with this I'll never get that you got
[01:55] 10,000 people have already said that
[01:57] they disagree why do you think you need
[01:59] to also no one gives a dam what you
[02:01] think like why why do you why do you
[02:02] also need to just say and I and I as
[02:05] well I yes me
[02:07] too well um and that's rhetorical I know
[02:10] why they feel the need to do it but in
[02:12] any case was Kirk wrong about this uh
[02:14] was he racist no of course not what he
[02:17] said was obviously true the the only
[02:19] thing he's doing different is that he's
[02:21] he's he's saying the words out loud you
[02:24] know he's saying out loud what is the
[02:26] clear implication of Dei which is that
[02:29] since the lines have announced their
[02:30] intention to increase the number of
[02:32] minority and female pilots and decrease
[02:34] the number of white male Pilots that
[02:36] means they are taking something other
[02:38] than Merit and skill into account in the
[02:40] hiring process there is something else
[02:42] there is a even if you want to claim
[02:43] that well but they also are looking for
[02:45] merit and skill um doesn't matter
[02:47] they've brought something else into the
[02:49] picture that has nothing to do with
[02:51] Merit and skill and that is the problem
[02:54] it so it also means that you know if you
[02:57] see a black pilot uh that he he could
[03:02] have he could he obviously easily could
[03:06] be perfectly qualified for the job uh he
[03:08] could be someone who got the job before
[03:10] Dei existed or he could be someone who
[03:12] got the job when Dei existed but but
[03:15] would have gotten it without di I mean
[03:16] all of that is perfectly possible but he
[03:21] could also be someone who got it because
[03:24] he fit the Dei demo so there is that
[03:27] weariness and
[03:28] suspicion that happens because we don't
[03:31] know we don't know balance of nature
[03:34] fruits and veggies are a great way to
[03:35] make sure you're getting essential
[03:37] nutritional ingredients every single day
[03:38] balance of nature uses an advanced cold
[03:40] vacuum process that encapsulates fruits
[03:42] and vegetables into the whole food
[03:44] supplements without sacrificing their
[03:45] natural antioxidants the capsules are
[03:48] completely void of additives fillers
[03:50] extracts synthetics pesticides or added
[03:52] sugar the only thing in balance of
[03:54] Nature's fruits and veggies capsules are
[03:55] well fruits and veggies right now not
[03:57] only will my listeners get 35% off your
[03:59] first order you will now get a free
[04:01] fiber and spice supplement as well
[04:04] balance of Nature's fiber and SP spice
[04:05] supplement is a revolutionary fiber
[04:07] drink with a unique blend of 12 spices
[04:10] and Whole Foods our office loves balance
[04:11] of Nature and they use it every day
[04:13] there's never been an easier way to make
[04:14] sure we're getting our daily dose of
[04:16] fruits and vegetables experience balance
[04:18] of nature for yourself today go to
[04:19] balanceof nature.com use promo code
[04:21] Walsh for 35% off your first order as a
[04:22] preferred customer plus get a free
[04:24] bottle of fiber and spice that's balance
[04:26] ofn nature.com promo code walls for 35%
[04:29] off your first preferred order plus a
[04:31] free bottle of fiber and spice
[04:34] now if you have a white male pilot you
[04:38] know you know that he has the job based
[04:41] on Merit because there is no program
[04:43] there is no policy there is no
[04:45] initiative explicitly trying to increase
[04:47] the number of white males in the
[04:49] industry so he couldn't have gotten a
[04:52] job because of
[04:53] Dei that's one of the ironies here is
[04:56] that that all you know you're doing this
[04:57] because you want to have fewer white
[04:58] male Pilots or whatever but you're
[05:01] you're just making
[05:03] people although you are decreasing the
[05:06] number and you're taking opportunities
[05:08] away from people that are otherwise
[05:09] qualified which is
[05:11] horrible um in a way you're making
[05:14] people like biased in favor even if they
[05:19] won't say it out loud the way that
[05:20] Charlie Kirk did you're making people B
[05:23] biased in favor of white male pilots in
[05:25] a way that they would not have been
[05:27] otherwise but now they are because like
[05:29] well okay they're the only ones who like
[05:32] especially now if they have if they got
[05:34] that job in spite of all the D like
[05:37] you're a white male and these industries
[05:39] are not interested in you and you still
[05:40] got the job well then you must be super
[05:43] good at your job that you still got
[05:45] it um so that's that's what's happening
[05:49] here um and what you might be picking up
[05:52] on is that yes Dei has the side effect
[05:56] of calling into question the skills and
[05:58] competence of everybody in every
[06:01] demographic except white
[06:04] males and also Asians Asian males in in
[06:07] most of these industries too so that's
[06:11] it it's like white males and Asian males
[06:14] in most Industries are the only ones who
[06:16] are not called into question now because
[06:18] of
[06:19] it uh whose fault is that it's not
[06:22] Charlie Kirk's fault it's dei's fault if
[06:25] you don't like it I don't like it well
[06:29] get rid of Dei get rid of affirmative
[06:31] action in every form and then all of
[06:35] this goes away then this is not an issue
[06:38] anymore but if if so if but that's the
[06:42] only
[06:43] way get get rid of any when it comes to
[06:47] hiring and recruiting in any
[06:49] industry what you do is you state
[06:52] outright we don't care about race or
[06:55] gender it doesn't matter to us we're
[06:58] just looking for the best of the best
[07:00] that's all we're looking for you know
[07:02] United could come out and announce our
[07:06] one single goal for recruitment is to
[07:08] have 100% of the most qualified people
[07:12] period and we do not care what they look
[07:15] like United announces that and actually
[07:17] enacts it then great none of this is an
[07:21] issue
[07:24] anymore but if they won't then it
[07:26] remains a live issue thanks for checking
[07:28] out this video If if You' like to listen
[07:29] to my full podcast on the go you can
[07:31] check out the Matt wall show on Apple
[07:33] podcast Spotify or wherever you get your
[07:35] podcasts
Comments
Be the first to comment on this video.