Professor Pride: I'm Breaking Down What Really Happened With Charlie Kirk's Murder and Its Chaotic Fallout

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

The Assassination of Charlie Kirk: How a 22-Year-Old Gunman Cut Short the American Comeback Tour in Utah

The Assassination of Charlie Kirk: How a 22-Year-Old Gunman Cut Short the American Comeback Tour in Utah

9:04

Hunter Kozak Was Debating Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University When the Assassination Happened

Hunter Kozak Was Debating Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University When the Assassination Happened

42:58

Why I Won't Fly My Flag at Half-Mast for Charlie Kirk Despite His Assassination

Why I Won't Fly My Flag at Half-Mast for Charlie Kirk Despite His Assassination

12:03

Professor Pride: I'm Breaking Down What Really Happened With Charlie Kirk's Murder and Its Chaotic Fallout

A week after Charlie Kirk was shot and killed at a Utah event, I'm walking through the claims and counter-claims that have piled up since, starting with why I think security failed him and how an innocent man in Toronto was wrongly named as the shooter online before authorities identified Tyler Robinson, a 22-year-old from Utah. I get into what's known about Robinson's background, his alleged ties to Nick Fuentes' Groyper movement, the messages reportedly etched onto the bullet casings, and how a roommate is credited with turning him in. I also cover the shifting statements from Utah's governor, Donald Trump's comments about political violence on Fox News, and the questions I have about evidence handling at the scene, plus the monetization of Kirk's death through merchandise and fundraisers. I'm upfront that I never agreed with Kirk's politics and don't pretend otherwise here, but my goal in this rundown is to separate what's actually been confirmed from what's been spread online this week without much fact-checking.

Categories: Liberal Opinions
September 17, 2025

A Week of Unequal Outrage

The video opens by noting that Charlie Kirk was shot and killed at an event in Utah, with the creator stating upfront that political violence should be condemned from all sides. The creator argues that Republicans have shown more outrage over this shooting than over other mass shootings or acts of political violence in recent years, and criticizes what they describe as a wave of calls for civil war and easily disproven claims circulating online throughout the week. The creator also pushes back on people who present opposing factual claims about Kirk as simply differing opinions, arguing that describing someone as racist, homophobic, or transphobic based on their own statements isn't a matter of feelings but of documented behavior.

Why Security Failed Charlie Kirk

The creator claims Kirk had been warned months earlier by a hired security consultant that his security setup had major flaws and that he could be killed at an event within six months if he didn't improve his protocols, and that Kirk did not act on that warning. The creator also claims that local police stationed at the event were focused on enforcing Utah's HB77, a law signed by Republican Governor Spencer Cox in May 2025 restricting the display of LGBTQ pride flags on college campuses, rather than monitoring rooftops for threats. The creator further claims a student had spotted someone on the roof hours before the shooting in a video that later went viral, and that the person returned to the roof shortly before the attack without being stopped.

The Wrong Suspect Goes Viral

The creator describes how an account called Libs of TikTok initially claimed a specific man had been arrested and was in FBI custody, when in fact that man was reportedly in Toronto at the time and had no connection to Kirk, forcing him to delete his social media accounts amid the backlash. The creator says the FBI later muddled the record further by stating they had released a suspect from custody who, by the creator's account, had never actually been in custody at all.

Who Tyler Robinson Is Alleged to Be

The creator identifies the eventual suspect as Tyler Robinson, a 22-year-old from Utah raised in what's described as a religious, gun-focused Republican household, who attended college on a full scholarship and lived with roommates in an apartment, one of whom is reportedly transgender, though the creator notes the evidence for that is thin. The creator claims Robinson was connected to a far-right group associated with Nick Fuentes known as the Groypers, describing the group as holding white supremacist, antisemitic, and Holocaust-denying views and as having been linked to the January 6, 2021 Capitol attack. The creator further claims Robinson and others in that movement had targeted Turning Point USA and Kirk specifically for not being far-right enough, and that Robinson had previously donated to Trump's campaigns.

Reading the Bullet Casings

The creator describes messages reportedly inscribed on the bullet casings recovered at the scene: one telling fascists to catch something, another declaring that anyone who reads it is gay, meant as an insult within far-right culture aimed at anyone investigating the case, and a third simply reading Bella Ciao, a reference to an Italian anti-fascist resistance song from World War II. The creator interprets all three as signals aimed at a far-right audience rather than evidence of a left-wing motive, framing them as an attempt to sow confusion and shift blame onto Democrats.

How the Alleged Shooter Was Turned In

The creator says rumors had circulated about a pastor alerting authorities, but claims the FBI has since credited Robinson's roommate, reportedly transgender, with turning him in after his father questioned him about a circulating photo and did not report him himself, reportedly because Robinson threatened self-harm if his father did. The creator argues that whether or not Robinson and the roommate had a romantic relationship is beside the point, since Robinson's alleged motivations traced back to Fuentes' influence regardless, and credits the roommate for the arrest.

A Changing Narrative From Utah's Governor

The creator recounts an initial press conference in which Utah's governor said both major parties had extremists fueling a dangerous political climate and expressed sadness that the suspect turned out to share his own party's affiliation. The creator then claims that after a phone call with President Trump, the governor's public statements shifted, describing Robinson instead as far-left and the roommate as suddenly uncooperative, a shift the creator characterizes as following pressure from Trump rather than new evidence.

Trump's Comments on Political Violence

The creator plays a clip of Trump responding to a question about violence from both the far right and far left, in which Trump says radicals on the right are motivated by concerns over crime and immigration, while describing the radical left in starkly negative terms. The creator also notes Trump told a Fox News host that Robinson had a transgender girlfriend, framing this as an inadvertent acknowledgment of the roommate's gender identity even amid the broader political fallout. Separately, the creator flags Fox News host Brian Kilmeade's on-air comment suggesting involuntary lethal measures for homeless people, noting he later apologized but was not fired.

Questions About Evidence and Monetization

The creator raises concerns about evidence handling at the scene, including fans reportedly taking souvenirs from the speaking area and Kirk's own film crew removing a camera positioned near the stage before authorities could review its footage. The creator also points to Turning Point USA selling merchandise referencing the shooting and more than 100 fundraising campaigns on GoFundMe and GiveSendGo that have collected millions of dollars for Kirk's wife. The creator closes by reiterating disagreement with Kirk's politics and views on political violence broadly, describing him as a terrorist the creator does not care about, while clarifying that not caring about him is not the same as thinking he deserved to die or that his death should be celebrated, and criticizing what they see as a lack of visible grief from Kirk's inner circle in the days after his death.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!