Stephen A. Smith Calls Charlie Kirk's Murder Cold-Blooded in an Interview With Brandon Tatum

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Megyn Kelly Refuses to Condemn Candace Owens Despite Ben Shapiro Calling Her a Coward at AmericaFest

Megyn Kelly Refuses to Condemn Candace Owens Despite Ben Shapiro Calling Her a Coward at AmericaFest

9:24

Brandon Tatum Defends Charlie Kirk Against Pastor Critics Calling Him Racist and White Supremacist

Brandon Tatum Defends Charlie Kirk Against Pastor Critics Calling Him Racist and White Supremacist

15:27

Nate Freedman Confronts College Students About Charlie Kirk Assassination to Expose Campus Attitudes Toward Political Violence

Nate Freedman Confronts College Students About Charlie Kirk Assassination to Expose Campus Attitudes Toward Political Violence

29:02

Stephen A. Smith Calls Charlie Kirk's Murder Cold-Blooded in an Interview With Brandon Tatum

Stephen A. Smith joins Brandon Tatum to talk about Charlie Kirk's assassination, making clear he didn't personally know Kirk but was struck by his willingness to debate anyone openly on college campuses. Smith describes watching footage of the shooting and calls it cold-blooded murder, rejecting any suggestion that Kirk's political views could ever justify the act, and recounts how his own daughters told him they'd rather he be broke and safe than successful and at risk. The conversation widens into a broader discussion of racism in America, with Smith crediting his white grandmother, Carmen Brady, for teaching him to distinguish real racism from using it as an excuse, and explaining why he refuses to let either political party take his support for granted. Smith also opens up about his friendships across ideological lines, from D.L. Hughley to Sean Hannity and Mark Levin.

Categories: Analysis
September 14, 2025

Stephen A. Smith Calls Charlie Kirk's Killing Cold-Blooded Murder

Brandon Tatum opens by noting his own long friendship with Charlie Kirk, dating back to 2017 when the two worked together to bring 400 black leaders to the White House, before asking Stephen A. Smith to share his reaction to Kirk's death.

"I did not know Charlie Kirk at all. I knew the name. I knew the face... I knew that he was incredibly influential. I knew about the college campus tours, his willingness to engage in open and constructive debates with whomever," Smith says.

Smith describes watching footage of the shooting circulate on social media.

"To see the bullet pierce his neck the way that it did, to see him jolt and then his body just collapse and you see the blood gushing out... it was horrific in every sense of the word," Smith says, noting that Kirk's wife and two young children were present.

His Life Was Taken Away, and for What?

Smith rejects any framing that treats Kirk's political views as justification for his death.

"His life was taken away. And for what? Because he may have had a different opinion than yours, whatever that opinion may be," Smith says. "It's cold-blooded murder. That's what happened to him. And that usurps everything." He adds that when people in his private circle have tried to bring up disagreements with Kirk's views as context, he's shut the conversation down outright, saying, "There's no right in that whatsoever. There's you can never sit back and think that cold-blooded murder is a justification."

A Father's Fear: What Stephen A.'s Daughters Told Him

Smith shares a personal moment with his daughters after the shooting.

"They said, 'Daddy, we'd rather be broke. We'd rather be broke knowing that you're safe and sound every day than rich and worried about whether or not something like that could happen to you too,'" Smith says. "It saddened the living hell out of me to hear something like that."

Comparisons to MLK, Malcolm X, and Medgar Evers

Smith notes that some commentators have compared Kirk's death to the assassinations of Martin Luther King Jr., Medgar Evers, and Malcolm X in the 1960s.

"In the end, what it comes down to is that this is not something that should ever be excused. It should be universally condemned," Smith says, adding that Kirk was a pundit and activist rather than an elected official, which he says makes the act no less serious.

Would the Reaction Be Different If the Victim Looked Like Him?

Tatum asks Smith whether the public reaction would differ if a black commentator had been killed under similar circumstances.

"They would say it's racist. That's what they would say," Smith says, before drawing a broader distinction. "There are people who are racist in this world. But there are also people who are not racist. They just don't like your ass... I think that a lot of times, you got people that literally want to do that, and they want to operate with impunity. That's not what a lawful society is supposed to be like."

On Racism, Accountability, and the Black Conservative Movement

Asked whether racism still blocks black success in America, Smith says it depends less on what's directed at someone and more on how they respond to it.

"I think it could get in the way of those things... because it's not just about what the perpetrator is throwing at you. It's about what you're receiving and how you react accordingly," Smith says, explaining why he respects black conservatives even when he disagrees with them. "I believe y'all have been victimized for decades... but I'm not going to let my facts be usurped by emotion."

His Grandmother's Lesson on Racism

Smith credits his white grandmother, Carmen Brady, who was married to his black grandfather in St. Thomas, with teaching him how to recognize real racism.

"Racism by and large evolves around the issue of entitlement: somebody believing they deserve what you have, or more than what you have, even if it's at your expense, just because of their pigmentation," Smith says, recalling her words. "Does that exist in our country? You're damn right it does... but not as prevalent as some people in the black community try to make it out to be."

Why He Doesn't Fight With D.L. Hughley, Sean Hannity, or Mark Levin

Smith explains that his closest cross-ideological friendships, including with D.L. Hughley, Sean Hannity, and Mark Levin, work because of in-person conversation rather than public sparring.

"When you talk to people face to face, it goes a long way, because you're touching one another literally and figuratively, and you're more apt to try to find sense and common ground," Smith says, adding that Hughley is "an intelligent brother" whose passion sometimes overtakes his message in public.

Who Stephen A. Smith Would Vote For

Asked who he'd support if the next presidential election were held today, Smith says he would not vote for JD Vance, citing distrust, and sees no Democrat with a national profile he currently supports, aside from Maryland Governor Wes Moore, who has said he won't run.

"The number one person I will vote for is Marco Rubio," Smith says, praising Rubio's credentials as a former senator and current secretary of state. He also names Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro favorably, while criticizing California Governor Gavin Newsom over the state's unemployment, homelessness, and affordability issues, and criticizing Republican lawmakers he sees as unwilling to work across the aisle.

Comments

Be the first to comment on this video.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!