Tim Miller Confronts Pastor Doug Wilson on Iran War and Political Christianity on Piers Morgan
Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.
Up Next
Tim Dillon and Max Blumenthal Reveal Charlie Kirk's Growing Skepticism Toward Israel and Donor Pressures Before His Death
36:42
Nick Fuentes and Hunter Biden Find Common Ground on Trump, Israel, and America's Future
1:46:06
Tucker Carlson Breaks With Trump Over Iran War and Israel Policy
57:36
Tim Miller Confronts Pastor Doug Wilson on Iran War and Political Christianity on Piers Morgan
Tim Miller from The Bulwark shares extended clips from his appearance on the Piers Morgan show where he debated Pastor Doug Wilson about the Iran war and refused to call Wilson "pastor" due to his political activism. Miller argues that the case for war in Iran is so weak that Morgan's show struggled to find defenders, and critiques Wilson's brand of Christianity as divorced from the teachings of Jesus. The debate covers Trump's conflict with the Pope, J.D. Vance's recent Catholic conversion, and the backlash Trump faces from his own base over a war that has raised gas prices and cost American lives without clear strategic gains.
Tim Miller from The Bulwark introduces extended clips from his appearance on the Piers Morgan show, where he debated Pastor Doug Wilson about the Iran war and various political issues. Miller explains that after a clip went viral of him refusing to call Wilson "pastor," viewers demanded the full debate. While Miller initially questioned whether to subject his audience to what he considered weak arguments from Wilson, he decided to release the extended clips after popular demand, comparing it to "giving an a swirly" even if it wasn't high-brow debate content.
Trump, the Pope, and Catholic Doctrine
When asked about the conflict between Pope Francis and President Trump, Miller, a cradle Catholic, argues that people claiming the Pope crossed a line have no historical memory. He points out that Pope Francis's comments align with previous Popes dating back to Pope John Paul II, who vocally opposed both Iraq wars without George H.W. Bush or George W. Bush picking fights with him. Miller notes that multiple Popes have criticized Democratic leaders on abortion without those leaders telling the Pope to "shut his pie hole."
Miller reserves particular criticism for J.D. Vance, who converted to Catholicism recently and then wrote a book about his conversion, yet now suggests the Pope needs to be careful when speaking about theology. Miller finds it absurd that Vance, who has "been a Catholic for 2 minutes," would presume to know more about Catholic doctrine and just war theory than the Pope. He describes Vance's simultaneous conversion to both Catholicism and MAGA-hood as "very phony and very fake," suggesting it isn't helping either Vance or Trump politically.
The Incoherent Case for War
Miller argues that the most telling aspect of appearing on Morgan's show, which attempts to present both sides for debate, is how difficult it has become to find people willing to defend the Iran war. He characterizes this difficulty as revealing the fundamental weakness of the case for military action. Miller notes that Trump's recent statement denying that Israel talked him into the war is "a lady doth protest too much moment," given that Benjamin Netanyahu sat in the White House Situation Room making the case for war just weeks before it began.
Miller emphasizes that he's not suggesting a "secret cabal of Jews" manipulating Trump, but simply stating the observable reality: Netanyahu made his case, and weeks later, the war started. He argues there's no reason to believe Trump would have pursued this war alone if Israel hadn't been agitating for it, especially given Trump and Vance's own previous statements against such action.
The Balance Sheet of Failure
Miller presents a devastating accounting of what the war has achieved versus its costs. He asks viewers to imagine if, eight weeks ago, someone had pitched the following scenario: the Strait of Hormuz would be closed, energy prices would rise for everyone, critical energy infrastructure in Arab states would be taken offline, the UAE would need to ask for loans, over a dozen Americans would be dead with unknown numbers wounded, Iranian civilians including schoolchildren would be accidentally killed, and military material would be depleted.
In exchange for all that, Miller notes, the U.S. has merely moved "from one hominid to another," the IRGC is actually in more control, and Iran has lost some ships and missile capabilities. He argues that if this deal had been pitched to the American people eight weeks ago, only about 3% would have supported it—perhaps only the strongest Israel hawks. The administration had claimed the war would be over in two to three weeks, but six weeks later, things have only gotten worse.
Refusing to Call Wilson "Pastor"
When Wilson mentions he's been "a quote-unquote pastor for just shy of 50 years" and asks how much longer until he becomes a "real pastor," Miller responds bluntly: "Well, you have to follow the teachings of Jesus Christ, probably, if you want to be a real pastor." Miller explains he's tired of Wilson being called pastor and will simply call him Doug, stating that Wilson spreads hate against black people, gay people, immigrants, and Jews.
Miller acknowledges he hasn't read Wilson's book and is "very happy to have not read" it, arguing that Wilson's social media material doesn't require further study as there isn't "a ton of deep thought" behind it. When Wilson protests about attacking religious leaders, Miller draws a distinction: "I have no problem attacking wolves in sheep's clothing." He specifically criticizes Wilson for writing that American slavery was "mutually harmonious" between slave masters and slaves, for wanting to do away with the 19th Amendment that gave women the right to vote, and for being the religious leader of Pete Hegseth, whom Miller calls a "cosplay crusader" whose leadership as Secretary of Defense is getting Americans and innocent civilians killed.
Two Visions of Christianity
Miller contrasts Wilson's version of Christianity with what he learned at his all-boy Jesuit Catholic high school—a Jesus who took care of the sick and poor, welcomed immigrants and the marginalized, and helped them. He accuses Wilson of using Jesus as "a mascot" for "white Christian supremacy, your cruelty, your misogyny." Miller expresses satisfaction that people are "finally waking up" to what he sees as Wilson's cruelty and the incompetence of his "star disciple" Pete Hegseth, who Miller claims "does not read the Bible and quotes Pulp Fiction."
Wilson's response—"Jesus was not a socialist because he could actually feed people"—prompts laughter and demonstrates what Miller considers the weakness of Wilson's position. Miller notes that Morgan probably would have preferred to have Michael Knowles defend the war position instead, but suggests Knowles didn't want to appear because the war is "so stupid."
Why the Bullying Isn't Working Anymore
Miller explains Trump's recent attacks on supporters like Riley Gaines as a function of Trump doing things that have caused backlash among his own voters and are negatively impacting their lives. He traces the beginning of the backlash to the Epstein files cover-up, which upset people even though it didn't affect them personally. But the Iran war represents a different level of impact—voters are experiencing real financial harm through higher gas prices without understanding why.
Miller argues that Trump's historical bullying tactics worked because his base was always with him in those fights. That dynamic has changed because Trump didn't make the case for this war to anyone, including his own voters. Many voted for him believing he would avoid "dumb Middle East wars" because that's what he told them. Now they're paying more at the gas pump and receiving a nonsensical explanation about degrading Iran's ship numbers.
The result is that Trump's usual bullying strategy has lost its effectiveness. In the past, when Trump attacked Republicans who stepped out of line, they backed down because their voters sided with Trump. That's not happening now because "people are pissed because the war is stupid, he didn't make a case for it, and they're being harmed." Miller notes the irony that even George W. Bush knew a war in Iran would be disastrous and a quagmire, yet Trump is stuck in one eight weeks in, unable to get out but doubling down due to his ego.
Strange Bedfellows in Opposition
Miller acknowledges the unusual coalition forming against the war, noting how opponents are appealing to authorities like Nick Fuentes, Candace Owens, and Alex Jones. He admits the war is so obviously misguided that he and Candace Owens "finally agree on something," joking that while he doesn't believe her conspiracy theory about the first lady of France, they're "on the same page" about the war being dumb. Miller states that 80% of Americans are opposed, representing an unusual fusion of people who would never normally agree on anything.
