Charlie Kirk Confronts Liberal Student on Hypocrisy Claims About Trump and Disabled People at ISU

Enjoying this? Share it with someone who needs to see it.

Up Next

Charlie Kirk on Strong Men, Western Civilization, and Why the Left's Cultural Revolution Failed

Charlie Kirk on Strong Men, Western Civilization, and Why the Left's Cultural Revolution Failed

1:38:11

Charlie Kirk Defends Trump at Oxford Union Debate: Has the President Gone Too Far?

Charlie Kirk Defends Trump at Oxford Union Debate: Has the President Gone Too Far?

50:38

Charlie Kirk Confronts Identity Politics: Merit and Character Over Skin Color Organization

Charlie Kirk Confronts Identity Politics: Merit and Character Over Skin Color Organization

0:41

Charlie Kirk banner
2,387 videos 1,376,944,188 views US Joined Aug 30, 2018

Charlie Kirk is the Founder and President of Turning Point USA, the largest and fastest growing conservative youth activist organization in the country with over 250,000 student members, over 150 full-time staff, and a presence on over 2,000 high school and college campuses nationwide. Charlie is also the Chairman of Students for Trump, which aims to activate one million new college voters on campuses in battleground states in the lead up to the 2020 presidential election. His social media reaches over 100 million people per month and according to Axios, he is one of the "top 10 most engaged" Twitter handles in the world. He is also the host of “The Charlie Kirk Show,” which regularly ranks among the top news shows on Apple podcast charts.

Charlie Kirk Confronts Liberal Student on Hypocrisy Claims About Trump and Disabled People at ISU

Charlie Kirk faces a self-described liberal student at Illinois State University who accuses him of applying double standards when it comes to mocking disabled individuals. The student questions why Kirk condemned Congresswoman Jasmine Crockett for calling Governor Abbott "Governor Hot Wheels" but never criticized Donald Trump for allegedly mocking a disabled reporter or Elon Musk for using offensive language. What follows is a direct exchange about political hypocrisy, state governance, and whether conservative policies actually reflect what Americans want. The conversation shifts from accusations about Trump's behavior to a debate about why millions are leaving Democrat-run states like Illinois and California for Republican-run states like Texas and Florida.

Categories: Debates
April 9, 2025

A Liberal Student Opens With Strong Accusations

At Illinois State University, Charlie Kirk welcomed a self-described liberal student to the microphone who wasted no time addressing what he saw as blatant hypocrisy. The student explained that while he spent considerable time studying conservative and Republican values, they simply weren't for him. However, his major grievance wasn't with the ideology itself but with what he perceived as contradictions in how Kirk applies his principles.

The student pointed to a specific incident where Congresswoman Jasmine Crockett called Governor Abbott "Governor Hot Wheels," referencing his wheelchair use. Kirk had responded on X by calling her "trash." The student agreed the comment was inappropriate but argued Kirk never applied the same standard to Donald Trump when he allegedly mocked disabled reporter Serge Kovaleski in 2015, flailing his arms and imitating his voice and movements. The student also noted that Elon Musk, whom Kirk praises frequently, used what he described as "the R-word" over 14 times in 2024 alone, including on the morning of this event.

"I want to know why you hold the left and Democrats to different standards than you do the right and Republicans," the student challenged.

Kirk Disputes the Premise About Trump Mocking Reporters

Kirk began by clarifying that he worships Jesus Christ, not Trump or any political figure, before addressing the substance of the accusations. He flatly rejected the claim that Trump mocked the New York Times reporter, stating it has been "disproven like 10 times" and that even the reporter himself said Trump didn't mock him.

Kirk then reframed the Jasmine Crockett incident: "A tree fell on this guy while he was going for a jog and now he's in a wheelchair and she makes fun of that. I think that's trashy behavior." The student agreed it was wrong but insisted the Trump incident was captured on video and covered by every major news outlet.

Kirk dismissed this as a "decade-old hoax" and challenged the student to bring up something more recent than an event from 2015 when the student was nine years old.

The Debate Shifts to Joe Biden's Mental Fitness

The student pivoted to more recent examples, mentioning that Trump frequently mocked Joe Biden's stutter on Truth Social. He noted that Biden has had a stutter his entire life and questioned whether it was appropriate to mock someone for not being mentally present.

Kirk pushed back hard on this characterization. He argued that Trump never made fun of Biden's stutter but rather pointed out that Biden was not mentally capable of serving as president—a fact the country was allegedly lied to about for four years. Kirk described moments where Biden appeared confused about which door to walk through, where tape had to be placed on the ground to guide him, and where he read stage directions off the teleprompter saying "Thank you very much. Stop speaking."

"It was a tragedy for America that we elected a quasi-brain-dead individual to be president of the United States," Kirk stated, emphasizing that the criticism wasn't about mocking a disability but about questioning who was actually running the country and signing executive orders.

Testing the Student's Understanding of Conservative Values

Kirk then turned the tables, asking the student—who claimed to have studied Republican and conservative values extensively—to explain what conservatives actually believe. The student responded that Republicans want to limit government spending, run the government like a business to make profit, and emphasize religious traditional values. He also mentioned modern Republicans focusing on "man versus woman, abortion is bad, all that stuff."

Kirk acknowledged these points but then posed a different kind of test: If the student had to identify the best-run state in America that aligns with liberal values, which would it be? The student said he was perfectly content in Illinois and appreciated things like the $15 minimum wage.

The Migration Argument: People Voting With Their Feet

Kirk saw an opening and pressed the issue. If Illinois is so well-run, why does it keep losing population? He cited census data showing Illinois lost well over a million people in the last decade, with someone leaving the state every 9 and a half minutes.

The student countered that it's Republicans leaving Democrat states, so how can you judge a Democrat state based on Republicans not liking it? Kirk responded that the trend existed regardless of party and had been ongoing even during Republican Governor Bruce Rauner's tenure. More importantly, the pattern wasn't limited to Illinois—California, New York, and New Jersey were all experiencing net population losses while Arizona, Texas, and Florida saw massive increases.

"Why is that?" Kirk asked. "Maybe people are voting with their feet because states like Illinois and California and New York are so terribly run with high taxes and bloated pension systems and radical left-wing ideas."

Kirk argued that the concrete reality—millions moving to conservative states and away from liberal ones—demonstrates that the conservative worldview is more popular and therefore closer to reality.

The Popular Vote and Tax Policy Discussion

The student countered that he wouldn't call the conservative worldview more popular since Trump didn't win a majority of votes in the popular vote. Kirk clarified that Trump did win the popular vote but with less than 50%, which is a plurality, not a majority. He noted that winning an actual majority of the popular vote is incredibly unusual in American elections—most presidents win with a plurality.

Kirk then asked what the student thought conservatives got right. The student immediately answered: taxes. He understood the conservative position on taxation but believed the wrong people were being taxed, advocating for taxing "the rich," specifically the top 1%.

Kirk challenged this by asking what would happen if the 1% were taxed to such an extent that they simply left—who would build businesses and companies? The student answered: small business owners. Kirk pointed out the irony, noting that a large portion of the 1% are actually small business owners themselves. "You need both capital and labor," Kirk explained.

A Respectful Conclusion

Despite the contentious exchange, Kirk ended on an encouraging note, urging the student to keep studying, keep asking questions, and to ask people in the audience why they believe what they believe. He left the student with a final challenge to think more deeply over the coming days, weeks, and years about why people are fleeing Democrat-run states for Republican ones if Democrat policies are truly superior.

The student politely asked if he could have a hat as a souvenir, and Kirk obliged, noting the student's politeness throughout the exchange.

Video Transcript

Link copied to clipboard!