Up Next
Destiny Dismantles Conservative Twitter Files Narratives and Republican Conspiracy Theory Problem
18:32
Tim Miller Confronts Pastor Doug Wilson on Iran War and Political Christianity on Piers Morgan
17:01
Candace Owens and Ana Kasparian Unite Against Elite Control, War Propaganda, and Zionist Intimidation Tactics
1:25:29
The Republican Jewish Coalition's Shifting Tone on Israel Critics
The Republican Jewish Coalition held a gala that revealed significant anxiety about the future of pro-Israel sentiment within the conservative movement. Six months earlier at their November gala, Senator Ted Cruz expressed alarm, claiming he had "seen more anti-Semitism on the right than I had in my entire life." Without naming names directly, Cruz took shots at Candace Owens, Nick Fuentes, and Tucker Carlson, with whom he had just had a contentious interview where he struggled to explain his unwavering support for a foreign country.
When the same group reconvened on Sunday, they struck a different tone. Possibly emboldened by a series of primary election victories, including the ousting of Thomas Massie, the resignation of Marjorie Taylor Greene who had been a vocal Israel critic, and Joe Kent leaving the White House, the RJC appeared more confident. Matt Brooks, CEO of the Republican Jewish Coalition, stated: "We have been strong and vocal in confronting the poisonous anti-Semitism and anti-Israel rhetoric coming from people like Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens, and Nick Fuentes."
Conflating Anti-Zionism With Anti-Semitism
Brooks continued: "Whether it comes from the far left or the far right, whether it's wrapped in America first language or dressed up as social commentary, anti-Semitism is anti-Semitism." However, this statement conflates criticism of Israel with hatred of Jewish people. Anti-Semitism occurs when you hate a group of Jewish people because they're Jewish, when you discriminate against them, when you're okay with people harming them based on their ethnicity, race, or immutable characteristics.
Zionism, by contrast, is a political belief. No one is born a Zionist. People adopt Zionist ideology, but they're not born with it. This distinction matters because it means criticism of Israeli policy or Zionist ideology does not automatically constitute hatred of Jewish people. Just because Israel insists on calling itself a Jewish state and building an ethno-state doesn't mean all Jews are implicated in that project or that all Jewish people buy into Zionist ideology.
The RJC Celebrates Its Political Victories
After attacking Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson, Brooks went on to applaud the Republican Party's handling of Israel's detractors: "Anti-Israel in today's Republican Party is not, unlike in the Democratic Party, a path to success." Brooks also bragged to applause about the RJC spending $5 million in the race against Thomas Massie, describing the experience as "a fight worth having and a victory worth celebrating."
This boasting contradicts claims by some pro-Israel activists who insist the Israel lobby plays no role in American elections. The direct admission of spending $5 million to defeat a sitting congressman reveals the significant influence wielded by pro-Israel organizations in shaping the Republican Party.
Concerns That Israel Critics Haven't Been Sufficiently Purged
Some on the right worry that Israel's critics haven't been sufficiently purged from the Republican Party, and they specifically cite Tucker Carlson. Carlson has been seen as one of Israel's most prominent critics on the right, and he has been very vocal about his concerns regarding American foreign policy toward Israel. He experienced an uptick in popularity because the American people appreciate truth tellers and can usually identify inauthenticity.
Oren Siegel, the ADL's vice president of extremism and intelligence, said in an interview with JTA that his organization's biggest worry regarding Carlson is not merely his relationship with conservative elected officials, but the normalization of his views. However, this perspective misses the point entirely. Tucker Carlson did not normalize these views—Israel's behavior normalized these views.
Israel's Actions Drive American Public Opinion
People are not sitting around waiting to hear what Tucker Carlson tells them to think. The American people have viewed endless videos of Israel's military campaigns in sovereign countries and in Palestinian territory. Israel's behavior has normalized the perspective that many Americans now share regarding Israeli policy. Pattern recognition is real, and the pattern many have recognized is that the Israeli government engages in actions that don't value human life unless it involves other Zionist Jews—not Jews generally, just Zionist Jews.
Zionists want to have it both ways. They want to engage in whatever military actions they choose, including what many view as endless suffering and slaughter carried out by the IDF, and on top of that, they expect everyone to sit around and talk about how great Israel is without any criticism. Most Americans don't play that game because they value free expression.
Has Tucker Carlson's Influence Really Waned?
Some argue that Tucker's influence within the right has begun to decline. Randy Fine, a Florida congressman, reminded the audience at the RJC event that in his speech in November, he called Carlson "the most dangerous anti-Semite in America." Fine now claims that title belongs to Amin Mamdani, New York City's anti-Zionist mayor. Fine stated: "I think that brand has been destroyed in the last six months," attributing the change to politicians like himself calling Carlson out, as well as damage Carlson has supposedly done to himself.
However, Fine's assessment could be way off. Despite expressing no serious interest initially, Tucker Carlson has floated the possibility of running for president in 2028. During an interview with Russian television, Candace Owens said she would support him if he threw his name in the hat: "I would love for him to run. I would gratefully get behind someone like Tucker Carlson."
The 2028 Presidential Question and American Sovereignty
If Tucker decided to run, he would have to contend with serious opposition from the RJC. As CEO Matt Brooks stated: "There's only one party where American Jews can be proudly pro-Israel, and that is the Republican Party. And those who imperil that will have to come through the RJC first."
This raises a fundamental question for American voters: Do you want to live in a sovereign country or not? Do you want elected representatives, lawmakers, and presidents who consistently side with Israel and its interests at the detriment of the American people? For many Americans, this has become a defining issue—one that might justify being a single-issue voter for the first time.
Both Parties Remain Largely Pro-Israel
Currently, there isn't a single party where you can safely be anti-Israel. The Democrats aren't as committed to Israel as the Republicans are, at least rhetorically, but through their actions, they remain largely aligned with Israeli interests. You can name only a handful of Democrats who would push back against Israel's demands: Ro Khanna, Rashida Tlaib, and Ilhan Omar are among the few. The pickings are slim on both sides of the aisle.
The Counterproductive Nature of Pro-Israel Advocacy
The irony is that pro-Israel organizations don't seem to realize how their actions run counter to their stated goals. They want Americans to love Israel, but all of their behavior—including pushing aggressively to censor Americans who are critical of Israel—makes Americans dislike Israel more. They're too committed to their current strategy to realize it's backfiring, and they keep doing it. For those who would prefer America to act as a truly sovereign country, ideally one with no special relationship with Israel whatsoever, this continued overreach may ultimately serve their purposes by waking more Americans up to the issue.
Video Transcript
[00:01] : are having a
[00:02] tough time deciding whether or not Tucker Carlson poses a threat. In fact, some of
[00:08] them are concerned that the former Fox News host is considering a presidential run in 2028. And
[00:14] he does have a significant amount of popularity among conservative voters. So if that does happen,
[00:20] he wouldn't be a formidable opponent to any pro-Israel candidate. Nonetheless,
[00:28] I do want to talk a little bit about what's going on behind the scenes because at the Republican
[00:32] Jewish Coalition Gala last November, so this is like about six months ago, seven months ago,
[00:38] there was a palpable concern, a complete panic over anti-Semitism erupting from within the right
[00:46] wing in America. And Senator Ted Cruz at the time said the following, in the last six months, I've
[00:52] seen more anti-Semitism on the right than I had in my entire life. That's hilarious and I don't
[00:59] believe it. But nonetheless, without naming any names directly, Cruz then took shots at Candace
[01:06] Owens, Nick Fuentes, Tucker Carlson, with whom he had just had a pretty contentious and embarrassing
[01:13] debate with. That was the now notorious interview with Tucker Carlson where Ted Cruz had a hard time
[01:21] answering questions about his unwavering support for a foreign country. Now Cruz rounded out his
[01:28] complaints by saying this, and as for me, I choose to stand with you, I choose to stand with Israel,
[01:33] and I choose to stand with America. But when the same group reconvened just this past weekend on
[01:40] Sunday, they struck a different tone, which I found fascinating. They might be emboldened
[01:46] by a series of eight pack victories recently in various elections, primary elections, of course,
[01:53] that included the ousting of Thomas Massey. You also had the resignation of Marjorie Taylor
[01:58] Greene, who was a pretty vociferous Israel critic toward the end of her congressional
[02:04] career. And then you have Joe Kent leaving the White House, resigning, which I don't think the
[02:11] Israel lobby had much to do with, but I'm sure they're very, very happy with that. Nonetheless,
[02:16] uh here's the CEO of the Republican Jewish Coalition. His name is Matt Brooks, and here's
[02:22] what he had to say just this past weekend. We have been strong and vocal in confronting the poisonous
[02:28] anti-Semitism and anti-Israel rhetoric coming from people like Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens, and
[02:34] Nick Fuentes. Whether it comes from the far left or the far right, whether it's wrapped in America
[02:42] first language or dressed up as social commentary, anti-Semitism is anti-Semitism. Anti-Semitism is
[02:51] when you hate a group of Jewish people because they're Jewish. When you discriminate against
[02:58] them, when you are okay with people harming them, whatever. It's when you are targeting a group of
[03:06] people, based on their ethnicity, based on their race, based on their immutable characteristics.
[03:12] Zionism is a political belief. No one is born a Zionist. People are brainwashed into being
[03:20] Zionists, but they're not born to be Zionists. Just keep that in mind. After throwing shade
[03:27] at Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson, he also went on to applaud the Republican Party on its
[03:32] handling of Israel's detractors. Take a listen. Anti-Israel in today's Republican Party is not,
[03:40] unlike in the Democratic Party, a path to success. ah It needs to be though. It needs to be. So the
[03:48] American people have a decision to make here. And I do think it makes sense to, for the first time,
[03:53] be a single issue voter. Do you want to live in a sovereign country or not? Do you want our elected
[03:59] representatives, our lawmakers, our president? consistently side with Israel and its interests at
[04:08] the detriment of the American people. But it's a simple question. I don't give a damn about Israel,
[04:14] just like, do I care about other countries? Sure, but not as much as I care about my own. And I do
[04:25] hate Israel, how could you not? Especially as an American, especially as someone who has carried
[04:32] the brunt what Israel does in the Middle East, whether you're Palestinian, whether you're an
[04:38] Iranian, Lebanese, Syria, Syrian. mean, it's just the list goes on, Iraq, the list goes on
[04:46] and on and on and on. So yeah, a lot of people hate Israel, that doesn't mean they hate Jewish
[04:50] people. Just because you insist on calling it a Jewish state, just because you insist on trying
[04:55] to build an ethno state, doesn't mean that all Jews are implicated in that. it doesn't mean that
[05:03] all Jewish people buy into the Zionist slop that clowns at this conference have bought into. Hating
[05:11] Israel is not the same as being an anti-Semite. So Brooks also bragged to raucous applause about the
[05:24] RJC spending $5 million in the race against Thomas Massey. But don't tell Shabbos Kestenbaum that,
[05:32] right? Because Shabbos would have you believe that the Israel lobby had no role, had no role at all,
[05:39] at all, right? And then you hear Brooks bragging about it. He described the experience into the
[05:45] race as a right a worth having and a victory worth celebrating. And a right worth having meaning
[05:52] right wing politicians who get down on their knees and pleasure Israel. That's the right that he's
[05:57] talking about. uh But some on the right are not as convinced and in fact, some are worried that
[06:05] Israel's critics haven't been sufficiently purged from the Republican Party and they specifically
[06:11] cite Tucker Carlson. So Carlson has been seen as one of Israel's most I think that's a fair label.
[06:20] He has been very vocal for good reason. I agree with a lot of what he has to say about Israel
[06:24] these days. And he did experience an uptick in popularity because guess what? The American people
[06:29] like truth tellers and they can usually suss out inauthenticity. In the case of Donald Carlson,
[06:34] he's pretty authentic when he's talking about Israel. Others argue that, so I'll give you an
[06:39] example of some of the people speaking out. Or in Siegel, the ADL's vice president of extremism and
[06:47] intelligence. Let's all pause for laughter. There's nothing more extreme in the country
[06:50] right now than Zionists. He said in an interview with JTA that his organization's biggest worry
[06:56] regarding Carlson is not merely his relationship with any conservative or elected officials,
[07:01] but also the normalization of his views. The other night I was scrolling through shop TYT when I saw
[07:07] our awesome No Money for Wars hat and thought I need that. I click add to cart ready to dig out
[07:13] my wallet. That's on the other side of the room. But right there in checkout glowing like a beacon
[07:19] is that glorious purple shop a button one tap and boom order place. That's the magic of Shopify the
[07:25] platform behind millions of businesses and 10 % of US e-commerce including our own shop TYT.
[07:32] That purple shop pay button is the best converting checkout on the. planet. It means fewer abandoned
[07:37] carts and more actual sales. If you run a business, Shopify makes it super simple to
[07:42] build a beautiful site with hundreds of templates and a blast email and social campaigns wherever
[07:47] your customers are scrolling. It's like having a full marketing team behind you. So do what we did,
[07:52] use Shopify. See fewer carts go abandoned and more sales go with Shopify and their shop pay
[07:59] button. Sign up for your $1 per month trial today at Shopify.com slash tyt. Go to Shopify.com slash
[08:08] tyt. That's Shopify.com slash tyt. Okay, let me be clear. Tucker Carlson did not normalize these
[08:15] views. Israel's behavior normalized these views. You think people are sitting around waiting to
[08:22] hear what Tucker Carlson tells them to think? Or could it be that the American people have viewed
[08:28] endless videos of Israel's slaughter campaigns in sovereign countries or in Palestinian territory.
[08:38] Israel's behavior has normalized the perspective that people like me share on the show almost on a
[08:46] daily basis at this point in regard to Israel. Just stop slaughtering kids, stop killing
[08:52] innocent, stop trying to steal land. It's not that hard, but they can't help themselves. So if you're
[08:57] going to do that, then you're going to have to deal with the criticism. But here's the thing,
[09:01] Zionists want their cake and eat it too. They want to do whatever they want. Endless suffering
[09:07] carried out by the IDF, endless slaughter carried out by the IDF. And that's not good enough. On top
[09:14] of that, we all have to sit around and talk about how great Israel is and never criticize them,
[09:19] no. No, I don't play that game. And most Americans don't, we like to express ourselves. So
[09:26] um pattern recognition is real. And the pattern I've recognized is that the Israeli government is
[09:34] full of war criminals, bloodthirsty, greedy, and doesn't value human life. Unless we're talking
[09:42] about other Zionist Jews, not Jews, just Zionist Jews. So, others argue that Tucker's influence
[09:52] within the right has begun to wane. look, Randy Fine, who's a disgraceful, disgusting hog of
[09:59] a congressman said, reminded the audience at the RJC event held in Manhattan on Sunday that in his
[10:06] speech to the RJC in November, he called Carlson the most dangerous anti-Semite in America. Now he
[10:13] said, I don't know that that's true anymore. Now Fine has a different person in his crosshairs.
[10:21] He now believes the country's most dangerous anti-Semites are on Mamdani, New York City's
[10:26] anti-Zionist mayor. In contrast, he said Carlson's impact had only plummeted in the past half year.
[10:33] Quote, think that brand has been destroyed in the last six months, he wrote, attributing the
[10:39] change to politicians like himself calling Carlson out, as well as the damage he has done to himself.
[10:47] whatever you need to tell yourself to feel better. But Fiennes' assessment could be way off. In fact,
[10:52] I think it is way off because despite expressing no interest, Tucker Carlson has
[10:56] floated the possibility of running for president in 2028. look, during an interview with Russian
[11:06] television just last week, Candace Owens uh said that she would support him if he threw his name
[11:12] in the hat. He says, I would love for him to run, would- gratefully get behind someone like Tucker
[11:18] Carlson. he showed, look, polymarket is not a good indicator of what's actually going on. So
[11:26] I'm not even gonna go to that. I thought about it. There was a polymarket uh story about how a bunch
[11:32] of people in this betting market are betting that he will secure a victory in the 2028 presidential
[11:39] campaign, or primary, I should say. Still if Tucker decided to run, he has to contend with
[11:44] serious turtles, as the RJC CEO Matt Brooks said. There's only one party where American Jews can be
[11:52] proudly pro-Israel, and that is the Republican Party. And those who imperil that will have to
[11:57] come through the RJC first. Well, I hope we all get to experience and witness that fight. I don't
[12:05] know if we will. I don't know if Tucker Carlson is going to run in 2028. I'm sorry, we don't have a
[12:14] single party where you can safely be anti-Israel. The Democrats aren't as cucked as the Republicans
[12:21] are, at least rhetorically speaking, but they're pretty cucked through their actions, aren't they?
[12:27] I mean, you can name a handful of Democrats who would go against Israel and everything
[12:35] Israel desires. I don't even know if I can name a handful, I know Ro Khanna is one of them. I know
[12:42] that Rashida Tlaib is another one, Ilhan Omar is another one. I'm supposed to pretend that
[12:46] AOC would push back against Israel aggressively. I don't believe it, but okay, slim pickings, right?
[12:55] So. I just, I don't think these people realize how delusional they are. I don't
[13:04] think they realize that everything they do runs counter to what their agenda is. They
[13:11] want Americans to love Israel, but all of their actions, all of their behavior,
[13:14] including pushing pretty aggressively to censor Americans who are critical of Israel,
[13:19] makes Americans hate Israel more. But they're too dumb to realize it and they keep doing it.
[13:25] And honestly, for my purposes, I think that's great, keep doing it. because I'd love to live
[13:31] in a sovereign country. Ideally one that has no relationship with Israel whatsoever. uh
Comments
Be the first to comment on this video.